4 ms·
The real issue is so far all the supporting evidence and theory says antimatter obeys normal rules of gravity. So it really is a long-shot experiment - if it ac
by XorNot 8y ago
The real issue is so far all the supporting evidence and theory says antimatter obeys normal rules of gravity. So it really is a long-shot experiment - if it actually differs in a significant way (and let's be clear: experiencing less gravity, going in a slightly different direction - anything - would be major) - then that would be a huge surprise.
- eganist 8y agoRight, and if it turns up nothing, what does it invalidate? ...well, nothing. The negative conclusion of this experiment doesn't achieve anything, and the aspirational conclusion is a colossal longshot. So more likely than not, time is wasted here (though it'd be cool if there were a Discovery, or even just a 3σ observation).
- blueprint 8y agoWhat evidence are you referring to which supports antimatter obeying "normal rules of gravity", by which I am presuming you mean gravitating in the same direction as matter?
- krastanov 8y agoThere is a very large and very convincing body of purely mathematical arguments, and some minor experimental work https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational_interaction_of_antimatter https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational_interaction_of...
- blueprint 8y agoFor some reason I had a feeling you'd post that. That wikipedia page doesn't show anything except for, at best, an argument that the Standard Model is incompatible with gravitational repulsion plus many statements of unsuccessful attempts to falsify repulsion of antimatter. Did you even read it?? By the way, it's old news by now that Standard Model is incomplete. But let's just go back to passive aggressively condescending to people we don't know on the internet by implying they've never studied so much as modern QFT because we're not prepared to understand their original argument.
- eganist 8y ago> But let's just go back to passive aggressively condescending to people we don't know on the internet Please stop accusing people of this; it's being observed as radiating from your own commentary by multiple people, which might explain why others are responding in kind. I called out the gaslighting elsewhere, and the fact that you're persisting with it against multiple parties hampers constructive discussion.
- blueprint 8y agoAre you not aware of his other comment to me? I've seen it many times before. We don't know each other so perhaps defer belief that you can tell whether that is true or not until you have some evidence. Gaslighting... lol
- krastanov 8y agoHow was I passive aggressive or condescending? I do believe you are misunderstanding what the math says about all of this, but I am eager to suggest textbooks that explain my point of view. I am suggesting textbooks not because I am condescending, rather because I can not give a meaningful arguments in a comment. And you are misrepresenting the wiki page. There is a large number of "though experiments" and a few actual experimental observations that make antigravity look implausible. Yes, there are loopholes (like in virtually any statement about fundamental physics) and we should devise experiments to test the loopholes, but when these loopholes are already implausible it is not unreasonable to put the majority of your resources in more interesting experiments. P.S. None of my comments have anything to do with the Standard Model and I do not see why you are bringing it in this conversation.
- blueprint 8y agoMisunderstanding what math? If I'm misrepresenting that wiki page, then how about actually getting specific for once in your comments. It shouldn't be so hard to point out one example with actual details and questions if there such a large number of them. P.S. If you think your comments about what is considered likely and not likely to CERN have nothing to do with the Standard Model then you really do need to read that wiki page again. I don't see a single substantial and actually relevant argument in your comments so far. If I'm missing something, again, let's get specific so I have something that tells me you know what we're even talking about here. Are you representing "tensor interactions" as somehow capable of sufficiently explaining gravity and its interactions with antimatter? And are you saying that CERN is using constraints on "tensor interactions" as their reasoning to deprioritize such an experiment? What are your qualifications in physics, by the way?