7 ms·
Coding Horror: The Keyboard Cult
- duck 16y agoMechanical keyboards are nice, but I think I would go crazy if I worked in an office full of them. I have the small form Deck keyboard ( http://www.deckkeyboards.com/product_info.php?products_id=30 http://www.deckkeyboards.com/product_info.php?products_id=30) and love how it doesn't have the number pad which pushes your mouse further away.
- jawee 16y agoI have an old mechanical keyboard of sorts that I use... I am currently typing on a fairly old Packard Bell keyboard that has individual plastic switches. It is not the best there is, but it works well... so that is what my normal keyboard situation is. but what interested me most was the thoughts on how using touchscreen devices really affects input patterns. I have an iPod Touch that I often use to surf the web... usually Hacker News in Opera Mini in fact. I can type fairly fast on the device as well... I have timed myself at 80wpm vs 120wpm on my normal keyboard. From time to time I have even used it to type serious things, such as a few page long history paper. It is never pleasent though. It feels like an absolute chore of utter concentration to type fast on the touchscreen keyboard. It's convinient enough to type a few short sentences here and there, but whenever I go type anything lengthy I cringe at the fact that I have to type there. I cannot imagine having something like the iPhone as my primary phone because of how much texting that I do (I chose my non-smartphone simply for having the best possible keyboard). I really do wonder how that will affect how people think of data.. if we move more and more to devices where text input just isn't as nice as on a keyboard, such as iPads and phones like the Droid X and iPhone, for our computing needs, are we going to be less likely to do serious interaction?
- makmanalp 16y agoI also think that touch screen keyboards are crippling, but it seems that most non techies don't type fast enough to care anyway. So maybe keyboards will end up being a specialist tool?
- protomyth 16y agoAdd every secretary and administrative assistant to that list. The big volume typing problem with touch screens (other than the constant "shifting" to get other keys (e.g. Numbers on the iPad)) is the lack of movement which results in more stress on the fingertips. Not to mention the lack of contours to tell where fingers should be placed. I do think it might be interesting to allow the word prediction to be system wide on desktops / portables.
- Qz 16y agoFor me the biggest factors are the lack of physical response (although the mini vibe on Android helps here), and the way touch screens can get overloaded if you type too fast. On my keyboard I can type hella fast, but if I tried typing like that on a full size touch keyboard, even if I hit every key perfectly, the touch screen would get overloaded and miss letters.
- awolf 16y agoHmm, this is not the case on the iPad: many people are able to type at 100wpm+ on the it. How fast do you mean?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- evanrmurphy 16y agoI'm a recent mechanical keyboard convert. Bought a Customizer 101 [1] a couple months ago and was so pleased I ended up buying a second one (one for work, the other for home). I can type for much longer now before reaching any kind of exhaustion in the hands/wrists. Recommended for the RSI-prone, as long as the people around you don't mind the noise too much. --- [1] http://pckeyboards.stores.yahoo.net/cus101usenon.html http://pckeyboards.stores.yahoo.net/cus101usenon.html
- kgtm 16y agoOn mechanical keyboards, Razer is bringing this puppy to the gaming masses (and the rest of the tactile feedback enthusiasts): [ http://store.razerzone.com/store/razerusa/en_US/pd/productID.211651300/categoryId.35156900 http://store.razerzone.com/store/razerusa/en_US/pd/productID... ]. If you must combine some ultra-geekery, including n-key rollover even when connected via USB, with futuristic looks, it is a top-notch offer.
- baddox 16y agoHow do the various mechanical keyboard mentioned here compare to an IBM Model M keyboard? Are they as loud, etc.? I find typing on my M very satisfying, but the volume truly is a problem, and I think even the weight of the key presses might be a problem for lengthy typing sessions.
- kellishaver 16y agoI have a model M as well and I love it. It feels amazing to type on, but yeah, I can't use it to take notes during a phone call/meeting, or if I'm doing anything where I also need to hear what's going on in the background. Still, it's worth the trade-off for me, because I find it so comfortable to type on. I bought a Mead 5 subject notebook for meetings. I work from home, too, though. I'm sure if I worked in a shared office space, my co-workers would be ready to kill me... but then again, on the plus side, due to its mass and solid construction, the Model M is probably a viable weapon for self-defense, and would likely still work just fine afterward.
- aaronblohowiak 16y agoMoving to a buckling-spring keyboard (similar action as the Model M) relieved a great deal of forearm pain for me. I am naturally a furious typist, and the increased resistance seems to help.
- klodolph 16y agoI wonder if this is related -- it seems that people who wear shoes with less padding (or no shoes) are less likely to get certain types of injuries. With no padding, we strike the ground carefully. Wearing cushioned shoes, we strike the ground with full force.
- wyclif 16y agoI use a Unicomp too. I actually don't think they increase resistance, they increase actuation and positive response. That is what reduces RSI in this case.
- fourk 16y agoI recently switched from a model M to a Das Keyboard (not the silent edition) and found that the key presses are not as satisfying, but that it emits a more acceptable level of volume for working in a crowded office. Probably 70% volume as compared to a Model M. After about a month of using the Das Keyboard I started getting some RSI issue which led to me starting the process of switching over to a Kinesis Advantage (the initial learning curve for this keyboard sucks). I really really wish that the Kinesis had level of tactile feedback closer to that of a Model M or Das Keyboard.
- rix0r 16y agoI simply love typing on the keyboard of my MBP. Does anyone know what class of keyboard that is?
- ciupicri 16y agoI think that it's a scissor-switch keyboard[1]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scissor-switch http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scissor-switch
- djhworld 16y agoI'm not sure if the keyboards on a MBP and normal MacBook (what I have) are the same, but I'll concur if they are because I enjoy typing on my MacBook.
- raganwald 16y agoSo, Jeff Atwood can't take me seriously as a programmer: As he puts it, when was the last time you saw a hunt and peck pianist? But I'm a composer, not a pianist, and technology has been liberating composers from the need to be expert performers at least as far back as since Apple funded a MediaLab project to give grade school children computers to perform music so that they could compose music a long before they could learn to play their own compositions. Then again, he may have a point, I do a lot of whimsical programming. Maybe if I took programming more seriously I'd learn to type. And learn to use an IDE. And learn to push dirt: http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2007/12/codes-worst-enemy.html http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2007/12/codes-worst-enemy.ht... :-)
- wvenable 16y ago> But I'm a composer, not a pianist. Perhaps Atwood's analogy isn't the best. Programmers are the composers and the computer itself is the pianist, running the composition. However, you need a keyboard to compose! I don't think my typing really got fast until I started using instant messaging. When it comes to programming, I could always type a lot faster than I could think. I'm probably typing this message significantly faster than I'd type any code.
- petercooper 16y agoSo, Jeff Atwood can't take me seriously as a programmer Thankfully this is hardly a slamming indictment.
- raganwald 16y agoNo, but at the same time, I wonder if being a terrible typist is a little like riding my bike with a rusty chain. Maybe my riding is more about where than how fast, but whatever my speed, there must be a decent return on being more efficient. If I typed more quickly, maybe I would have more time for thinking. That might be very important.
- rbxbx 16y agoPerhaps while hunting that next key, you'll have realized a better solution. Perhaps knowing the eventual time you must spend to type causes you to think more before you begin typing... Who's to say? That said, I can't imagine those blog posts come out quickly :)
- petercooper 16y agoI long for a mechanical keyboard about as much as I do a typewriter or non-power steering and I used to have one of those Model Ms back in the 90s! I'm a writer more than a programmer but the new "thin" Apple keyboard does me proud for hours on end and is only marginally less comfortable than the Microsoft ergonomic keyboard I used to enjoy. This is yet another "different strokes for different folks" scenario, though I love the irony of Atwood not taking other programmers seriously considering how often he gets reeducated by Spolsky on their podcast.
- jerf 16y agoI find myself wondering if there are "cheap" membranes and "better" membranes. My wife's netbook keyboard is terrible and mushy, not that it matters to her, but my Dell Studio 17's keyboard is relatively snappy and I like it. It feels like the Apple keyboards, though it doesn't have the visible separation between the keys. I mean, I suppose it could be better but it would be an awfully incremental improvement.
- jseliger 16y agoThen why don't you buy a Unicomp Space Saver or Customizer? Those are modern Model Ms, made on the same equipment with the same feel: http://jseliger.com/2008/05/07/product-review-unicomp-customizer-keyboard/ http://jseliger.com/2008/05/07/product-review-unicomp-custom...
- spamizbad 16y agoI find the new thin apple keyboards to be horrid, and it's not often I see people praise them (they're universally disdained on keyboard snob forums, even among dedicated Mac users). Have you tried any boards with Topre or Cherry browns/blues switches?
- klodolph 16y agoHm, really? I've heard some fair praise for them. I prefer my keyboard (it has brown Cherry switches) but the thin Apple keyboards seem a step above standard membrane switch keyboards (this is the catch) once you get used to them.
- sdrinf 16y agoI've used to type exclusively on my handy IBM PS/2 keyboard ( http://www.dansdata.com/images/clicky/ballboard1024.jpg http://www.dansdata.com/images/clicky/ballboard1024.jpg ). Not only was it a beauty to behold, it was manufactured in 1983, had no performance degradation either since then, or throughout the 5 years we spent together (-circa 2007(!!!)), and had an awesome tactile feedback. Finally, the ps/2 port gave in to excessive wear, and I switched it to a deck. Still have it in my old room, owning a piece from ancient history :)
- msbarnett 16y agoIf it was the ps/2 connector on the cable, many (but not all) of the Model M keyboards have swappable cables, and you can get a new cable quite cheaply. If it was the ps/2 port on your computer, you can get a ps/2->usb adapter for around $10. I use a Model M Spacesaver (basically identical to the one in your link, minus the number pad) built in 1992 as my go-to keyboard.
- wiredfool 16y agoI've got a pair of M13s that I use on a daily basis. They're the full sized ones with a built in trackpoint nub in the middle. I wish they were narrower, but I've mostly gotten around that by switching mouse hands.
- ciupicri 16y agoIf there's one thing that I hate at most "modern" keyboards, is the fact that keys are a bit smaller and they seem to be more crowded.
- roblund 16y agoMechanicals are too loud for me most of the time, but I understand his point. I enjoy a quality keyboard. I've also never really liked the apple keyboards. It's nice to have some contour to your keys instead of just flat. Key layout is the thing that kills a keyboard for me more than anything. I've brought home a few keyboards just to find out when I was unwrapping it that the Insert and Delete key rows are goofy, or the arrow keys are all messed up.
- jfb 16y agoI use and endorse the use of the Kinesis Advantage keyboard; I have two (one for home, one for the office) and I love the things. I don't get RSI pain in my joints any longer, a development that correlates (who knows about causation?) to my adopting the Kinesis and switching mousing hands, about ten years ago. I used to rock the Model M, and I still love it, but my favorite keyboard, at least from an aesthetic perspective, was the Apple Adjustable; I loved that weird-ass thing.
- jseliger 16y agoI'm a fan of the Kinesis too: http://jseliger.com/2009/07/20/kinesis-advantage http://jseliger.com/2009/07/20/kinesis-advantage , but I'm not a huge fan of its price. But considering how much time I spend at the keyboard, I can deal.
- jrockway 16y agoStrange that Atwood only recommends the Realforce 87U. Although it is my favorite (and primary) keyboard, the other Realforces are just as good. The 86U is nice, as are the 103 key variants. All have the same keyswitches and variable weights, and all have very durable keycaps. I also have two Happy Hacking keyboards (which are Topre switches, but without the Realforce's variable weighting), and their keycaps are also very durable. I damaged one once by an aggressive washing session (actually, using my hairdryer on it), and was able to order a complete replacement set. It's nice to be able to buy replacement parts when it breaks. Anyway, Topre = love, no matter which one you get. (Oh, and one thing... modern mechanical keyboards, Topre or otherwise, are nothing like those Model Ms from 80s. The Topres have finger-saving 35/45/55g variable weighting. The Model M actuation pressure is over 80g!)
- Qz 16y agoI use some junky 4 dollar Microsoft keyboard that came with my system. At least, I thought it was junky, but it has the mechanical switch thing he's talking about (I think? there's definitely no rubber inside here, clickety clack all night long). It has one row of 'media buttons' or whatever that I almost never use. I now actually go out of my way to avoid those kinds of keyboards because all that extra junk is just wasted money. I used to have a Logitech G15 but that was really more for the cool factor rather than actually having a use for the LCD display (although I really do miss having a button I can press to change between speaker/headphone mode for my sound card without having to dig into Window's audio settings menu every time I plug in or unplug my headphones).
- jbellis 16y agoAll the keyboards he pictures are ergonomic nightmares. +1 to jfb's recommendation for Kinesis Advantage. Their ergonomic designs are well-made and durable. (My first lasted seven years; still on my second.) Doesn't hurt that it gets a lot of attention. Sort of like a sports car for your fingers. :)
- cookiecaper 16y agoI really wish there were more ergonomic keyboards out there. The only one that is viable anymore is the MS Ergo 4000, which, while nice, is not ideal. I would prefer a nice mechanical ergo, but I would also prefer a normal ergo keyboard that was more my style; I never use the zoom slider or most of the other extra buttons on the keyboard. It takes a lot of space for all of those buttons and I would like to buy an ergonomic keyboard that is better, but this is basically the only choice.
- wonderzombie 16y agohttp://www.goldtouch.com/p-65-goldtouch-adjustable-keyboard-putty.aspx http://www.goldtouch.com/p-65-goldtouch-adjustable-keyboard-... I have one of these at work. I switched from the Ergo 4000 to this, and I like it quite a bit. (There's a Mac version, too.) No idea whether it's a crappy keyboard by Atwood's standards. Beware: there are trade-offs. For the Mac keyboard, you'll want to map Caps Lock -> Ctrl. I don't know what's optimal for the PC keyboard; I run Linux and don't use the Windows key. Also, neither has a numeric keypad. There's a Numlock key, a la laptop keyboards. I don't miss it but some people do swear by them. I'm assuming you've also ruled out Kinesis. :) I'm too scared to splurge on one but I've heard they're fantastic.
- cookiecaper 16y agoI run Linux too but the Windows key ("Super" or "Mod-4") is the activator-key for all the shortcuts in my window manager, awesomewm. I also really love numpad and wouldn't spend much money on a keyboard that didn't come with one. :( Anyone know why we see so few mechanical ergos? I would think keyboard snobs would be wary of RSI...
- wonderzombie 16y agoHa! I used awesomewm for a while, myself. Alt was the default in Hardy, so when I upgraded to Lucid, I remapped it from Win to Alt. No idea why there aren't many mechanical ergonomic boards, though. I'm actually surprised by the extent to which people type on regular keyboards.
- Figs 16y ago> What happens when people become trained to think of information and entertainment as something they receive and not something they create? Well, how was it during all those decades when TVs were ubiquitous but PCs were not?
- michael_dorfman 16y agoWell, how was it during all those decades when TVs were ubiquitous but PCs were not? Pretty bad. Cf. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Arguments_for_the_Elimination_of_Television http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Arguments_for_the_Eliminat...
- vl 16y agoI recently learned that Kinesis headquarters are close to Seattle (in Bothell) and have a showroom. I'm going to visit over lunch someday - I'm not ready to shell out $300 for Advantage without trying it first .
- nlawalker 16y agoI consider myself to be something of an input device dork (you can pry my MX518 from my cold, dead hands), but after trying a couple of the MS ergo keyboards and a few other things, I've found that the Comfort Curve 2000 (MS' cheapest keyboard) seems to work for me best. Everyone seems to be all about the clacky mechanical or ergo boards, but I love the CC2000's gentle curve, and the wide, low-throw, near-silent keys. I feel like I can really fly on the thing when I'm typing, and it's spill-resistant to boot.
- awolf 16y agoTouch screen typing is NOT THAT BAD. I type 65 wpm on my iPad which is defeintely fast enough that I can rely on it to do "real work".
- georgemcbay 16y agoIn terms of pure words per minute, I agree with you to an extent, but I also much prefer to type on a keyboard when it is possible to do so. My problem with touchscreen typing isn't so much related to how many WORDS I can type in a given time, but rather the annoyingness of the modality of the virtual keyboards combined with unintuitive chording for things like standard keyboard shift, ctrl, etc. (I realize the better virtual keyboards do have 'solutions' for the chording issues but I've tried them and found them all severely lacking). Having to switch modes to do symbols, numbers, etc, is a real flow-breaker and ultimately means that while I can type informal texts and emails fine on a touchscreen, I find it excruciating to type mostly-grammatically correct English on them. I wouldn't even attempt to code on one for similar reasons.
- awolf 16y agoThis really need not be the case. With practice I have become quiute proficient typing the common symbols and all of the numbers. Instead of a one-tap character it is a two-tap character, that's all. (quick iPad tips that are a huge help: swipe from right hand number key upwards to the exclamation/comma key to type " ; swipe from the right hand shift key to the question mark/period key to type a period)
- atlei 16y agoGet a kinesis keyboard and learn to touch-type; it's probably the best investment you'll ever make... You'll save time when programming, but also when you create the design/requirement/test documents, the help file, the web pages, your blog, all your e-mails, your twitter messages, your IM and Facebook messages, and of course your comments on Hacker News :-) If you don't touch type, give yourself a good kick in the butt and start now !!!! An hour a day for a few weeks and you'll save time every time you write something for the rest of your life ...
- csomar 16y agoMy netbook LG X130 (http://www.lg.com/ae/it-products/notebooks/LG-netbook-X130.jsp http://www.lg.com/ae/it-products/notebooks/LG-netbook-X130.j...) has got the most incredible keyboard I have ever seen. It's easier, way lot faster to write with. May be because it's small, but I think it has a particular precision over the keystroke I hit. Really an amazing one, not sure what type of keyboards it is, but happy with the experience.
- points 16y agoThe key travel on those keyboards is phenomenal. How do you not injure yourself? Who is still using non-laptop style keyboards and why? :/
- wyclif 16y agoWhich keyboards are you talking about? Key travel is not the issue, it is the actuation and positive response of the switch that matter.
- points 16y agoAny 'desktop' style keyboard with big fat keys that travel down more than a few mm. I want as little key travel as possible. Typing on a desktop keyboard is slow and tiring.
- wyclif 16y agoI'm not sure about your 'desktop' distinction, as many laptop keyboards (the MacBook Pro and many Windows laptops for that matter) have bigger keys than, say, a Model M-type standalone keyboard.
- daralthus 16y agoIt is facinationg how people get stuck into one idea and can't get out of it. Why would anyone want to type on a touchscreen the same way he used to do on a keyboard? I am actually thinking to make an ide for the ipad that eliminates typing of letters one by one. Getting your code into the machine should have much more freedom, than stooping in front of a keyboard and typing each word and symbol after another. There must be some next level ui to autocomplete/typing in the world of multitouch.
- Pistos2 16y agoI've worked with someone who looked at the keyboard when he typed, and overall wasn't a very fast typist (I'd estimate < 50 WPM). He made frequent use of tab completion and mouse-based copy-pasting. [Although he didn't use them] there's also double-click and double-click-and-drag copying, and the "features" of IDEs. He produced code of quality on par with the rest of the team, and I never thought of him as having a final-product throughput less than the rest of us [who could type faster]. It's true that you can't hunt and peck and be even just a mediocre pianist, but performing music necessitates keeping tempo -- you must actuate your instrument at the right time, and poor mechanical skill on your part has direct and significant impact on the quality of the music. There is no such analogous requirement in coding, other than perhaps deadlines -- but that is obviously on an entirely different scale (no pun intended).
- rbanffy 16y agoI think, much like Microsoft before it, Oracle's best products now are keyboards. They have Control where God Intended It To Be (with the "Unix layout" option), a nice stack of keys to the left and the overall RT-PC layout we use today. X3701A-UNIX is the part# I also find the 122-key IBM layout intriguing. Unicomp makes one http://pckeyboards.stores.yahoo.net/122keyterkey.html http://pckeyboards.stores.yahoo.net/122keyterkey.html Those, I think, are the only ones I would consider to replace my obsolete beige Microsoft Natural keyboard. Those and a more modern take on the Space Cadet, but nobody seems to be doing that.
- astine 16y agoYou mean Sun's keyboard business which Oracle acquired? I hate those, at least the "Unix layout" ones. Some of these are installed at some of the workstations at work. I don't mind having the control where the caplocks usually is, but I do mind having thew caplock where the control usually is. Because we have both layouts I have to constantly switch between them all the time and I have to be careful and watch which keyboard I'm typing at or it will screw me up. It's very annoying.
- rbanffy 16y ago> I hate those, at least the "Unix layout" ones. Don't say that. Those keyboards are great. I am thinking of buying a couple in case Larry decides to ax the whole line just because its sheer coolness makes their RDBMS look so meh... Now, seriously, the added keys are useful (if you can make them do something), like the 122-key I also mentioned. And there is also an element of nostalgia for the golden age of the Sun workstation.
- jbarham 16y agoI use a standalone ThinkPad keyboard (complete w/ pointer nub) and find it very comfortable. It's also nice and compact since it doesn't include a number pad.
- antirez 16y agoI don't think the typing speed is so important for a programmer as a quality itself. Ok there is all the "interface with the computer" business, but in my opinion here the point is, it's strange that you managed to be a good programmer and not a good typist, because getting good at programming requires typing a lot of programs. So either you are simply genetically not good typing, so even if you typed a lot, and you are a good programmer, you are still a bad typist, or you did not typed enough and perhaps did not programmed enough to be a good programmer. Exceptions exist but I think the final possibility of being very good at programming with little programming activity is very unusual and strange.
- ItarPeyo 16y agoI'm sure all those keyboards do wonders for him. Although people writing stuff like this should take into consideration that a 7Kg (15 lbs) $150+ keyboard that you can only order by mail sounds like elitist BS to some people, especially in some parts of the world. Especially when you take into consideration the fact that most of those keyboards ship only in the US, Japan and 4 other countries. Somewhere in the links he provided there was a comment that went like "If you're a taxi driver how important is your ability to drive". Now what Jeff does is tell us all taxi drivers that we're probably driving a '99 honda civic while he drives and prefers his ferraris and vintage porches. And driving those kinds of cars makes him a more effective driver. If you want a decent keyboarding experience without breaking the bank the Logitech illuminated is an excellent scissors switch keyboard. You can be pretty sure it won't degrade after 2+ years of heavy use. A versatile mechanical keyboard that according to some is even better then DAS (and much more easy to find) is the Black Widow from Razer.
- cgs1019 16y agoI use the cheap Microsoft keyboard that came with my work system. My favorite feature is that in exchange for somewhat tedious hour I can dismantle and thoroughly clean the damned thing. I am surprised that there was no mention of cleanability in the article and that it has not yet come up in the thread.
- novel 16y agoI wonder why programmers think so much about keyboards. My speed is about 65-70WPM as typeracer shows. I'm pretty comfortable with that and can reach the speed on almost any more or less sane qwerty keyboard. I don't feel like I will be way more productive even if I reach 100 or more WPM as thinking usually takes more time than typing (this goes for both programming activities and writing documentation, emails etc). Moreover, as I'm not addicted to some specific keyboard I feel quite comfortable at any desk with any keyboard or laptop and I don't have to carry my keyboard everywhere I go (which seems quite cumbersome).