5 ms·
Can we go electric before it's too late?
- beat 8y ago"Catastrophic climate change" is no longer my primary concern here. I don't think we're going to avoid that. My big concern now is Peak Oil. If major producers like Saudi Arabia and Iran peak and start petering out, then demand will quickly outstrip supply, before widespread electric vehicles are viable in the market. What happens to the world if the price of gasoline spikes 50-100% in a mere year or two?
- gpm 8y agoWhy do you believe that we are that near peak oil?
- beat 8y agoBecause I can read.
- rootusrootus 8y ago> What happens to the world if the price of gasoline spikes 50-100% in a mere year or two? An uptick in EV sales, I'd guess. Gasoline was about 55% more expensive less than a decade ago, recall. We survived. I don't think it would get all that interesting until gasoline gets around $10 or more per gallon in today's prices.
- noir_lord 8y agoIt's around $7 per gallon in the UK already. The net result is on average we drive smaller cars with more efficient engines.
- beat 8y agoThere are serious limits to the scalability of that solution. We can't all just sell the cars we have and buy something 25% better every year. And frankly, we've squeezed most of the efficiency we're going to get out of internal combustion already.
- noir_lord 8y ago> And frankly, we've squeezed most of the efficiency we're going to get out of internal combustion already. If we stick to large engines we need to push honking great SUV's around maybe, modern 3 door's (like the Citigo) are pushing 60+ mpg average in the is something like 25.
- rootusrootus 8y agoWe're already there for anyone who wants it. A Prius gets essentially the same gas mileage as the Citigo while also being more appropriately sized for American tasets.
- beat 8y agoTo my point, your solution is not better cars, but rather smaller cars. That's incrementalism, and it won't go far. Feel-good snark about the American love of big cars won't solve the problem at all.
- daxfohl 8y agoWe are forced to drive and consume less, avoiding climate change extinction? Sounds like a thing to hope for rather than a concern.
- theandrewbailey 8y agoI'm highly skeptical that peak oil will happen from lack of supply. I'm betting it will happen from lack of demand. Petroleum extracting technology gets better, and is always increasing viable reserves of existing oil fields.
- brixon 8y agoThere are still very large oil fields up north, but they are a bit too expensive to extract right now. If gas prices go up enough then they can start getting oil from there.
- beat 8y agoThat's what I'm hoping will happen - that EVs will lead to a big drop in demand before Peak Oil leads to a drop in supply. But hope is not a strategy.
- gwbas1c 8y agoIt won't, because at that price point it's cost-effective to manufacture gasoline using algae or other biological techniques. the only reason why we pump oil out of the ground is because it's the cheapest way to manufacture gasoline and diesel fuel.
- noobermin 8y ago>"Catastrophic climate change" is no longer my primary concern here. I don't think we're going to avoid that. I don't know about you, but I will live to see a destroyed climate. We should do everything in our power to soften its blow when it comes.
- vpribish 8y agoyeah - I mean no matter how bad is is, it can always be worse! There's a sort of nihilistic worldview implied by these statements from usually-smart, usually-young folks that I don't think they actually believe. it's just an intellectual tantrum, i think.
- vpribish 8y agopeak oil is not worth worrying about. I've studied this for investment projects and the whole idea is just a perpetual, simplistic, political meme that has existed since the oil industry started a century and a half ago. Oil might get more expensive than it is now, but that will lead rapidly to renewed investment in exploration and extraction. There are centuries-worth of reasonably-extractable oil - supply will literally never be a problem because we will have to leave that oil, and the coal, unburned for atmospheric chemistry reasons. peak oil consumption is a policy choice, peak oil supply is a myth.
- gwbas1c 8y agoWhat most of us forget is that we can manufacture gasoline and diesel fuel in carbon neutral ways. (From algae or other plant-based materials.) It's just currently much more expensive than pumping oil from the ground. So, we don't need massive adoption of electric cars to solve the problem. We can also figure out how to manufacture conventional fuels in environmentally friendly ways.
- jamespetercook 8y agoIsn’t the issue to do with consumption of gasoline rather than production? Burning carbon based fuels releases large amounts of carbon, no matter how you’ve produced it
- eigenvector 8y agoExtracting and burning fossil fuels release carbon that is already stored in the Earth, while biofuels capture carbon from the atmosphere when the feedstock is grown then release it when the resulting fuel is burned. That is why biofuels are considered to be carbon-neutral.
- gwbas1c 8y agoWhen you produce fuels by biological means, the carbon in those fuels is captured from the atmosphere. Thus biological fuels are carbon neutral. No new carbon is added. (For the same reason, if you heat your home with wood, the only new carbon comes from the energy used to cut the wood down and transport it to your home. The carbon released from your chimney is neutral because the tree captured that carbon from the atmosphere while it was growing.)
- ars 8y agoPS: Please don't heat with wood, it's very very polluting. There's more to pollution than just CO2.
- fhbdukfrh 8y agoThat's a little simplistic. The state of the carbon is incredibly important - keeping it locked in a tree, ice or the ground instead of floating around in the atmosphere is kind of the entire goal. Heating with wood unlocks all that essentially inert carbon into wide spread particulate, so it's no more carbon neutral than burning coal you collect by hand. You're also depleting the carbon absorption side by harvesting the tree
- naskwo 8y ago"Transportation makes up the largest share of emissions."1) Transportation is still only 28%, slightly more than a quarter. Electricity & "industry" account for 50%. Further, I remember a discussion with the president of Mercedes who was pushed for cleaner cars. He mentioned that one ocean-going freight vessel pollutes more than 450k cars combined (here is an article in that same trend (2). I love the notion of quiet, electric cars, but the "industry" that pollutes these cars, and the "electricity" that is needed to charge these cars still accounts for 50% of the pollution. So, until ocean freighters are cleaned up, the net effect on pollution will likely be zero. 1) https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/sources-greenhouse-gas-emissions https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/sources-greenhouse-gas-emis... 2) https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-1229857/How-16-ships-create-pollution-cars-world.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-1229857/How-...
- daxfohl 8y agoSo by way of the trade war with China, potus may ironically be the greatest hero in the war on climate change.
- Cshelton 8y agoYou laugh, but actually yes! Trade, while it's a pretty efficient market today, is not efficient as far as raw materials -> manufacturing -> products go and how they are moved. The most common thing today is to move raw materials to a location where the manufacturing and labor is the cheapest..., the finished product may go right back to where the raw material came from. Seems silly right? The tariffs will alter where raw materials and finished products are sent, if sent anywhere at all. Ideally, raw materials, manufacturing, and final delivery of finished goods would all be next to each other. Of course scarce, or regional, raw materials are different because there may only be a few places in the world to obtain them. But that's not the norm. Governments can economically incentivize all three steps to be at least in the same country so we aren't shipping things across the ocean for basically cheap labor/production cost.
- x220 8y agoYeah. Instead of burning gasoline for our cars, we will burn oil/gas for electricity for our cars.
- x220 8y agoEven though 100 companies are responsible for the bulk of climate change, lets keep painting it as the moral failure or greed of the general masses.
- noobermin 8y agoWhile I share your sentiment, I don't see any real actual address of the underlying cause of climate change before irrecoverable harm to the planet.
- ars 8y agoThose 100 companies don't include oil companies I hope? Because including them would be completely nonsensical, and would totally ruin any point you are trying to make.
- beat 8y agoThis reads far too much like a Facebook virtue signaling meme, rather than a supported fact. Not saying it's wrong, just saying the standards are (usually) higher on HN.
- cbhl 8y agoI imagine we'll need pretty substantial upgrades to our electrical grid if we want electrical charging to be ubiquitous. A typical home peaks at 15-30 kW, whereas a single DC fast charger can use as much as 62 kW or 500 kW. Even a L2 charger uses something like 6.6-19.2 kW; if you tried to retrofit a Wal-Mart parking lot to have L2 chargers at every parking spot you'd probably need to build a new electrical power plant next door.
- blacksmith_tb 8y agoI doubt we'll see every space getting a charger, in fact as EVs/PHEVs become more common I would expect to see the free charging parking spaces go away (they're supposed to be an incentive to get people to switch, but if everyone already has...).
- pkaye 8y agoI see the free charging spaces at my local Target packed full of cars. I was wondering who would have time to spend there all the time until I realized some of them are Uber drivers. They get electric cars so they can charge for free waiting for their next customers. I'm guessing Target was hoping they would be actual customers who you drop by to shop while charging. I'm sure some time in the future they will be changed to have a fee once EVs become more common place.
- Cshelton 8y agoExactly. I've owned a Tesla for 3 years. Never once have I used those retail parking lot chargers. They seem silly to me. I charge in my garage, which doesn't need to be very fast at all, about 10Kw. And use the Supercharger network only on road trips.