6 ms·
For anyone downvoting this I'll expand what he said so you can understand it before reflex downvoting. Nationstate backed fiat currencies require enormous amou
by superkuh 8y ago
For anyone downvoting this I'll expand what he said so you can understand it before reflex downvoting.
Nationstate backed fiat currencies require enormous amounts of energy waste in the form of standing armies and other tools of power. Compared to the energy Bitcoin uses to protect itself from attack or fraud this energy is very large.
- mancerayder 8y agoThe implication now is that there'd be no standing armies or other, as you say, tools of power? Do you believe this?
- superkuh 8y agoNot sure where you are going with this, but yeah, Bitcoin does not have a standing army. It secures itself from attack by proof of work.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoOk, cool. How does that secure the rest of us?
- OedipusRex 8y agoIt doesn't, Bitcoin is as safe as the security of the person who holds it. And as someone who had Bitcoin on Mt Gox, this is a moot point to argue.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoThe point is that the military that the person claimed should be counted in the energy expenditures related to the USD does far, far, far more than "protect the dollar", and even if we all moved to Bitcoin, we'd still have to have the military.
- root_axis 8y agoIf your logic made any sense then only countries with standing armies could successfully issue their own currencies, but that's obviously not the case.
- sleepless_on 8y agoAlso one could argue the intrinsic value of Bitcoin is it's computing power, as that is worth something.
- epicide 8y ago"Value" implies you can retrieve that work back out of it. Otherwise, it is a cost. Seeing as how I can't retrieve the computing power back out of Bitcoin that was mined, it is a cost.
- starbugs 8y agoWell, couldn't you actually sell the coin in exchange for computing power?
- epicide 8y agoThat's just buying computing power like you would do with USD.
- starbugs 8y agoMy point is: it boils down to someone putting power into something which then conserves that power (and can be exchanged for something else). Another example of this is gold. To extract it out of the ground, you need to invest energy. That energy is then "stored" in the gold. You can release it by selling it for USD, then purchasing service from someone and so on. I think it's hard to argue that the energy you put into it is lost even if that seems unintuitive at first glance. The only currencies which exhibit that feature (no energy put in, hence no real intrinsic value) are fiat currencies, which come with their own set of unique issues.
- epicide 8y agoI never said the energy is lost. I'm saying I, the owner, cannot extract it back out. This is also true for gold-backed currency, but USD, among others, hasn't been backed by gold for some time now. My understanding is that a currency needs to be backed by something intrinsically (seen as) valuable as it goes through the bootstrapping process. Once it is generally accepted, it can stand on its own (at least for a while). No matter how big Bitcoin is, it can never get off of its "gold standard" -- i.e. the computing power required to mine it. On its own, this would be fine, but the parallels break down very quickly when we are talking about new *coins coming out at a MUCH higher velocity than traditional currencies.
- OedipusRex 8y agoYes a nationstate does protect the value of it's money with a standing army but to imply the purpose is to protect the currency is false. The armed forces and stability of the country bring about the value of the currency, not the other way around.
- Cmerlyn 8y agoYes, because if cryptocurrencies became the standard, armies will become obsolete and Nation states will dissolve their Military programs. Makes sense.
- statguy 8y agoHa. That would be true if the only purpose an army was to stabilize the currency. The army/military of any nation does far more than that.
- ikfmpwdsoz 8y agoArmies are to protect people and national interests, not currency. I'd love to here more about your vision of a future without military, though.
- jimjimjim 8y agowut? nations will continue regardless of currency. nations will always have different levels of resources. nations will need to defend those resources. this has nothing to do with electricity used in current electronic financial transactions. bitcoin and it's ilk are wildly fantastically inefficient.
- jcranmer 8y agoThe government's monopoly of force and the stability of its currency are not strongly correlated. A country like Somalia had a stable currency despite the fact that its notional government barely exerted any power beyond the walls of its offices, and a country like Zimbabwe has seen its currency lose any value despite the government lacking any reasonable prospect of invasion and the military/security forces preventing any reasonable prospect of internal rebellion. If anything, a powerful standing army is more likely to result in failure of fiat currency (hyperinflation)--hyperinflation is fundamentally caused by a government pursuing really bad economic policies to the detriment of the economy, and the failing economy will tend to precipitate an internal (potentially violent) rebellion if there is space to do so.