3 ms·
So you’re willing to concede that the rich pay their fair share?
by refurb 8y ago
So you’re willing to concede that the rich pay their fair share?
- greesil 8y agoPlease define fair, and rich.
- nevir 8y agoIsn't the other half of the statistic something like "the top 0.1% of U.S. taxpayers earned majority of income"?
- coldtea 8y agoHow did you come up with that? The article just says that top 3% of US taxpayers pay the majority of income taxes. If they pay 60% of all income tax paid, but have e.g. 80% of income, they're still paying "the majority of income taxes", but not a fair share of them.
- harryh 8y agoYour hypothetical is not the case (as you can see in one of the graphs in the article). I don't know what "fair share" means exactly, but the 3% in question make far less a % of national income than they pay in income taxes.
- coldtea 8y agoMy hypothetical was an extreme example to show how this can be still fair. Besides this extreme example, you can get the 3% much lower in their share of income and still be justified for the taxes they pay. Say, a person makes 1M year and a 999999 people make 10K per year. The first person earns just 0,01% of the total income combined, but he might be the only one paying taxes if the others are below the taxable income level. So, he might pay e.g. 20% of 1M (and 100% of taxes), while he only makes 0.01% of the income -- and that could still be fair. Now add many dirt poor, many middle class, and a 3% of upper middle class, millionaires, billionaires and so on.
- sintaxi 8y agoAs someone else has pointed out the top 3% have about 30% of the income while paying 60% of the tax. https://assets.bwbx.io/images/users/iqjWHBFdfxIU/itOyNXaN9ahY/v1/760x-1.png https://assets.bwbx.io/images/users/iqjWHBFdfxIU/itOyNXaN9ah... edit: downvoted for providing facts. I take it we have marxists here.
- coldtea 8y ago>downvoted for providing facts. I take it we have marxists here. Well, speaking of facts, "I take it we have marxists here" shows a bias, and it's not exactly a fact in itself. Under a progressive taxation scheme, it can be perfectly normal to make "30% of the income while paying 60% of the tax". (In fact, more normal than being 3% of the population but making 30% of the income). And for many progressively harsher taxation is fairer -- for one because 20% for someone who makes $20K can leave them with difficulty even paying for rent, while even 50% for someone earning $1M will leave them with a very comfortable amount to have all kinds of luxuries. Below a point of poverty, even 10% or 5% is cruel. Whether 60% share of taxes is fair it depends. Perhaps they should pay even more than 60% of the tax.
- sintaxi 8y agoMy comment corrected the assertion that the top 3% take home 80% of the income - and was written without bias (the marxist comment was added after the downvotes).
- tankerdude 8y agoNo chance. There are lies and there are statistics. It misses the point about local taxes and fees. If you flip it around, and ask, how much of your total income is used to pay taxes and fees for federal, state, and local taxes, the ones at the lower end will be paying a much higher percentage of their income. There is only so much you actually have to pay for when you become rich where the folks on the lower end must pay for certain things that take a larger part of their income. No chance it is “fair” and we know who is writing the tax laws.
- harryh 8y agoIf you flip it around, and ask, how much of your total income is used to pay taxes and fees for federal, state, and local taxes, the ones at the lower end will be paying a much higher percentage of their income. This is simply false. One can certainly argue that our tax code should be more progressive than it is, but denying that it is progressive at all is contradicted by the facts.
- tankerdude 8y agoProgressive for federal income taxes, yes. But overall progressive, the answer is simply no. Many places switched from part of income tax to fees. Skyrocketed increase for fees to national parks this past year. Went up 300% for a weekly pass. You apply that over and over again in many parts of your life, and it adds up. It just simply costs more of the percentage of your income to live and because of it, it takes a bigger chunk of your income and thus isn’t progressive. Lastly, Social Security is a kicker for the one thing that is flat out regressive. Capital gains pays zilch for it, and it stops at 127K or so of income. That tax is burdened by the middle class. That’s chump change for the wealthy, but anyone hit by it is burdened less and less the more money they make. And don’t tell me it’s a “fund”. That’s not how the GOP acts with it.
- harryh 8y agoThere are publicly available stats on this stuff. You can look them up on the IRS website. They disagree with your assertion.
- kylestlb 8y agoDo you think marginal utility factors into fairness?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]