4 ms·
Is original Java still alive? That's the question. Yes, the whole AP CS curriculum is based on it, Google's Java can somehow be called its continuation. But de
by baybal2 8y ago
Is original Java still alive? That's the question.
Yes, the whole AP CS curriculum is based on it, Google's Java can somehow be called its continuation. But despite of all of that, the overall feel is that Java's development and developer scene is rather morbid.
>The developer community doesn't want to touch anything from Oracle with a 10-foot pole even if it's licensed under GPL.
Yes, that's exactly the case here. Oracle pigeonholed Java back into the category of "corporate software stuff" language, just as it was getting close to being called a normal programming language
- maltalex 8y ago> Is original Java still alive? That's the question. Yes. Very much so. It's either the top or one of the top languages in pretty much every benchmark: https://insights.stackoverflow.com/survey/2018#technology https://insights.stackoverflow.com/survey/2018#technology https://www.tiobe.com/tiobe-index/ https://www.tiobe.com/tiobe-index/ https://githut.info/ https://githut.info/
- guitarbill 8y agothere's more to it than that. let's take C#, as i find that interesting and a bit sad. C# had what seemed like huge mindshare around the 2.0 era. great tooling, sane language, great developer experience. of course it helped that Windows was still huge. now? it still exists, but i'm happy to bet it will never become that big again for various reasons (windows only for a long time, still windows-centric, sucky webdev + mobile). java has issues, too. i'm not talking about the language per se, but the whole situation. the end-user java experience sucks, most people know it mainly for requiring updates, making browsers insecure, and using ungodly amounts of RAM. in a world with containerization, the write-once-run-anywhere marketing line isn't so interesting anymore. groovy, scala, clojure, and kotlin injected some cool ideas, but might have done more harm by cannibalizing the community and proving that just because it runs on the JVM doesn't make it great (to some people :)). we agree it isn't going anywhere fast. huge corporations use it daily still which means huge paychecks. but getting by isn't the same as thriving, and i think it's a valid question to ask. because just like C#, simply adding new language features isn't always enough.
- oblio 8y agoBoth C# and Java have settled as very successful back end language. So your downsides don't really matter for end users.
- threeseed 8y agoReading your comment is honestly like going back in time. Where are these client side Java apps ? I haven't seen one in the wild for years.
- giancarlostoro 8y agoAnd now with Microsoft's Blazor[0] technology you're more likely than ever to see C# on client-side web applications through WebAssembly. [0]: https://github.com/aspnet/Blazor https://github.com/aspnet/Blazor
- guitarbill 8y agominecraft? all of jetbrains' IDEs? but yeah, i struggled to name even those. actually, the minecraft modding community is awesome, and they are doing some really great stuff. including amazing GUIs (inside minecraft, but still).
- int_19h 8y agoC# is still the sanest default choice for any Windows desktop app. And the web stack has only gotten better since 2.0 days, especially with .NET Core. And all the "enterprise" stuff never went away, either. Never become as big again? It's way bigger than it was back then.
- guitarbill 8y agoyou're probably right, and i'm not here to bash C#, just to show what can happen to a healthy language when external things are occurring in the meantime. C# 2.0 was released around nov 2005. even with two solid years of use, that's 2008, and means i haven't touched windows in almost 10 years professionally! coincidentally, intel macs were released jan 2006, and vista was 2007. those same enterprise customers that wanted desktop apps started wanting web-based tools, for mostly good reasons. developers, especially web devs and designers started using macbooks. virtualisation, containers, etc. all came from linux/bsd, and that showed for a long time. but hey, who knows. maybe they'll magically fix all the issues with windows 10, regain people's trust especially w.r.t. to updates, captialise on Apple's hardware weakness (if you see it that way), make .NET and GUIs with .NET first-class citizens on other OS', then maybe?
- the_clarence 8y agoIt's definitely not the trendy language anymore. We still have a lot of it because of legacy products and a generation trained on it mostly. But new languages are objectively better and getting adopted at a faster rate than ever. What young programer wants to write java nowadays? When you have Golang, Rust, Swift, Python, etc.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y ago> What young programer wants to write java nowadays? One who wants to earn good money working with legacy stuff?
- unixhero 8y agoYes. Can confirm. My now senior java developing friends are now making solid 150k+ at corporate gigs.
- knightofmars 8y agoIt's more than "legacy stuff" as well. People always hear "Java" and immediately think "legacy application". I find it quite amusing. It's this weird idea that somehow nobody would or could ever write a new application in Java. Yet here we are with RedHat Thorntail (previously Swarm) and other modern frameworks written in Java and ready to deliver solid large-scale performance.
- spreiti 8y agoI like it that way. Keeps my rate high while doing trivial CRUD applications. On a serious note, I still think Java has one if not the best ecosystem of any language. Fast JVM, lots of high quality Open Source libraries/frameworks, tooling (IDEs, monitoring, debugging) and if you have a problem you probably are not the first one and usually find an answer.
- brazzy 8y ago> It's definitely not the trendy language anymore. It stoppend being "trendy" sometime in the last millenium. "Trendy" isn't the same thing as useful or widely adopted, though. > But new languages are objectively better and getting adopted at a faster rate than ever. They also get dropped and replaced by the next "trendy" thing at a faster rate than ever.