3 ms·
I see nothing special about package managers that makes competition undesirable. The most common rationale I hear for using Snap/Flatpak/AppImage over tradit
by michaelt 8y ago
I see nothing special about package managers
that makes competition undesirable.
The most common rationale I hear for using Snap/Flatpak/AppImage over traditional deb/rpm is that the fragmentation of the latter is burdensome [1].
One of the main claims of Flatpak is "The days of chasing multiple Linux distributions are over. [...] Create one app and distribute it to the entire Linux desktop market." [2]
If you are designing something to solve the problem of fragmentation, and by so doing you increase fragmentation, you've achieved the opposite of your goal.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18215978 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18215978
[2] https://flatpak.org/ https://flatpak.org/
- CogitoCogito 8y agoJust to be clear, I see no reason to use Snap/etc. over older packaging solutions. However I wouldn't necessarily agree that this automatically increases fragmentation. If Snap/etc. were to support Ubuntu, debian, Redhat, etc., they could provide maintainers a single target across many systems. Then the maintainer could just target that solution and be done. Of course this requires them to win that developer marketshare, but if they believe they can, then they believe they can achieve their goals without fragmenting they system. I personally don't see the need for these systems, but I still see absolutely nothing special about packaging. No maintainer has to support these new packaging methods if they want. If some developers believe they can introduce new and improved packaging systems, I wish them luck.