4 ms·
Good stuff. One concern with Callisto though: What stops a serial perpetrator from reporting himself (using an alias) to be able to identify anyone else who has
by ummonk 8y ago
Good stuff. One concern with Callisto though: What stops a serial perpetrator from reporting himself (using an alias) to be able to identify anyone else who has reported him?
- giarc 8y agoI would imagine the attorney that gets involved would not divulge the identities of those coming forward to each other.
- Hongwei 8y agoHopefully self-preservation - why call attention to himself (or herself)? Unless they had more sinister intentions to intimidate previous victims or worse. But even then, reporting yourself to the watchdog wouldn't be worth it. I think this is a great thing for YC to be doing.
- glangdale 8y agoSomewhere else upthread it was suggested that Callisto could "get together" victims, which another commenter pointed out is less than ideal for legal reasons (looking like they cooked up testimony). The 'fake report accomplice' would be another good reason not to allow victims to directly communicate. Generally, an attacker would probably not want to call attention to themselves. A sufficiently well-resourced adversary (I suppose) could hire people to spam the system with false accusations (possibly targeting similar peers so it looks like "hey, everyone in crypto/databases/... is being accused") but if the process of getting an account with this system isn't trivial (invite-only, verified email, etc) it wouldn't be easy.
- tlb 8y agoThis paper explains the cryptography and game theory behind their approach: https://www.projectcallisto.org/callisto-cryptographic-approach.pdf https://www.projectcallisto.org/callisto-cryptographic-appro...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tetrep 8y agoIt sounds like you'd need to lie to a lawyer, which (I assume has) legal implications: Users of this product will be able to enter the identity of their perpetrator into the escrow. This data can only be decrypted by the Callisto Options Counselor (a lawyer), when another user enters the identity of the same perpetrator. If the perpetrator identities match, both users will be put in touch independently with the Options Counselor, who will connect them to each other (if appropriate) and help them determine their best path towards justice. The client relationships with the Op- tions Counselors are structured so that any client-counselor communications would be privileged. edit: from https://www.projectcallisto.org/callisto-cryptographic-approach.pdf https://www.projectcallisto.org/callisto-cryptographic-appro...
- forapurpose 8y ago> It sounds like you'd need to lie to a lawyer, which (I assume has) legal implications There are no legal implications from lying to a lawyer that are different than lying to a software developer or anyone else, at least not that I can think of. I suppose communication with lawyers is more likely to be in situations where lying has legal implications, such as in legal proceedings. But if you lie on the witness stand, the problem is not that you lied to the lawyer but that you lied to the court.
- gowld 8y agoHere's a potetntial attack that could happen in general (but perhaps unlikely among a pool of YC founders): A perpeterator's accomplice files a report, triggering a process that leads to meeting an accuser. The accomplice then carefully unwinds and backs out the process, and leaks the accuser's identity to the perpetrator for use in other harassment or blackmail.