9 ms·
Tech suffers from lack of humanities, says Mozilla head
- bem94 8y agoThis is such an important point. Engineering does so much to shape society and the lives of individuals. But we give zero training to new engineers in these issues. Worse, so many engineers I speak to are willfully ignorant or disdainful of the humanities. Engineers mustn't loose sight of who we work for: humanity.
- SamReidHughes 8y agoHumanity and "the humanities" are often direct opposites.
- matt4077 8y agoQuite a way to prove their point...
- tomnipotent 8y agoI'd much rather see engineers trained in law - it's considerably more practical and I'd wager will lead to far more positive outcomes than general humanities Most modern legal frameworks already incorporate the better structured part of the humanities (philosophy & ethics). However, none of this matters when we live in a hierarchical society where most people just do not exist in a bubble where they can dissent on any and all things they're working on without fear of reprisal. The fact that Google employees were able to speak-up about bidding on government contracts is huge, but that's a luxury most workers don't have.
- truculent 8y agoLaw is a humanities subject, though?
- tomnipotent 8y agoYes, but there are so many classes an undergrad can take.
- chr1 8y agoWhat part of the humanities do you think would be helpful to engineers? I so far hadn't seen anything that would be useful enough to make me not disdainfull of humanities, but i would be happy to be proven wrong.
- tarboreus 8y agoIdeally the humanities forces you to think about values and the why of things, not just the how. Not all goals are worth achieving...you can "change the world" and make it a worse place. More practically, the humanities teaches persuasion and rhetoric, in writing and in speaking, as well as reading between the lines when reading or listening. I work with engineers...kind of am one myself, though I was trained as a humanist...and I see them dashing themselves on those rocks on a weekly basis.
- theparanoid 8y agoEvery ABET accredited engineering school in the US is required to give a class on professional ethics as part of the degree. Doesn't seem to have much effect.
- caseysoftware 8y agoSoftware Engineering has only been ABET accredited for a few years and there are currently only 21 programs nationwide: https://www.softwareengineerinsider.com/articles/abet-accreditation.html https://www.softwareengineerinsider.com/articles/abet-accred... We've applied the title "engineer" to many, many people who haven't been through a formal engineering program, accredited or not. * My undergrad is one of those 21 but I went through as EE, not SE.
- gaius 8y agoBut we give zero training to new engineers in these issues This isn't true, as anyone with an undergrad engineering degree will tell you!
- toomuchtodo 8y agoI’d also posit it would be helpful for larger tech firms and most accelerators to have an ethecist on staff, to help with the “could we vs should we” evaluation.
- nsriv 8y agoIt would definitely be helpful from a corporate strategy perspective, but I think the real solution is educating engineers in the humanities or liberal arts.
- SamReidHughes 8y agoThat sounds like a great way to waste time and create barriers of entry to the field.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoBarriers to entry are not necessarily a negative. I want my doctor to have an "MD" credential as a barrier to providing me care, for example. Too many technologists with too little empathy and ethics makes the world dystopian "because I can" at scale.
- SamReidHughes 8y agoIf you can come up with a way to make people more moral that works, that sounds great. Right now I can't think of any.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoLegislation and regulation as a hard stop, ethics staff as guardrails.
- NateEag 8y agoLegislation does not make anyone more moral. It gives society the right and responsibility to punish people caught violating it. Those are two very different things.
- m4r35n357 8y agoIdiocracy
- cmehdy 8y agoIt's not just the metaphorical "tech" that suffers, it's also the candidates themselves. When you have empathy and you prefer thinking about your impact (on customers, on the environment, on current culture, etc), what is open to you is a long and arduous road. Applying to companies, the choice is limited. Creating products, there's extra inertia. Acquiring experience with these constraints is also mentally draining at times. Self-image can also take a hit, when your beliefs have you refuse easy ways towards prestige or money. You might walk with your head held high, but not necessarily have the savings or the opportunities that your friends have. There's a social cost to "doing the right thing" that not everyone is willing or able to pay. It takes a bit of luck to find the right places and projects, but to anyone out there facing similar struggles: continue believing in yourself. The system will come around eventually..
- TheJoYo 8y agoAh yes, we should tell engineers they need a behavior adjustment. This doesn't happen enough.
- stcredzero 8y agoAs a veteran programmer, I'd say that on average, engineers in the Bay Area do need an attitude adjustment. There are a lot of awesome people here, and bad behavior is an exception, but I've seen more douchey entitled behavior from Bay Area programmers than I have in the entire rest of my professional career. Another thing I seen too often from programmers, is a disdainful, even disgusted attitude when faced with negative feedback. The first reaction should be to try and understand where the feedback is coming from, not to disdain it. What I've seen too often, is a defensive retreat behind the idea that the feedback is coming from an idiot. The thing to remember about online idiots, is that a) most people aren't them, most of the time and b) even when someone is that, they are usually far different in real life.
- xvedejas 8y agoIs it the programmers/engineers that make the "incorrect" value judgements? It seems to me that it's usually the managers who are responsible for ethical gaps, and engineers are caught up in the act. That's the exact situation in which I would understand disdainful attitude.
- tomjen3 8y agoThe feedback typically comes from people who think they are smarter than the engineers, or who have more social capital and so are used to be looked up to and respected. As such they get pissy when nerds question them. Nerds tend to accept good solid feedback when a good reason is given; nerds rightly disregard feedback that is about pleasing peoples egos. Really smart nerds do strike a balance, but egos should be considered a flaw, and worked around as any other flaw.
- stcredzero 8y agoThe feedback typically comes from people who think they are smarter than the engineers I know exactly the kind of feedback of which you speak. I once hired a tester to test a 2D game with Asteroids movement mechanics. His feedback: "Where are the brakes? It doesn't go where I point it." Well, that's sort of the point of the Asteroids movement mechanic, and my tester didn't even bother to understand the point. Nerds tend to accept good solid feedback when a good reason is given; In my experience, not always. I've had a number of experiences where I explain my background as a fellow programmer, and I'm doing my level best at explaining in depth how I perceive a design as a user and why I'm reacting, and all too often, instead of getting clarifying questions or a reflection-back, I immediately get the start of some 'splainin. Conclusion jumped to after no iterations, and apparently after only a simple pattern-match. One time, I'd started explaining my reactions as a user, then got back a reply about the codebase. There were lots of changes to the UX, yet the major "plusses" for the change were from the POV of the programmer, and as a user, I'm left wondering, "What's in it for me?" Really smart nerds do strike a balance, but egos should be considered a flaw, and worked around as any other flaw. Most nerds never get past the point of only considering the egos of others to be a flaw.
- newtothebay 8y agoHumanities knowledge is just a tool which may and may not be used for good. FAANG already hires tons of humanities and social science PhDs to understand user behaviors. Whether that's used for good or ill depends on what the corporations are incentivized to do, not on the number of humanities grads employed. (I'm speaking as a social science PhD employed at FAANG.)
- freshhawk 8y agoSo the problem of the blindspots in STEM focused people and the fact that his leads them to just unthinkingly doing what they are told to do ... isn't a problem? Because it depends on what they are being told to do? I don't buy that, more humanities knowledge distributed among everyone is clearly needed, because our system ensures that the people at the top are more likely to use that knowledge for ill and the lower ranks knowing what is going on can be a check on that.
- Joe-Z 8y agoWhile it may be a problem that people „unthinkingly do what they are told to do“, I don‘t think requiring engineers to take an ethics class will fix that. What it does is give people the tools to properly articulate thoughts they are already having. It won‘t make someone an activist who just doesn‘t care.
- Fricken 8y agoMany of the people who go into STEM do so because they want to deal with the task put in front of them without it being complicated. They don't want to deal with a bunch of icky emotions, and they don't want to trip themselves up asking murky existential questions about why they're doing what they do. This is a condition of temperament, you can run them through a gristle mill of humanities classes, it doesn't mean they'll internalize it if it isn't what they're inclined towards. You can lead a horse to knowledge, but you can't make it think.
- 121789 8y agoI think your characterization of people who go into STEM is detracting from what could be an otherwise compelling argument. There are stronger reasons why people choose STEM. I agree that adding a few ethics classes won't change ethical behavior outcomes for those who would have chosen STEM programs anyway.
- fromthestart 8y agoAh, yes, need more humanities to combat wrongthink.
- xvedejas 8y agoI once attended a small scientific conference with a couple hundred attendees total. Over the two days of the conference there were many technical presentations to the full group, but two of the final presentations were non-technical. One presentation was from a science ethicist, who I believe was a professor at an Ivy-league school. It pained me to be in the audience for the ethicist's talk and following Q&A session. She was unable to provide any framework for thinking about ethics which the scientists present did not already have. The scientists asked direct questions about how to approach specific ethical issues they saw in their own work, and her responses were all along the lines of "well, the important thing is that you think hard about it." She displayed no ability to teach the scientists much, and no willingness to dive into discussion of their issues. Her presentation was a lot of the sort of thing that this article is trying to do: shaming STEM folks for their mistakes, and claiming the humanities is the cure-all. Let me make a claim: if the humanities are really a solution for problems created by STEM, all you should need to do is demonstrate the case. Technical and scientific crowds understand problems, and will jump on real solutions. (Aside: of the STEM undergraduate programs I'm aware of in the US, they all require somewhere between 20% and 50% of classes to be in the humanities or social sciences)
- tclancy 8y agoClearly she didn’t discuss the danger of extrapolating a trend line from a single datapoint.
- xvedejas 8y agoI make no claim as to whether competent science ethicists exist. Clearly this anecdote is a good example of what professors of humanities should try to avoid if they aim to fix problems in STEM.
- sprash 8y agoMost humanities do not understand or even argue against the concepts of statistics. It might well be that she even lacked the capabilities to make an argument like you just made.
- 8y ago
- jstewartmobile 8y agoA) Tech already hires psychologists to optimize mark fleecing. B) This is rich, coming from an exec at a "nonprofit" that gets most of its money from Google. C) Spend more time around humanities professors--no less ruthless than the engineers, but they can pull quotes from Foucault and Derrida to justify their own assholery. A less enlightened engineer would just have to accept that about himself.
- stcredzero 8y agoIn the US, there is a big problem with trying to get more balance in the STEM fields by introducing humanities education, in that the humanities in higher education are massively skewed to the left. https://www.ted.com/talks/jonathan_haidt_on_the_moral_mind https://www.ted.com/talks/jonathan_haidt_on_the_moral_mind Conservatives may understand human nature better than liberals: https://theindependentwhig.com/haidt-passages/haidt/haidt-conservatives-understand-human-nature-better-than-liberals/ https://theindependentwhig.com/haidt-passages/haidt/haidt-co...
- jekrb 8y agoA co-worker (and a great friend) of mine gave a lecture at University of Nebraska–Lincoln, on bridging the gap between the liberal arts and the tech industry. He talks about the value that liberal arts can provide the tech industry. In my opinion he is also giving rhetoric against this notion that you are tied to working in the same field that you studied at school, and that you have to follow the "correct" path that other people tell you is "marketable" for your career. We both studied liberal arts, and we both work together in tech. He got his PhD in Classical literature, and works on the strategy team. I am in my final semester for getting a BA in Philosophy, and I'm on the engineering team. If you listen to the lecture, around the 28min mark he says "I asked him, do you regret majoring in Philosophy?" My response is still the same now as it was when he asked me. I don't regret it, and I don't regret choosing it over computer science or a related major. I believe having the philosophy background helps me live a better life, and helps me do my job well. Ask certain academics in the philosophy department what exactly philosophy is, and they'll tell you something like: "the systematic testing of our rational beliefs about the world." This to me, is where philosophy and software engineering intersect. Link to the lecture: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4-wNv9FHLqM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4-wNv9FHLqM
- 121789 8y agoWell of course you don't regret majoring in philosophy, because your outcome is good (you are employed). I wonder what the other folks who had much more difficulty getting jobs would recommend. The lack of humanities seems to be mainly due to competitive factors and employers reducing risk. Assuming all other factors are equal, if you had only one spot to hire an entry-level software engineer, who would you take the risk on? The CS major or the philosophy major?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sprash 8y agoWhen their real goal is to "tackle misinformation" they should abolish any thinking prevalent in the humanities. If you want pure objective truth you need logic and evidence. Basically the tools that are employed by Math, Physics and Engineers. The concepts of Classical Positivism are over 100 years old and are still the best thing we got to find out the truth. In order to "tackle misinformation" humanities have zero solutions to offer. Any mediocre engineer would be better.
- mcphage 8y ago> In order to "tackle misinformation" humanities have zero solutions to offer. Any mediocre engineer would be better. Engineers are just as prone to misinformation as any other field. They just have more trouble recognizing it, due to a lack of training, and a mistaken belief they are immune.
- sprash 8y ago> Engineers are just as prone to misinformation as any other field. I would argue that this is exactly not the case because they know how to employ the scientific method. If humanities make all kinds of bold claims without providing logic and evidence engineers won't listen for very long. That is probably true. The problem is that "tackle misinformation" and "ethics" get conflated here. If you want to know the truth you have to employ the scientific method. Ethics on the other hand only contain very few "truths" and are mostly social convention. E.g. In some places of the world it is ethically perfectly correct to kill you daughter if she commits adultery. However there are some eternal truths that are correct for all different ethics out there, like the prisoner dilemma, contract/game theory and the fact that might is always right. The latter eternal truth is the one that are interesting and worth discussing. However the former parts of ethics are the ones discussed by humanities. Hence from the viewpoint of an engineer useless.
- tarboreus 8y agoHow do you know if your boss is mad at you? Or if someone is interested in you romantically? Or if a landscape is beautiful or ugly? Not all knowledge is gained through empirical methods. We know that because people had knowledge, including sophisticated technology, before there was a scientific method, i.e. before the 16th century. Most of our knowledge is gain through interpretation of the world...basically, doing the various things our minds do to arrive at conclusions. In the humanities, we (I am a humanist though also a programmer) try to hone our interpretive ability. We have a bunch of fancy names for ways to do that, like hermeneutics and dialectic and rhetoric, but basically you do it through practice. There's bad interpretive work, just like there's bad scientific work. But thinking empiricism is the be-all of knowledge is kind of silly. Do you use the scientific method to decide if you should kick a dog or pet it? Whether you beleive a politician's statement? Wheter a newspaper is trustworthy? No, you go through a process of modelling that other consciousness. That's interpretation.
- growlist 8y agoI'm not sure whether this is aimed at the Zuckerbergs of this world, or an attempt to shoehorn (yet more) leftist viewpoints into tech. Personally I'm just going to continue ploughing my autistic tech furrow until the entryists hopefully move on.
- caseysoftware 8y ago> "Technology companies need to diversify their hiring practices to include more people from backgrounds in philosophy and psychology if they want to tackle the problem of misinformation online, the head of one of the biggest internet charities has warned." If it's misinformation, shouldn't intelligent people of any background be able to identify and flag it? > "we are intentionally building the next generation of technologists who have not even the framework or the education or vocabulary to think about the relationship of Stem to society or humans or life." Oh. Because it's not about truth or critical thinking but frameworks and vocabulary.
- pjc50 8y ago> If it's misinformation, shouldn't intelligent people of any background be able to identify and flag it? Evidently not. Smart people from all sorts of backgrounds can fall for all sorts of scams, especially the ones tailored to them.
- cpeterso 8y agoFor examples of the consequences of big data and ML, check out mathematician Cathy O'Neill's book "Weapons of Math Destruction". She posits that the problematic systems share three key features: they are opaque, unregulated and difficult to contest, and at the same time scalable, thereby amplifying any inherent biases to affect increasingly larger populations. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weapons_of_Math_Destruction https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weapons_of_Math_Destruction
- pochamago 8y agoMozilla has been on a role lately of making statements that make me skeptical about the future of their browser. I just don't feel like every software I use needs to have a robust social policy behind it. I'm happy to just use something that works well
- SamReidHughes 8y agoWell there's a difference between MoFo and for-profit Mozilla.
- archagon 8y agoHow about just one? Just one browser with a robust social policy? Would that be so bad for the world?
- Nasrudith 8y agoThey keep on insisting this is the case but they never give reasons why and spend all of their time on the offensive. Cynically it looks like they want in on the action and are trying to extort what they want via character attacks instead of any merit. Like courting lobbyists. All while giving vague and unsubstantiated hype. Nobody needs such parasitic manipulators. Even the example is a terrible one as it shows a lack of technical knowledge and hype susceptibility. Machine learning is vulnerable to all about spurious correlations - that isn't lack of humanities but not understanding how to apply statistics and the limitations of the tools. Despite what statistics say Nicolas Cage doesn't drown people. http://tylervigen.com/view_correlation?id=359 http://tylervigen.com/view_correlation?id=359 That said a good understanding of history can act as a very good guide. Humanities may have their uses but their promoters never seem to be honest.
- SamReidHughes 8y agoThere are plenty of ways you could improve a random engineer. One for many guys would be to have played a team sport, or been in a marching band. Or something else outside the scholastic bubble. Another would be mandatory physical education in college.
- nyberg 8y agoI just find it interesting how they seem to find AI to be the issue half of the time when it just reflects what it's shown. The example near the end just reflects their internal process give or take mistakes in the initial design and method used.