2 ms·
You're assuming you know more about evacuation planning and base design than the US Air Force. I think that's an unreasonable assumption. Some possibilities:
by mulmen 8y ago
You're assuming you know more about evacuation planning and base design than the US Air Force. I think that's an unreasonable assumption.
Some possibilities:
1) Nuclear hardened bunkers exist on base but were already full.
2) Nuclear response planning does not require planes to be stored in hardened bunkers.
3) The threat model for a nuke is different than a hurricane.
- CamperBob2 8y agoRegardless... these guys had a LOT of warning. Excuses don't seem credible.
- mulmen 8y ago72h is a lot of warning? It's not like they left everything behind. There was a large scale evacuation and a significant amount of hardware was moved without being lost. Do you have any indication that the evacuation was poorly planned or executed? Or that the base design was lacking? I'm not offering excuses. Hell, I'm not even suggesting the base design was satisfactory or that this damage is acceptable. I am offering possible explanations for why this amount of hurricane damage was sustained and why these specific air frames were not in "nuclear hardened bunkers". "I saw some bunkers somewhere" is a pretty poor excuse for criticism of a military installation's design, or anything really.
- onetimemanytime 8y ago>>72h is a lot of warning? It's not 72hours, but probably since ~ 1492 they knew that FL is hurricane country. They also know that x% of planes are always on maintenance and a certain amount of planes cannot evacuate to a safer base. And while not cheap, it's possible to make hurricane proof hangars. Someone dropped the ball and a lot of money was lost.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Numberwang 8y agoIt is completely obvious to everyone else that this outcome was predictable and that they did a bad job which will cost a lot of money. USAF is incompetent.
- ecocentrik 8y agoNot all hurricanes are equal. This was the most destructive hurricane to hit that region in recorded history (yet still weaker than the storm that took out Puerto Rico a year ago). The Florida panhandle has mostly been an infrequent target for slow and rainy cat 1 hurricanes every 20 years or so. Those storms take down some trees and power lines, and sometimes cause minor flooding. This was a strong cat 4 with heavy forward momentum and a significant storm surge, a 200+ year storm for the area. Nobody builds for highly unlikely events like this, they buy insurance.
- onetimemanytime 8y ago>>Nobody builds for highly unlikely events like this, they buy insurance. Building better ones I bet would be cheaper than year after year insurance on billion $ items
- syngrog66 8y agohurricanes happen every year. air base on coast of Florida. only a moron would design things so they dont have a reasonably hurricane safe place to protect aircraft on site. not hard. bumbling incompetence if not planned for.
- mulmen 8y agoIt seems disingenuous to me to criticize the US military for massive budgets while also expecting bases to be built to withstand a 200 year storm. Neither of us knows the detailed cost benefit analysis that went into hurricane preparedness at this base. No lives were lost and most of the F22s made it out, presumably a lot of the other assets did as well. Overall I’d say that’s a success. If our plan for a 200 year storm is “rebuild” I’m ok with that if the alternative is “spend more than rebuild costs to hurricane proof the base”.
- JohnBooty 8y ago72h is a lot of warning? That's a very disingenuous statement. Of course they had only 72h notice about this hurricane. But uh, is it really news that hurricanes roll through Florida with pretty regular frequency?
- mulmen 8y agoThis is the most powerful hurricane to strike the Florida panhandle in recorded history. So, uh, yeah, it’s news. It’s disingenuous to claim there was a huge failure in preparedness in an area with frequent storms while ignoring the efforts involved to evacuate and the severity of the storm. This evacuation successfully saved every person on base and a significant amount of hardware from a 200 year storm in... 72 hours.
- CamperBob2 8y ago72h is a lot of warning? It's about 71.5 more hours than they'll get from an enemy.
- mulmen 8y agoSurely the response plan for a hurricane is different than an enemy attack?
- CamperBob2 8y agoNo. Any airplanes you want to keep need to be off the ground either way. Not all of these planes were airworthy, of course, but that in itself is a bit of a problem, IMO.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]