3 ms·
> This was a list of people not to work with "Defamation is an area of law that provides a civil remedy when someone's words end up causing harm to your reputa
by mpweiher 8y ago
> This was a list of people not to work with
"Defamation is an area of law that provides a civil remedy when someone's words end up causing harm to your reputation or your livelihood"
https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/defamation-slander-libel https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/defamation-slander-l...
- DanBC 8y agoIt's not defamation if it's true.
- kbenson 8y agoAnd that's the problem of a private list. The accused don't get a chance to rebut the accusations, so anyone can fabricate an entry.
- mpweiher 8y agoAnd that's why the suit is good. If true, this will come out. If false, that will come out.
- DanBC 8y agoJust checking, but you seem to be saying that these alleged rapists MUST ALWAYS have presumption of innocence, but not these women who are clearly defaming people. Is that what you're saying?
- kbenson 8y agoNo... I'm not really sure where you got that from. I'm saying that if you're accused of something, you should have the chance of addressing that accusation. I think that's a bare minimum, because otherwise we're de-facto deciding cases by deciding which ones are worth hearing. People here have been accused of things, and while they may not have been legal accusations, they aren't without career or so cliial ramifications. This is no different than if a group of men shared a list of women they did or did not want to work with for sexual reasons. If that list came out, it would likely be defamatory and any women seeking to take legal action would likely be supported, as they should be. Some people are going to jump towards the different respective power of the people involved as justifying the difference. I think that is (or should be) irrelevant when it comes to the basic question here, which is "should someone be allowed to seek legal restitution for harm?".
- geofft 8y agoI think if I'm accused of something in court I should have presumption of innocence against the use of the government monopoly on violence. I don't think I should have presumption of innocence in the privacy of people's minds, even multiple people's minds. OJ Simpson has not had any of his rights violated by people openly believing he did it, because the government does not believe he did it. And for the government to force people to believe differently would be an immense violation of their rights. Should people act on their beliefs extrajudicially, the government will punish that—after due process and presumption of innocence to the alleged vigilantes, of course.
- mpweiher 8y agoYou seem to be mixing up presumption of innocence, the right to your own opinion and the concept of defamation, largely ignoring the latter. I can have an opinion that HN user geofft is a <insert horrible thing>. This is my right. However, I cannot go to other people and say that geofft is a <insert horrible thing>, particularly if doing so causes you harm, for example economic/reputational. I have a hard time seeing how such a list does not cross that line. Except of course if the accusations are true, but they must then be proven to be true.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> I can have an opinion that HN user geofft is a <insert horrible thing>. This is my right. However, I cannot go to other people and say that geofft is a <insert horrible thing>, particularly if doing so causes you harm, for example economic/reputational. Yes, you can. Now, if geofft can prove that it is false, and that you reasonably should have known it was false (and the standard may be higher depending on subject matter and other context), then you may be liable for defamation. > Except of course if the accusations are true, but they must then be proven to be true. No, in the US, falsity is an element of defamation where, as in the other elements of the tort (rather than defenses against liability) the burden of proof is in the plaintiff, not the defendant. The offended party must prove the statement false. As well as proving the negligence of the one publishing it with regard to the truth.