8 ms·
> “We care about markets,” Mr. Di Maio said in a television interview last week. But faced with a choice between bond yields and the Italian people, he added, “
by Nasrudith 8y ago
> “We care about markets,” Mr. Di Maio said in a television interview last week. But faced with a choice between bond yields and the Italian people, he added, “I choose the Italian people.”
That demagogic rhetoric comes up commonly and it makes the same fundamental mistake or perhaps not wanting to understand that serving your creditors serves you as long as you need credit. The consequence for defaulting is not getting any more loans. Setting up an unsustainable system is setting up for a nasty fall.
Reminds me of some claiming that Greece being able to print the drachma would give them an easy out to their crisis. Even if they did it just plain wouldn't work last I heard Greece was still very dependent on imports for things like pharmaceuticals. Hyper-inflating their own currency relative to growth would not be a solution - it does nothing for the cost of imports which they depend upon and is worse than disease it is meant to cure. Less extreme inflation relative to economic growth could boost relative competitiveness of labor costs is their own slight advantage but even that would call for a decline in standard of living as a corollary.
Which brings to mind a thing about loans in general and fiscal wisdom - one should take out a loan only if it is an investment in some way - either generating more money or reducing long-term expenses in some way. It may in fact go bust but it has actual potential to pay for itself. The same seems like it would apply to countries and investments can also include some humanitarian purposes - a healthy and well educated workforce can generate more and is a case of everyone wins.
- sgt101 8y ago> Less extreme inflation relative to economic growth could boost relative competitiveness of labor costs is their own slight advantage but even that would call for a decline in standard of living as a corollary. The question is do you focus on the "real" economy or the spreadsheet? If you are able to devalue and take the increase of import costs and generate competitive advantage by adding more value at a lower cost then the possibility is that your real economy will grow. More activity will create more actual wealth, which will help your fiscal position and restore standards of living over time. There are a lot of dependencies there, but there is a possible out. On the other hand you can do what happened in Greece, stand behind the currency, slash spending. The problem is that this cuts the real economy without improving competitiveness. The Greek solution (and IMF standard) is to liberalise, sell assets and introduce more market activity into controlled sectors. The problem with this is that you have to actually do it and not just talk (Greece largely hasn't) and also while sometimes it has worked it seems that the precondition for it working has to be that the sectors in question are healthy and straining at the leash... which is not the case in crisis economies in general.
- RobertoG 8y ago"[..] and also while sometimes it has worked [..]" Can you give us some examples where this IMF standad solution has worked?
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoBritain in 1976, I think it was the first bailout by the IMF and was controversial at the time.
- sgt101 8y agoUK 1976, Mexico 1980's, India and Kenya in the 1980's too. It's a pretty dire record though. I think that it's easy to argue that where there have been positive results that's mostly by accident. The UK is the best example of this - there was an IMF rescue and liberalisation but also an oil discovery which recapitalised the commercial base of the country and allowed an infrastructure building program.
- intended 8y agoIf you are betting on an Indian styled recovery, then your odds are exceedingly low. Not only did we have a great economist as finmin, but also a lot of people who grew up to later take on major roles as bureaucrats and politicians. And all of that worked because we had a PM who was able to thread the needle and make it work without giving in to any political group. It’s a very very small window, and the resulting growth was pent up demand being brought online.
- sgt101 8y agoI couldn't agree more; as I said, the record is dire and where it's been seen to work I think a counter factual can be constructed that could have produced as good or better results. That's not to say that the IMF couldn't do far better, just not by using the formula of fail that they've stuck to for the last fifty years. Greece is going to be the proof point for me - all of the pain no gain at all. I give it eighteen months.
- RobertoG 8y ago"[..] That demagogic rhetoric comes up commonly and it makes the same fundamental mistake or perhaps not wanting to understand that serving your creditors [..]" Insisting that the path taken with Greece was the good decision is what looks like demagogic rhetoric to me: -In a country of 10 million persons, half a million have immigrated (probably the young and with more studies). -They had a fall of their economy bigger than the USA in the Great Depression, for longer. -They had been (and are being) forced to sell assets that belong to all the Greeks. -Their industrial capacity is in its way to disappear totally. -Of course, the quality of life have fall and unemployment is very high. -Their economy have been directed by foreign powers. -All the previsions done from the IMF, EuroArea and company were totally wrong. -Their public debt is the same, if not bigger, that when the crisis started. So, my question: what have to happen for you understanding that the option taken was wrong?
- choeger 8y agoCounter question: what would have been the alternative? Default, exit €, and then all of the above but worse? I know that there are lots of people out there that think more debt is just the answer, but consider two things: 1. Your today's debt is other people's pension fund. So with what right shall a Greek pensioner retain her quality of life at the expense of a Dutch pensioner? 2. Exiting the Euro would undoubtedly shut down imports. At least for a while it would be effectively the same as cutting wages, savings, and pensions by some massive margin. Also the state would have no one to lend money from just after a default. Hence it would be forced into an even stronger austerity program.
- rdm_blackhole 8y ago> Default, exit €, and then all of the above but worse? Says who? The economists who did not even seen the financial crisis coming and were clamoring that the real estate market was solid and totally fine even as late as 2007?? Just wondering...
- FabHK 8y agoThe troika's handling of Greece was despicable, vengeful, irrational, and counterproductive. > what would have been the alternative? An early writedown of some debt and extension of other, enabling the economy to return to growth and service the remaining debt. Re 1.: Pension funds and other institutional investors invest in equity and debt world wide, taking into account risk and return. Sometimes they make mistakes (or even not - sometimes the dice fall badly), and an investment goes sour. That's the market at work. In this case, however, European put massive amounts of money into Greece that were not used to prop up the economy, but to bail out investments by German and French banks. So, basically a transfer from the European tax payer to some banks. 2. It would make imports very expensive, but free up the domestic economy and make it more competitive. "Optimum currency area" describes what's necessary for a currency union: homogeneity wrt external shocks (not the case in the EU), high factor mobility (limited in the EU, due to language/culture), or internal transfer payments. In my view, Europe sat down for a nice dinner (10 years ago with the introduction of the Euro) in a restaurant and enjoyed it over a decade (with massive growth financed by cheap debt in many "peripheral" countries), and when the bill came (oops, we need these internal transfers now) - refused to pay. Shameful.
- cinquemb 8y ago>That demagogic rhetoric comes up commonly and it makes the same fundamental mistake or perhaps not wanting to understand that serving your creditors serves you as long as you need credit. The consequence for defaulting is not getting any more loans. Yeah, idk. How many times has Argentina defaulted in the past 100 years? How many times has the IMF swooped in for that basket case and others like it? All this means is that their yields will go up, and make it super attractive vs holding stocks, esp if you can lock in fx rates with forwards contracts on the EURUSD.
- tonyedgecombe 8y ago>All this means is that their yields will go up This isn't a small thing for Argentina.
- cinquemb 8y agoOk fair, but the come down from the ZLB high isn't going to be pretty anywhere, except for those who managed to see past the smoke and mirrors in inflated asset prices in all markets and incredible mis-allocation of resources the world has been engaged in… and even then, they will still have to deal with the fallout of those who took the bait (or "elected" people who took the bait on their behalf) and will be pissed… as we're seeing now all over the world today, and these were supposed to be the good times lol /me sighs
- Al-Khwarizmi 8y agoThe rethoric you cite is indeed somewhat demagogic, but the idea that "the consequence for defaulting is not getting any more loans" is disingenous. Most countries in the world have had sovereign defaults, often several times throughout their history. See, for example, the map at https://katapult-magazin.de/en/artikel/artikel/fulltext/stony-broke-over-and-over/ https://katapult-magazin.de/en/artikel/artikel/fulltext/ston... Spain defaulted 9 times, Portugal and Greece 6 times, Germany 5 times, the UK 4 times. They still get loans now.
- gebruikersnaam 8y ago> Spain defaulted 9 times This was all before 1900 though, things have changed quite a bit since then.
- ItsMe000001 8y agoThey have? Details, sure, like structure of debt and who the creditors are (things like the IMF didn't exist previously), but countries still default. https://www.rstreet.org/2016/02/22/countries-dont-go-bankrupt-the-20th-century-proves-otherwise/ https://www.rstreet.org/2016/02/22/countries-dont-go-bankrup... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_debt_crises https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_debt_crises https://www.bankofcanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/r101-revised-june2017.pdf https://www.bankofcanada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/r101-... In any case, defaulting on debt is completely natural. It is what's part of how the system is supposed to work. If lenders didn't pay attention, out of lack of knowledge or willfully, and the debtor cannot repay, that's it. There has been a very successful campaign that strengthened the side of the lenders, big and small, over many decades - not necessarily consciously and deliberately (not a concerted effort). It's been successfully made into a moral issue.
- kazen44 8y agoAlso, most of these nations defaulted because of vast political and societal changes. (russia has defaulted many times on it's debt thanks to the soviet revolutions and dissolution of the USSR for example).
- 8y ago
- Tsubasachan 8y agoItaly is banking on the welfare Northern Europe is giving them. Not unlike how California and New York pay for the US. If Italy can't lend money they are finished and they know it. Politicians don't believe their own words.
- acifani 8y agoWhat welfare are you talking about? Italy has been a net payer [0] in EU contributions from since I could remember [0] https://www.cbs.nl/en-gb/news/2016/50/netherlands-largest-net-contributor-eu-this-century https://www.cbs.nl/en-gb/news/2016/50/netherlands-largest-ne...
- Tsubasachan 8y agoThe biggest welfare is being in the same political Union as better functioning economies. I shudder to think how expensive it would be for Italy to raise money on the international bond market if it wasn't for the ECB.
- beerlord 8y agoMore than offset by the ability to control their own currency and interest rates. They could immediately print away their external debts, for example.
- kome 8y agoYou are factually wrong.