4 ms·
One is the original weblog model, with either no comments enabled or with some sort of whitelist comment participation. You can write whatever you want, and som
by jerf 8y ago
One is the original weblog model, with either no comments enabled or with some sort of whitelist comment participation. You can write whatever you want, and some asshole over there can write about how stupid you are, and it doesn't have to bother you unless you deliberately visit the asshole. Back before social media, there were cases where there were entire weblogs devoted to replying to literally every post some other weblog made, but nobody cared except the few who deliberately sought that out, because you had to go out of your way to visit.
I suppose I should point out explicitly that my goal is not to create a 100% comfortable world in which you never encounter an asshole, but to create something a bit more like the real world where by the time you're an adult and you've found a place for yourself in the world, by and large you probably don't have a problem dealing with lots of people-you-consider-assholes personally. (You may professionally, but that's a different sort of problem.) Even if you maybe have a problem with one or two people in particular, you almost certainly do not set a foot outside your bedroom door and immediately get several thousand people screaming at you at the top of your lungs. But you're going to encounter a few, sure.
More on the Reddit model, I outlined something here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16570017 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16570017 The observation that it is computationally expensive is true, but I'm not convinced it's intractably so. There the idea is that if some anklebiter starts replying to your every comment, by default you at most see something greyed out or collapsed if you did not have any previous connection to them, and they can't bother you. I think to jumpstart the system you'd always have to have a couple of random comments show up, and some of them may be assholes, but it wouldn't be the case I was describing where you can get this unrelenting torrent of abuse.
(I think such a system would have more manipulation resistance, too. $MEDDLER could go to some political forum that works that way, and maybe they could convince a few people or a subcommunity to upvote them, but they wouldn't be able to completely take over an entire topic by sheer mass the way they can on Reddit. You can't get a world where $MEDDLERs don't exist, but you don't have to have a world in which only $MEDDLERs and $MEDDLER-approved accounts exist on your forum.)
- divan 8y agoI really like your thinking here, especially the "more like real world" part. As you outlined in the previous comment, the source of the problem is the increased communication rates - in the offline world, you normally have like 60 microassholes per second, while online you can easily get up to 30K microassholes/s. This change of communications with assholes rate brings asymmetry that is a cause of the problem: you still have the same response capacity and emotional response decay time as in the offline world, but the incoming rate of assholes is so huge, so you can't cope with it anymore. So perhaps any solution should be seen from this perspective: decreasing the upper boundary rate to some reasonably acceptable value. But it also may lead to the opposite conclusion – we now in an online world, with different speeds and rates of everything. Maybe solutions "like in the real world" simply won't work anymore here. Perhaps we can use some new tools to solve these sorts of problems, that we never had in the offline world? For example, there was a brilliant idea to set a price tag for your attention in the online world. Imagine an email system where the sender should pay some price for you to receive it and read. This price can be dynamic and vary according to various parameters – from sender's identity to my current mood. If someone sends me a public speaking request or is trying to hire me, they'll pay like 5$ per mail, but for my friends or coworkers asking for help it could be 0.03$. And if my inbox is empty (ha-ha) and I'm in the mood to explore who's writing me, I can temporarily lower the price for all. That's of course, just a rough sketch of the idea, but it might work in the future if cryptocurrencies become ubiquitous for example.
- cakeface 8y agoI love this idea of adding real dollar cost to messaging. At the very least you would have a pile of money to go with your pile of harassing messages. That seems like an improvement. And you'd take money away from harassers. Making this a market seems like an interesting idea.
- jerf 8y agoBy "more like the real world" I don't mean that I'd limit the social mechanisms to that, just that it's not necessarily a goal of mine to make it so you meet a straight zero assholes online. I think that the things you'd have to do to make that possible would be worse than meeting the occasional asshole. It isn't even really possible, either, since there isn't even remotely a universal agreement on what the exact "asshole" line is. (There's lots of agreement about some things, but as you get away from the obvious stuff and start having to draw a line it gets very, very hard, as Facebook et al are really discovering right now.)