5 ms·
My understanding is that although The Selfish Gene is undeniably brilliant, it's somewhat dated (which figures). In particular I believe most modern evolutiona
by MaxBarraclough 8y ago
My understanding is that although The Selfish Gene is undeniably brilliant, it's somewhat dated (which figures).
In particular I believe most modern evolutionary biologists don't put quite as much emphasis on the gene as the unit of evolutionary selection, the way Dawkins done.
Can anyone suggest a 'spiritual sequel'? Or am I just mistaken?
Edit I was surprised to see Daniel C Dennett in the list. Having those two chew things over would make for an awesome podcast. Pity.
- FabHK 8y agoI recently re-read it and didn't find it dated. I suppose if you've taken in its lessons, then it over-emphasises its point a bit, but consider that (as Pinker points out) "its main point still needs to be made 40+ years later. Most journalists, psychologists, and intellectuals commenting on natural selection still write as if it acts for the good of the group or the species, without even realizing they have said anything problematic or contentious." Also, the stuff on evolutionary stable strategies is very insightful and lucidly explained.
- juskrey 8y ago"Selfish gene" notion was debunked by Novak et al. Also Taleb extensively writes in his books about how this contradicts evolution.
- FabHK 8y agoI wouldn't give much stock in what Taleb writes about anything except options trading. Can you give a more specific reference to Novak et al.? I don't think the "Selfish Gene" has been "debunked", and find no reference to Novak eg at Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gene-centered_view_of_evolution#Criticisms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gene-centered_view_of_evolutio...
- oceanofsolaris 8y agoI think this refers to Nowak et al and I assume refers to the discussion mentioned in the Wikipedia article of the book (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Selfish_Gene#Units_of_selection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Selfish_Gene#Units_of_sele...).
- holowire 8y ago> I wouldn't give much stock in what Taleb writes about anything except options trading. Why do you say that? I’m broadly familiar with Taleb’s writing, but have yet to fully read any of his books. So I’m curious of your perspective here and what is informing that sentiment.
- tptacek 8y agoHe's a gadfly, not a scientist writing to popularize a field he actually does work in. (With the plausible exception of options trading).
- claytoneast 8y agoDo you think his central thesises around Black Swan events, tail risks, hedging, and skin-in-the-game principle for evaluating advice/statements, are not relevant to scopes beyond options trading? Note, I am not stating he is not a gadfly. He is, absolutely. But is he wrong?
- tptacek 8y agoI'd take him about as seriously as I take Wikipedia. Sometimes useful. Follow links to sources, evaluate those.
- AceyMan 8y agoWhether he's truly a gladly or not, you have to appreciate a guy who's self-aware enough about such opinions that he listed this quip first on the back cover of his latest book (from memory, mind you) — >The trouble with Taleb isn't that he's an asshole—he is an asshole. The trouble with Taleb is that he is right. Love that!
- nabla9 8y agoThe Novak et al. paper was heavily rebutted. https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2011/03/researchers-challenge-e-o-wilson-over-evolutionary-theory https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2011/03/researchers-challeng... http://ped.fas.harvard.edu/files/ped/files/nature09836.pdf http://ped.fas.harvard.edu/files/ped/files/nature09836.pdf
- throwaway837914 8y agoThe nature paper is not a rebuttal, it just says "hey look we did some studies, didn't they read those studies? We studied lots of things and came to conclusions." There's no modeling of the Wilson argument that is then proven to be wrong.
- amadeuspagel 8y agoWhat unit of selection other then the gene is there?
- sarosh 8y agoIn The Social Conquest of Earth (2012), the entomologist E. O. Wilson contends that although the selfish-gene approach was accepted "until 2010 [when] Martin Nowak, Corina Tarnita, and I demonstrated that inclusive fitness theory, often called kin selection theory, is both mathematically and biologically incorrect."[35] Chapter 18 of The Social Conquest of Earth describes the deficiencies of kin selection and outlines group selection, which Wilson argues is a more realistic model of social evolution. He criticises earlier approaches to social evolution, saying: "...unwarranted faith in the central role of kinship in social evolution has led to the reversal of the usual order in which biological research is conducted. The proven best way in evolutionary biology, as in most of science, is to define a problem arising during empirical research, then select or devise the theory that is needed to solve it. Almost all research in inclusive-fitness theory has been the opposite: hypothesize the key roles of kinship and kin selection, then look for evidence to test that hypothesis." According to Wilson: "People must have a tribe...Experiments conducted over many years by social psychologists have revealed how swiftly and decisively people divide into groups, and then discriminate in favor of the one to which they belong." (pp. 57, 59) According to Wilson: "Different parts of the brain have evolved by group selection to create groupishness." (p. 61) from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Selfish_Gene#Units_of_selection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Selfish_Gene#Units_of_sele...
- jamesrcole 8y agoYou can read Dawkins' response to it here http://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/magazine/edward-wilson-social-conquest-earth-evolutionary-errors-origin-species http://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/magazine/edward-wilson-soc... This part is worth noting: I would not venture such strong criticism of a great scientist were I not in good company. The Wilson thesis is based on a 2010 paper that he published jointly with two mathematicians, Martin Nowak and Corina Tarnita. When this paper appeared in Nature it provoked very strong criticism from more than 140 evolutionary biologists, including a majority of the most distinguished workers in the field. They include Alan Grafen, David Queller, Jerry Coyne, Richard Michod, Eric Charnov, Nick Barton, Alex Kacelnik, Leda Cosmides, John Tooby, Geoffrey Parker, Steven Pinker, Paul Sherman, Tim Clutton-Brock, Paul Harvey, Mary Jane West-Eberhard, Stephen Emlen, Malte Andersson, Stuart West, Richard Wrangham, Bernard Crespi, Robert Trivers and many others. These may not all be household names but let me assure you they know what they are talking about in the relevant fields.
- theoh 8y agoIt's only a pity if you can't be bothered to Google "pinker dennett" and find multiple recordings of the pair in conversation.
- MaxBarraclough 8y agoYou can spare me the snark next time, but thanks. I'd assumed it didn't exist as, from what I can tell, Dennett isn't usually one for that kind of thing.
- theoh 8y agoI try not to be snarky, but only because it invites downvotes. Your "pity" comment came across as sententious. What do you mean by "that kind of thing"? Searching for " conversation with Daniel dennett" returns more appearances, on podcasts, with Dawkins, with W.V.O. Quine, with Sam Harris. Dennett is a big self-promoter even by the standards of academic celebrities. Dennett and Pinker are both massively overrated and past their sell-by dates IMO. But instead of having a substantive discussion that might enrich this thread you seem to be intent on low-effort idle speculation about what kinds of public appearance Dennett might or might not be keen on. It is exasperating.
- MaxBarraclough 8y agoYou're right, he's more publicly active than I'd thought. Now to find a good video of him fighting it out over his 'multiple drafts' theory of mind.