4 ms·
Some of these groups have a publicly stated goal of overthrowing British democracy - doesn't seem unreasonable for them to be monitored by the police and securi
by chrisseaton 8y ago
Some of these groups have a publicly stated goal of overthrowing British democracy - doesn't seem unreasonable for them to be monitored by the police and security services.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoAlso, the alleged spying goes back to the 1960s. It's not like they could just sit in their air conditioned offices and look at all your metadata and see whether or not you're talking to some sketchy guys in Yemen and buying fertilizer in bulk back then. They had to do Real Police Work(TM), like infiltrating the organizations in question, to figure these things out (I wish it was still that way).
- comice 8y agohow many of them have that goal? what do you think of the monitoring of the rest of them?
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoWell, if you're the police, how do you find out whether a group has that goal? Listen to their public pronouncements? That seems rather naive. No, you pretty much have to infiltrate in order to find out whether or not they're trying to violently overthrow the government. Of course, that's true of every organization. How do you know that the Kensington Garden Club isn't plotting the violent overthrow of the British government? But there's some level of plausibility where you should investigate. (Note well: I am not claiming that the British police drew the line in the right place.)
- geezerjay 8y ago> No, you pretty much have to infiltrate in order to find out whether or not they're trying to violently overthrow the government. I would add that enterism is a real thing with quite a few notable cases of a minor fringe group within a moderate party serving as a spearhead to takeover the reigns and leverage its goodwill to advance extremist ideals. This sort of thing is only caught by insiders keeping tabs on the organization's inner workings.
- 113 8y agoWhy? As long as they're not doing it violently.
- chrisseaton 8y agoThey say they want to 'seize control' of the government institutions using 'mass action' instead of voting. They aren't talking about asking nicely are they, come on.
- throwaway8689 8y agoMass action is a form of democracy, if the mass is large enough. It doesn't have to mean violence.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> Mass action is a form of democracy, if the mass is large enough. That cannot be what they are referring to - if the mass was a majority then they could use voting. They say they can't use voting, which implies to me they're planning some kind of minority undemocratic action.
- kiliantics 8y agoActions by governments are actions by a minority and most governments are voted for by a minority
- chrisseaton 8y agoWell ok another way to break it down would be that they want to do something without using the consensus system we have. They could use our consensus system to propose a new consensus system, but they aren't planning to do that. You could argue that our consensus system is wrong and that they shouldn't have to use it, and it's oppressive to apply it to them, but at that point I'm not sure what to say apart from the majority of people I know think the current consensus system is the best we know. How can you find out what the consensus is on our consensus system if you don't trust the current consensus system?
- clubm8 8y ago>Some of these groups have a publicly stated goal of overthrowing British democracy Britain doesn't have a democracy, it has a monarchy. The queen "consents" legislation, PMs, etc. They also have an entire "house of lords" which is literally a forum for the aristocrats to counter the democratically elected parliament. One could argue they spy to avoid democracy, not protect it.