5 ms·
$2,000,000,000+ worth issued without proof of backing? What value did Tether add that people were willing to deal with it as a middleman to dollars? Side note:
by zamadatix 8y ago
$2,000,000,000+ worth issued without proof of backing? What value did Tether add that people were willing to deal with it as a middleman to dollars?
Side note: The graph could use some TLC. The colors are indistinguishable and there are no static historical charts on the page, just the graph since my visit.
- londons_explore 8y agoWe have no proof $2B were issued. It's possible that $2M were issued, and the rest don't even exist (or rather they are still controlled by the tether organisation).
- TylerE 8y agoThat is could be used to avoid all those annoying banking laws (AML, KYC, etc).
- ceejayoz 8y ago(Maybe.)
- mrep 8y agoUntil the bank they are using to accept USD decides to check them on that (per https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18214935 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18214935): @patio11 19h19 hours ago Eventually, a bank or, more likely, a regulator is going to say “Actually this doesn’t look like a legit deposit that we’re uncomfortable with supporting due to AML/regulatory reasons. It looks an awful lot like proceeds of crime intermingled with grey money.” @patio11 19h19 hours ago More And the terrifying outcome, from the cryptocurrency economy perspective, is the regulator doing what the USFH did with respect to Mutum Sigillum (Mt Gox’s US front): “OK, we’re going to give you two choices.” @patio11 19h19 hours ago More Door #1: Prove that it’s legal money. This should be trivial for you because KYC is the law and your compliance should be automatic. So have your lawyer suit up. BTW we expect this to take 3+ years. Door #2: We propose a 50% haircut.
- yholio 8y ago> Prove that it’s legal money. A clear abuse, it's the government's job to prove illegal deeds. Holding customers funds hostage under the threat of bankruptcy, while the company navigates the complex legal minefield the government itself created is just about the most corrupt system and farther from the rule of law you can get, short of direct confiscation. They even went as far as claiming MtGox was a money transmitting business because it was a customer of Dwolla, and so customers of Dwolla could send money to themselves by withdrawing and depositing dwolla to MtGox: http://k.lenz.name/LB/2013/05/16/seizure-warrant-against-mutum-sigillum/ http://k.lenz.name/LB/2013/05/16/seizure-warrant-against-mut...
- cbau 8y agoI never really understand this claim, but also don't have a deep expertise in AML/KYC. How does Tether help here?
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 8y agoThe situation isn't too complex: Bitfinex is a crypto exchange that had difficulty finding banks that would work with them. Banks are regulated and expose themselves to a great deal of liability if they provide banking for services for illegal endeavors. As you can imagine, some crypto exchanges are deemed too risky. Tether and Bitfinex are the same thing, though both will vigorously deny that, but it's patently clear that they're intimately related. Tether has variously been able to get banking services, and thus act as a USD deposit to enter crypto exchanges like Bitfinex (USD -> USDT tether -> trade for Bitcoin, etc.). Because it's so clear that Tether is simply used as a way to circumvent AML/KYC, Tether continues to have difficulty securing banking services. This current uncoupling of USD:USDT(tether) is due to such a banking issue. There are two major risks with Tether: * Liquidity: without access to banking services, Tether uncouples and there can be a 'bank run' as the majority of funds are unavailable to maintain the stable price. * Reserves: right now there are no guarantees that each Tether is backed by actual USD. You simply have to trust Tether on this. Ultimately Tether may be a sort of fractional reserve, and thus enough selling pressure will make Tether worthless. At it's core, it's just a clumsy obfuscation.
- cbau 8y agoThank you for that answer! Would you mind briefly expanding on "Because it's so clear that Tether is simply used as a way to circumvent AML/KYC"? Not being contrarian, I just don't understand how this part works.
- bmh 8y agoA major use of USDT is that you can sell your cryptos when they're high, converting them to USDT, which holds it's value. Then, when the crypto prices drop, you buy in again, and repeat. By keeping it entirely in the crypto space, your country's tax system can't charge you for capital gains.
- charlietango92 8y agopardon my ignorance, but wouldn't you eventually convert your USDT to 'real'/fiat currency at some point? It would be taxed then as 'other income' right?
- vidarh 8y agoI'm guessing the theory (which may or may not be tax evasion depending on your local tax code) is that you're not taking the profit until you sell for fiat or take it out of the exchange.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> By keeping it entirely in the crypto space, your country's tax system can't charge you for capital gains This is blatant, willful and permanently-documented tax evasion, an amusing combination of illegality and stupidity.
- teilo 8y agoNo, it’s not. It means you don’t pay capital gains when you’re merely exchanging one form of crypto for another. You have not realized any gains until you have converted your crypto into real assets. Converting from one form of crypto to another for the purposes of arbitrage only delays the taxes. It never eliminates them. This is really no different than selling and buying stocks in an IRA account.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> You have not realized any gains until you have converted your crypto into real assets You transacted into (what you believed was) a proxy for cash. That's obviously selling. Every tax jurisdiction has rules about this because every tax jurisdiction has idiots who thought they'd found a clever workaround. (I think the first American one involved a guy in the 19th century selling property for the key to a lockbox full of cash.)
- granaldo 8y agoThe USDT pairs list here https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/tether/trading_exchanges#panel https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/tether/trading_exchanges#... can be intrigue