4 ms·
This is a semantic argument. The outcome depends on how you define "living". Any definition that includes fire (i.e. hot air) is so broad that it makes the wor
by smt88 8y ago
This is a semantic argument. The outcome depends on how you define "living".
Any definition that includes fire (i.e. hot air) is so broad that it makes the word "living" meaningless and useless. If you included fire, you'd perhaps have to include water or any other fluid.
- NavnitG 8y agoThe argument cannot be made for water as it does not respire or digest. Yes, the definition of life that fire fits in is broad. But it is still the definition of life.
- smt88 8y agoI don't know how you define "respire", but water dissolves and releases gases. Fire is a gas, so it can't "respire" the same way. It is just one gas or another. As for digestion, water is a powerful solvent that breaks many things down. Fire just heats them up, which may or may not change their chemical structure.