5 ms·
This is one of my favorite user interface design articles that I recommend every chance I get, and it should be required reading in every design class. Apple's
by DonHopkins 8y ago
This is one of my favorite user interface design articles that I recommend every chance I get, and it should be required reading in every design class.
Apple's long romance with skeuomorphism peaked with Bob Bishop's APPLE-VISION, and went downhill from there.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RiWE-aO-cyU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RiWE-aO-cyU
At the other end of the spectrum of video players with extremely terrible user interfaces, there's VLC.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13573499 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13573499
>[... detailed step by step instructions to demonstrate a terrible usability failure that I wrote up in a bug report that was brushed off and ignored ...]
>This single facet of VLC's terrible UI deserves to be front and center in the User Interface Hall of Shame [2] -- it's even worse than Apple's infamous schizophrenically skeuomorphic QuickTime 4.0 player [3], from 1999! The latest version of VLC in 2017 is still much worse than the shameful QuickTime player was 18 years ago!
At least QuickTime 4.0 serves as a useful ruler by which we can measure the terribleness of other video players.
- java-man 8y agowhile I fully agree with the critique of VLC usability, we have to admit that we get what we paid for with [probably] majority of open source software. what's worse, i don't think there is a reasonable solution for this problem. popularity of free software is just too alluring to the users, and asking for monetary compensation instantly reduces the user base. example: linux and openssl. large corporations benefit from running open source software. do they compensate the authors?
- briancollins 8y agoVLC can be pretty jarring. One thing I noticed a while ago is the fast-forward button behaves differently in full screen to windowed: - Full-screen VLC fast-forward skips forward in the video by a few seconds. - Windowed VLC fast-forward skips the entire video.
- bihnkim 8y agoAre you sure about that? On my Mac, the full-screen overlay shows both skip and scan arrows. The windowed version normally shows just the scan arrows. You can select an option to reveal the skip arrows when windowed. In none of the scenarios do the skip/scan arrows ever change function.
- rangibaby 8y agoYou are free to change anything you like about VLC yourself. I don’t mind that it’s interfacr is “broken” because it: - plays videos - is free
- bhandziuk 8y agoImagine if everyone who had an issue with a program forked it and made their own version.
- rangibaby 8y agoI'm not exactly a leet hacker but have done that multiple times to scratch my own itches.
- DonHopkins 8y agoSo where is your pull request to fix the bug I described? Why wasn't it accepted?
- DonHopkins 8y agoI invested the time in submitting a detailed bug report as a litmus test to determine if it was worth spending more of my time installing the source code, learning how it works, and trying to fix the problem myself. Because I'm a user interface programmer who could actually do that work, I also have a lot of other pressing things to do with my time, and wouldn't want to waste it if there was no chance of the developers accepting my changes or even acknowledging that there was a problem. If they brush off my bug report, I thought, then they probably won't accept my changes. But that's exactly what they did, which proved to me it wasn't worth my time. The developers also ignored and argued against many other valid bug reports and complaints on the discussion board. Their attitude came through quite clearly and consistently, and my experience wasn't unusual. If you disagree that it's not worth the time, then by all means you should get started downloading the source code, reading it to understand how it works, submitting bug reports on any problems you find, getting up to speed so you're qualified to make changes in the proper way that the developers will accept, fix the bug I described, test it on all platforms, and submit a pull request.
- bArray 8y agoI wouldn't say VLC has the best user interface in the world, but in no way is it as bad as the QuickTime/WinAmp [1] era UI we went through where UI looked cool but it wasn't obvious which part if it was actually functional or decoration. Not only that, but it was completely abstract in comparison to the OS's UI. VLC's interface is relatively honest in it's appearance in my opinion. I think modern UI is becoming over simplistic - it's no longer obvious what is meant to be interacted with [2]. Humans usually have a good grasp of depth and things pretending to have depth. I imagine OSX will eventually go the way of iOS and Android with a flat UI, where it's not obvious at all how you're supposed to interact with it. Apple products have been getting harder to use for a long time, with features such as the insane four/five finger scroll on an iPad to change apps, close windows, etc [3]. And don't even get me started with the Apple Newton [4]. [1] https://screenshots.en.sftcdn.net/en/scrn/30000/30671/winamp-6.jpg https://screenshots.en.sftcdn.net/en/scrn/30000/30671/winamp... [2] https://www.soft32.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/WIndows-10-UI.jpg https://www.soft32.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/WIndo... [3] https://www.macworld.com/article/2975857/ios/6-only-for-ipad-gestures-you-need-to-know.html https://www.macworld.com/article/2975857/ios/6-only-for-ipad... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newton_(platform) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newton_(platform)
- DonHopkins 8y agoTo their credit, WinAmp and QuickTime (or any other known video player) never rotated the zoom widget with the video rotation, the lower end of which was so small it was unusable at any scale, and the entirety of which was unusable at any non-normal rotation or reflection. https://imgur.com/gallery/g0acV https://imgur.com/gallery/g0acV That's right: the mouse target is the outlined region whose width (and thus usability) diminishes to zero towards one end. It's the most Fitts' Law Hostile user interface I've ever seen, AND it rotates sideways and upside down with the video, AND the mouse tracking doesn't work at all in 3 out of 4 rotations (or reflection), only when it's non-rotated and non-reflected: they didn't bother to transform the mouse event coordinates, just the video-resolution user interface drawing! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fitts%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fitts%27s_law Don't even get me started about "interlaying" the user interface INTO the video, so it looks jaggy with unreadable text, instead of "overlaying" the user interface at full screen resolution. Just look at those blocky letters "VLC ZOOM HIDE", and the ferocious jaggies on the diminishing zoom slider curve! It's not even worth fixing any of those particular bugs in the zoom interface, because the entire concept of "interlaying" the user interface into the video is fatally flawed. All that code needs to be printed out and burned, and VLC's entire user interface needs to be completely rearchitected from scratch by designers who know and respect Fitts' Law, so it works consistently across all platforms at all resolutions and rotations (and doesn't suck, while they're at it). But that's not what the VLC developers want to acknowledge or work on. They're more interested in supporting the latest fashionable Anime format. https://www.videolan.org/vlc/releases/2.1.5.html https://www.videolan.org/vlc/releases/2.1.5.html >FOR ANIME FANS >New 6.1 downmixer to 5.1 and Stereo from MKV/Flac 6.1. Correct YUV->RGB color matrix in the OpenGL shaders. Improved MKV support for seeking, and resiliancy. Editions support in MKV. Better subtitles and metadata support from MKV. Various ASS subtitles improvements. But nothing for us "usability fans".
- reaperducer 8y agoskeuomorphism I never understood why that became a dirty word in user interface design. There's nothing wrong with wanting a calendar to look like a calendar. If someone comes up with a different paradigm that is better, then by all means do it, and let people decide if it's good. But ever since skeuomorphism became an anti-buzz word, interfaces have been designed to be different just to be different, not to be better.
- kstrauser 8y agoI don't mind the skeuomorphic look. However, it almost always went hand in hand with skeuomorphic behavior, which I detest. From the article: > Unfortunately, the apologists fail to recognize that there are two likely consequences of this approach: (1) the user is unable to transfer his or her existing knowledge of computer interaction, and (2) the software becomes needlessly subject to the limitations of the physical device. I remember the bad old days where the Mac calendar would only let you flip between pages, because that's how real calendars worked. All your contacts were grouped by first letter, because Rolodex. It was a death by a million cuts where nothing worked as well as it could have because it had to exactly emulate the crummy real world thing it looked like. No thanks - that's the aspect of skeuomorphism that gave it such a horrible reputation. If you want to make my calendar look like it has leather trim, fine. So be it. Just don't make it act like an old-fashioned desk calendar instead of the special purpose database it really is.
- DonHopkins 8y agoAnd don't hide the title bar and the resize corners! (And don't be non-resizable, either!)