3 ms·
This is unfortanate and I expected it for a while now. First OnePlus was exposed a while ago, then Blu, then maybe a few other smaller ones (can't remember, any
by pdimitar 8y ago
This is unfortanate and I expected it for a while now. First OnePlus was exposed a while ago, then Blu, then maybe a few other smaller ones (can't remember, anybody has links?), and now Huawei... I have to wonder if the companies aren't strong-armed by the Chinese government or they are all simply the same kind of greedy shady private info dealers. So it's quite likely Xiaomi will be exposed at some point as well.
I like Xiaomi. Owned two of their phones and it was the best ever Android experience for me -- not because of the iOS look-alike-ness. The devices were just very snappy, the default apps were very functional and comfortable to use and the whole thing just worked pretty well out of the box. I was pretty impressed, still am.
But I seriously don't trust the baseband vendors so I moved to the Apple ecosystem. Now I am left wondering if Apple is simply not better at hiding it if they are doing things like that (remember when they were caught recording the phone screen's activity and sending it to Uber?)...
Are we better off at the Apple side? Or should we all be buying an Xperia X and installing Sailfish OS on it?
- robin_reala 8y agoI don’t remember the Uber incident. Have you got any links to that?
- pdimitar 8y agoIt was even posted on HN about a year ago: https://www.businessinsider.com/uber-iphone-app-secret-access-sensitive-apple-features-2017-10 https://www.businessinsider.com/uber-iphone-app-secret-acces...
- robin_reala 8y agoThanks! I hadn’t seen that article, interesting stuff.
- emsy 8y agoI think you got that wrong. They allowed Uber to use the private API that allowed screen recording. Apple didn't record the activity and send it to Uber.
- pdimitar 8y agoThanks for the correction. You are right. Still doesn't make it better though, wouldn't you agree?
- saagarjha 8y agoSlightly, I’d say. The reason why Apple granted that entitlement was because the Apple Watch API wasn’t powerful enough to perform some of the rendering that Uber needed for their watch app, so they’d render it on iOS and send it over in order to have an app available on launch day. The irresponsibility is that Apple didn’t immediately revoke such access once they developed a replacement API for this use case.
- pdimitar 8y agoAll of that definitely makes sense. It just makes me afraid what possibilities does that open for Apple and any other corp they are willing to scratch of back of. :( It also makes you wonder what other kinds of these "entitlements" exist.
- saagarjha 8y agoAs far as entitlements go, I don’t think there are any others that Apple has given out. Private API, though, has been approved by Apple for use in certain apps.