3 ms·
I've recently played Dark Souls 3 and it's depressing, as is Bloodborne; both games (spoilers etc) feel kinda meaningless in the end. The premise of Dark Souls
by Cthulhu_ 8y ago
I've recently played Dark Souls 3 and it's depressing, as is Bloodborne; both games (spoilers etc) feel kinda meaningless in the end. The premise of Dark Souls 3 is that there's a cycle of light (fire) and dark, and the objective - not just for the individual instalments, but for the world as a whole - is to link the fire, so that the age of fire lasts for a little longer - but the other side, the age of dark, is inevitable (and optionally you can cause it). The world is old, every civilization has fallen and/or decayed, and there doesn't seem to be any way for it to get back to normal given how everyone's either undead or dying.
Bloodborne is a bit less hopeless, in that it feels like there's a pretty normal world outside of the game area. However, it's depressing in all three endings; spoilers again, the first ending is probably the least depressing one, where after defeating the final boss, you just kneel down in front of your guide / master (so to speak), accept your fate, and choose to forget all of the events. You just wake up in the morning as if nothing happened. In the second one, you fight and defeat your master, buuut an eldritch monstrosity that masterminded the repeating cycle comes in and eats you, turning you into the replacement of the guide. The final ending is where you defeat the eldritch monstrosity and are reborn yourself as an eldritch monstrosity, again (probably?) repeating the cycle.
No real happy endings there. It's all just bleak and meaningless.
- naiyt 8y agoOne interesting thing about Dark Souls is that there is quite a bit of ambiguity around what the "age of dark" actually implies, and there's a lot of hints that it might actually be a beneficial state for humanity. Personally I found Bloodborne to be even more hopeless. It's all based on a Lovecraftian view of the universe, where we're completely insignificant next to these higher order beings and concepts. There are also almost no happy endings for any of the NPCs, which contrasts with Dark Souls a bit. But again, that's a really good translation of Lovecraft into video game form!
- bliblah 8y agoAh Bloodborne is amazing. Every interaction with non violent NPCs is seeping with tragedy even when you do the "right"thing. Send everyone to the chapel? You let a murder in also that will wipe them out. Ok so send him elsewhere; they all go insane and one of them gives birth to an old god. Your character is just a force of nature watching everything decay around them further. I like how From Software is able to present kingdoms / societies that have fallen from grace but each with their own spin making you wonder if they were ever great or just nostalgia.