4 ms·
While there have recently been some issues with some elections in the US, we definitely don't have an "election integrity" issue. There is very little evidence
by jjeaff 8y ago
While there have recently been some issues with some elections in the US, we definitely don't have an "election integrity" issue.
There is very little evidence that any elections in the US have been affected by fraud by any significant amount.
- telchar 8y agoTo be fair, there is also a significant lack of evidence that they haven't. It is difficult to collect data in this area because of the setup of the electoral system (both its federated nature and the lack of possible verification of individual votes). This together with the tight margins of modern American elections means potentially significant fraud could hide in the noise. In-person fraud would be hard to hide but electronic fraud is possible and there are interested, capable parties out there (e.g Russia) who shouldn't be discounted. So to say that 'we definitely don't have an "election integrity" issue' isn't correct. There is nothing definite about it - we just have a consensus that we don't have a problem. You could say the same about every data security breach until they were discovered. I have noticed that there is a significant cultural interest in propagating the idea that our elections are sound so I tend to take the idea with a grain of salt as long as our system is as vulnerable as it is.
- cowkingdeluxe 8y agoThere are many ways to negatively affect election integrity, both illegal and legal. For example, in Georgia, US, one of the candidates himself blocked 53,000 voter registrations just 3 weeks before the election. The demographics of the 53,000 is 70% black. https://www.npr.org/2018/10/13/657109536/georgia-puts-53-000-voter-applications-on-hold-weeks-before-election https://www.npr.org/2018/10/13/657109536/georgia-puts-53-000... Gerrymandering, strict voter id laws (e.g. requiring drivers license but removing all but one DMV in the entire county in opponent's strongholds) and similar are also various ways to negatively affect election integrity.
- someone454 8y agoSo who affected the integrity, the guy who blocked the votes or the woman he’s running against? If the voter registrations are questionable, shouldn’t they be checked, regardless of the race of the registrants?
- pjc50 8y agoYes, this is the kind of corruption where someone should go to jail but won't. It might not even be illegal for the Secretary of State to simply deregister voters who will be voting for his opponent.
- deadmetheny 8y agoThe USA is one of the few countries in the world that doesn't require an ID to vote. I'm continually astounded by the fact that people consider that having some sort of identification, which most functioning adults ought to have anyway, is some sort of horrifying oppression.
- notfromhere 8y agoBecause it can be used to disenfranchise voters. When Alabama enacted voter ID, it simultaneously shut down DMV offices in counties with the most potential black voters. Or like in Texas where student IDs are specifically prohibited from being used for voting, even though gun permits are, in order to suppress student turnout. Or in North Dakota, where voter laws were changed to suppress Native Americans from voting using tribal IDs.
- ArchTypical 8y ago> Because it can be used to disenfranchise voters. So can knives. > When Alabama enacted voter ID, it simultaneously shut down DMV offices in counties with the most potential black voters. Most of these problems are now mitigated by years of not needing ID. Now we have voter registration mailouts and such. Don't just throw away a good idea because of past abuse. We strive to be better. Giving up is regressive.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Don't just throw away a good idea because of past abuse. The specific (Alabama) “past abuse” referred to by the grandparent was in 2011-2015, not some distant time where there has been intervening radical change in the political culture that would render it irrelevant. > Don't just throw away a good idea The whole idea was voter suppression. There is no good idea associated with Voter ID laws in the United States. People involved in them this decade have admitted the racial and partisan purpose (usually, when they thought only members of their race and party were around, obviously.)
- 8y ago
- InclinedPlane 8y agoFraud in the form of the outcome of a specific election being different than the actual votes counted: well, probably not super widespread or rampant but not exactly non-existent. Disenfranchisement, gerrymandering, polling place reductions, unequal representation, etc. are, however, quite rampant. Not all votes are equal in the US, and not all voters are treated as equal either. The result is the same (subversion of democracy), but the tactics are different.
- riku_iki 8y agoI think the biggest issue for elections is that candidates can lie to public without any consequences.
- pjc50 8y agoI was thinking of issues like the use of provably hackable voting machines, as well as the selective disenfranchisement mentioned by other commentators. The latter has been a problem in the US for its entire existence.
- scotty79 8y agoMain "election integrity" issue is that you have just two parties to choose from. And that's very close to one.
- dragonwriter 8y agoSelective voter suppression and exclusion, which the US has had in a significant way for centuries, mitigated somewhat for a time by the voting rights act before it was gutted, is a pretty enormous issue with the integrity of democratic elections. The idea that the US doesn't have election integrity issues is simply false.