8 ms·
Tyndall F-22s, Left Behind Before Michael Hit, Possibly Damaged Beyond Repair
- mothsonasloth 8y agoI would have thought the base would have some nuclear hardened hangars for storing planes? IANAP (I am not a pilot/military) but the airbases near me in Scotland have bunkers like [these](https://i.pinimg.com/736x/9e/24/8f/9e248f941d40fca8e947c4a57d6c45bc.jpg https://i.pinimg.com/736x/9e/24/8f/9e248f941d40fca8e947c4a57...) for storing RAF Tornados and Typhoons. Hopefully this loss will be a lesson to the USAF
- mulmen 8y agoYou're assuming you know more about evacuation planning and base design than the US Air Force. I think that's an unreasonable assumption. Some possibilities: 1) Nuclear hardened bunkers exist on base but were already full. 2) Nuclear response planning does not require planes to be stored in hardened bunkers. 3) The threat model for a nuke is different than a hurricane.
- CamperBob2 8y agoRegardless... these guys had a LOT of warning. Excuses don't seem credible.
- mulmen 8y ago72h is a lot of warning? It's not like they left everything behind. There was a large scale evacuation and a significant amount of hardware was moved without being lost. Do you have any indication that the evacuation was poorly planned or executed? Or that the base design was lacking? I'm not offering excuses. Hell, I'm not even suggesting the base design was satisfactory or that this damage is acceptable. I am offering possible explanations for why this amount of hurricane damage was sustained and why these specific air frames were not in "nuclear hardened bunkers". "I saw some bunkers somewhere" is a pretty poor excuse for criticism of a military installation's design, or anything really.
- onetimemanytime 8y ago>>72h is a lot of warning? It's not 72hours, but probably since ~ 1492 they knew that FL is hurricane country. They also know that x% of planes are always on maintenance and a certain amount of planes cannot evacuate to a safer base. And while not cheap, it's possible to make hurricane proof hangars. Someone dropped the ball and a lot of money was lost.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Numberwang 8y agoIt is completely obvious to everyone else that this outcome was predictable and that they did a bad job which will cost a lot of money. USAF is incompetent.
- ecocentrik 8y agoNot all hurricanes are equal. This was the most destructive hurricane to hit that region in recorded history (yet still weaker than the storm that took out Puerto Rico a year ago). The Florida panhandle has mostly been an infrequent target for slow and rainy cat 1 hurricanes every 20 years or so. Those storms take down some trees and power lines, and sometimes cause minor flooding. This was a strong cat 4 with heavy forward momentum and a significant storm surge, a 200+ year storm for the area. Nobody builds for highly unlikely events like this, they buy insurance.
- onetimemanytime 8y ago>>Nobody builds for highly unlikely events like this, they buy insurance. Building better ones I bet would be cheaper than year after year insurance on billion $ items
- syngrog66 8y agohurricanes happen every year. air base on coast of Florida. only a moron would design things so they dont have a reasonably hurricane safe place to protect aircraft on site. not hard. bumbling incompetence if not planned for.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- orasis 8y agoSo one got, like, a flat tire?
- miguelrochefort 8y agoBelgium, too, is having trouble with their fighter jets (#1 post on HN at the moment): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18211632 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18211632
- walrus01 8y agoNot coincidental at all, found it linked from a forum that was also discussing the F16.
- lwansbrough 8y agoThere goes 12 hours worth of the defense budget.
- crazy_monkey 8y agoClearly a conspiracy to get taxpayers to buy 12 hours more planes...
- jbverschoor 8y agoWow, that's actually correct according to wikipedia In FY 2017, the Congressional Budget Office reported spending of $590 billion for defense, about 15% of the federal budget.[1] For the FY 2019 president Donald Trump proposed an increase to the military to $681.1 billion. [2]
- liquidise 8y ago1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_States#Total_budget_by_department https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_... 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_... I assume you are being downvoted for failing to actually include your footnotes.
- metaphor 8y ago...except the statement is pure bullshit given the assets weren't actually lost.
- walrus01 8y ago... except that they were, the aviation industry term for an aircraft that has been damaged beyond economical repair is "hull loss" https://www.google.com/search?client=ubuntu&channel=fs&q=aviation+hull+loss&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8 https://www.google.com/search?client=ubuntu&channel=fs&q=avi...
- metaphor 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dizziest 8y agoSince this amount of money lost isn't outrageous to the Air Force, what was keeping them from moving the planes we paid for, and spending the ~billion dollars on us and our pursuit of happiness, liberty, and life?
- andreasley 8y agoFrom the article: "The F-22s left behind could not fly for either mechanical or safety reasons, said a spokeswoman, who also said all the hangars on base were damaged."
- dizziest 8y agoSo we didn't budget for maintenance?
- specializeded 8y agoFrom the article: ““One of them was scheduled to leave but GABed [ground aborted] after an issue prior to taxi. The other three were jets that couldn't be spun up in time to fly.” Two had been cannibalized for parts, he said, and the others had “issues that couldn't be fixed. They were in hangars that [they] are usually put in according to hurricane plans.””
- dizziest 8y agoSo we budgeted for maintenance, but no one cared to fix the planes we paid for? ...costing us ~$1billion
- andkenneth 8y agoA certain percentage of these planes are always on the ground being repaired. They rotate in and out of flight readiness. What's important is that enough planes are ready for their missions at any one time, not that ALL the planes are ready.
- 8y ago
- elitistphoenix 8y agoIf only they could have just flown somewhere else!
- kolderman 8y agoDoes that $1b replacement cost include the cost of restarting the f22 assembly line?
- acjohnson55 8y agoThere's many billions more dollars where that came from.
- emayljames 8y agoKarma.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoLook at it this way - climate change is making the job of keeping a functional military harder and harder - something that may help focus minds as much as IPCC reports.
- patrickg_zill 8y agoPlease cite a good source for this assertion. With hard numbers, not conjecture.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoWhich assertion? Losing a billion dollars of planes because of weather? I know it is only a billion (a drop in the ocean for the military) but if a adversary had knocked out three F-22s they would be considered a national threat. Treat the weather like a potential national security threat is what I am saying.
- patrickg_zill 8y agoThere has been stormy weather across the planet, for as long as we know of. Climate change or no...
- sdrothrock 8y agoI really love the statement from the colonel in charge of the base; it's clear, concise, and conveys his message perfectly. > Wing Command Col. Brian Laidlaw said in a statement Friday the base was "better than yesterday, and that is how it is going to continue to be. We will continue to persevere." I like it so much that I really just want to make it a motto to live by: "things are better than yesterday and that is how I will continue to make them."
- yesenadam 8y agoThere was an state re-election campaign here in New South Wales, Australia 10 or 20 years ago run under the slogan More to do but heading in the right direction which was widely mocked for being particularly uninspiring. I still quote it all the time - hardly a week goes by when it can't be amusingly slipped into conversation hehe. (Usually to helpfully complete someone's attempt to describe the state of a situation they're working on.)
- robbiep 8y agoThe most outrageous part of the 2007 election was that they won. State politics is so unbelievably uninspiring
- Denvercoder9 8y agoThere's something to say for boring politics.
- marktangotango 8y agoAs a US-er I would cherish that boredom. Our politics are insane.
- onetimemanytime 8y agoStatements now aren't worth that much. The person in charge should have thought of these things, at least someone should have. It's not like the hurricane happened in Colorado so at least shelters should have been hurricane proof.
- metaphor 8y agoTyndall didn't lose $1bil in F-22 assets; the HN title of this article is pure clickbait. No other state takes hurricane evacuation more seriously than Florida. This article[1] posits that Tyndall has 55 F-22s divided between two training squadrons. If only 4 were left behind, that's 93% brought to NMCM Airworthy status or better, which is mindblowingly effective. [1] http://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/24204/setting-the-record-straight-on-why-fighter-jets-cant-all-simply-fly-away-to-escape-storms http://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/24204/setting-the-recor...
- walrus01 8y agoIt is correct English grammar to say that an asset which has been damaged beyond economical repair has been "lost", this is used in the shipping and aviation industries all the time. "Hull loss" incident, "airframe loss", etc. See for example the delightyfully 1997-vintage-looking website of cargo loss: http://www.cargolaw.com/gallery.html http://www.cargolaw.com/gallery.html Most commonly encountered when talking about an insured asset. In the case of military owned equipment, there is no insurance company, so the DoD takes the loss themselves.
- metaphor 8y agoTo be sure, your remark is directed towards a 10-year U.S. Air Force veteran who holds intimate familiarity with active duty military flightline operations. Until full damage assessment has been completed and Class A incident reports filed, asserting that these aircraft have been lost is utter bullshit.
- Denvercoder9 8y agoExcept no one has said those F-22s are damaged beyond economical repair. That's just speculation at this point.
- Theodores 8y agoThe products are 'out of warranty' and effectively antiques. The article states how much it would cost to get the tooling back to make more of the planes and you would be looking at spending billions to make replacements. There is no 'series production' going on and therefore that means that 'maintenance' is more like 'restoration' with these dubious machines. I wonder if it would make more sense and provide as much utility if the Air Force just settled for a fleet of classic concept cars. It wasn't as if the Air Force was of any use whatsoever on that day seventeen years ago when action stations was actually needed.
- jeswin 8y agoI am curious what reasons there could be for the planes to be immovable by road. F22 has a 13.56m wingspan. Would it make sense to build trucking platforms for such contingencies? PS: I have no knowledge in the subject, just curious.
- metaphor 8y agoFrom this article[1]: Throwing jets on flatbed trucks? People don't realize how large of a flying machine a Raptor is. They are roughly 44 feet wide, 62 feet long, and weigh over 43,000lbs. They are not something you just throw on pop's flatbed and skidaddle out of dodge. Nor are they made to be transported that way in the first place. And to where? You are talking about a highly sensitive asset packed with classified material. Its skin treatment alone presents a national secret risk. These aircraft are supposed to sit in last minute hurricane traffic heading somewhere as they hog up multiple lanes? The whole notion is ridiculous. And if they can't seek refuge in time, you have a flying machine strapped to a flatbed. Good luck with that. [1] http://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/24204/setting-the-record-straight-on-why-fighter-jets-cant-all-simply-fly-away-to-escape-storms http://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/24204/setting-the-recor...
- code_duck 8y ago“You are talking about a highly sensitive asset packed with classified material.” Ok, let’s leave it to be destroyed by weather then
- gambiting 8y agoEven once destroyed it's still within the base that is presumably still guarded. Once out of the base on a flatbed the risks of losing any part of it are much greater.
- code_duck 8y agoGetting an intact plane to safety would be far less of a risk of losing parts than letting it be destroyed in a flood.
- biehl 8y agoOne cannot put an F-22 on a truck and drive it to safety?
- mulmen 8y agoNot if all the trucks are busy moving other assets.
- x0x0 8y agoAnd particularly on 72h notice.
- LyndsySimon 8y agoToo tall, too wide, and too heavy for that to be practical.
- skookumchuck 8y agoLooks like it's time to upgrade building codes. I wonder what it would take to make 150mph winds survivable by homes and hangars.
- gonzo41 8y agoLots and lots of concrete. Which isn't that expensive if you've going to rebuild a state. The bigger problem for Florida is that it has no high terrain to absorb the hit. Britton Hill is a mere 345 feet above sea level. Which makes Florida a big sand bar that storms just roll over.
- skookumchuck 8y agoI would start with using screws/bolts instead of nails holding the wood to the foundation. It takes a lot to pull that loose. The other problem is the roof being lifted off from suction. I would bet that bolting it to the frame would stop a lot of that. With relatively minor changes like that, an ordinary wood frame house should be considerably stronger.
- noir_lord 8y agoAll that stuff exists, you can get re-enforced roof and truss connections and hurricane ties to upgrade existing buildings. The issue is as always cost, people operate on a "why spend the money it may never happen" risk model generally and are averse to dealing with a problem til it punches them (personally) in the face, I mean this isn't new, as a species we don't deal with things until it gets to the brink. If you want a fascinating example of this in the general case read up on the Clean Air Act in the UK. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_Air_Act_1956 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clean_Air_Act_1956
- skookumchuck 8y agoThat's why there's building codes. After all, I don't want the wreckage from your house smashing into mine.
- 8y ago
- burfog 8y agoIt's easy to find better solutions given that we now know the hangers would fail. It's cheating to know that. For example, a probable solution would be to place the aircraft far from things likely to become flying debris, then add sandbags... lots of sandbags. Park the planes on the runway, then add enough sandbags to divert the wind over the top. I'd take that chance if I knew that the hangar would fail, but again, that is cheating.
- new_guy 8y agoExpecting basic competence isn't 'cheating'. They're planes. Fly them out of the way, it's not rocket science.
- dba7dba 8y agoBut these F22 were not fly able for whatever reason, mostly due to maintenance.
- mcny 8y agoI agree with you but maybe we're missing some facts? I don't know if Delta lied to me but the excuse they gave me one time or flight was delayed was that some lights in the cabin were not working so they have to do electrical inspection. They eventually gave us all alternative flight on American (after having us wait until 4 PM with an initial departure if 9AM). Point is, we don't know if the planes were in flight ready state, do we? It could be something simple but I'd not risk my officer's life just to save a plane. My apologies if the planes were indeed flight certified.
- mulmen 8y agoThe article states these planes were not airworthy.
- 7952 8y agoI wonder if a fighter jet would be damaged by the wind alone (ignoring debris) as long as it is tied down. Naively a fighter jet is already designed to cope with high speed air flow.
- JohnBooty 8y agoIt takes a lot to make me furious, but I'm furious. These morons built an Air Force base with billions of hardware in hurricane territory, and were caught flat-footed by a hurricane because apparently there were no adequate plans for what to do when a hurricane approached? Jesus christ. Those planes are irreplaceable. F-22 production has ceased, so it's not like they can order up some more. And considering the problems with the F-35s, those F-22s are some of the only capable 5th-gen fighters we're likely to have for a longggggggg time. (I understand that most of the places were apparently evacuated, but it's tough to swallow any significant loss of those very expensive pieces of hardware due to inadequate planning)
- metaphor 8y ago> due to inadequate planning Seeing as you've had the opportunity to thoroughly evaluate Tyndall's emergency hurricane evacuation procedures, the airworthiness of 55 aircraft divided between two squadrons, O&M/MILCON budget of a training base, and logistical impediments arising from 72-hours notice coupled with a swarm of evacuating civilians from surrounding areas, please do take the time to enlighten us all.
- JohnBooty 8y agoWhat are you saying here? Are you saying that their plans were adequate? Clearly they weren't; they lost at least a handful of irreplaceable planes. Or are you saying that there was just no way to predict or prepare for a hurricane hitting an airbase right in the middle of hurricane country? I mean, a lot of hurricanes roll through that part of the country. the airworthiness of 55 aircraft divided between two squadrons, My "evaluation" is what the article says. Namely, that the planes left behind weren't airworthy. If you know otherwise, let's hear it. I'm no military brain genius, but it seems obvious to me that at any given time less than 100% of the planes at any given airbase would be airworthy and that perhaps some provision should be made for sheltering or evacuating these planes if a hurricane rolls through this base which, again, is located in a very hurricane-prone region. O&M/MILCON budget of a training base I'd think that the cost of making sure you don't lose a billion dollars worth of fighters every time a hurricane rolls through a hurricane-prone area probably costs less than, I don't know, a billion dollars.