2 ms·
You seem to be mixing up presumption of innocence, the right to your own opinion and the concept of defamation, largely ignoring the latter. I can have an opin
by mpweiher 8y ago
You seem to be mixing up presumption of innocence, the right to your own opinion and the concept of defamation, largely ignoring the latter.
I can have an opinion that HN user geofft is a <insert horrible thing>. This is my right. However, I cannot go to other people and say that geofft is a <insert horrible thing>, particularly if doing so causes you harm, for example economic/reputational.
I have a hard time seeing how such a list does not cross that line. Except of course if the accusations are true, but they must then be proven to be true.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> I can have an opinion that HN user geofft is a <insert horrible thing>. This is my right. However, I cannot go to other people and say that geofft is a <insert horrible thing>, particularly if doing so causes you harm, for example economic/reputational. Yes, you can. Now, if geofft can prove that it is false, and that you reasonably should have known it was false (and the standard may be higher depending on subject matter and other context), then you may be liable for defamation. > Except of course if the accusations are true, but they must then be proven to be true. No, in the US, falsity is an element of defamation where, as in the other elements of the tort (rather than defenses against liability) the burden of proof is in the plaintiff, not the defendant. The offended party must prove the statement false. As well as proving the negligence of the one publishing it with regard to the truth.
- DanBC 8y agobut geoftt has to prove that the comments have caused harm.