3 ms·
> It seems pretty strange that they can do this. How does copyright even apply here, other than for the defendant? If I buy a book [...] It might be significan
by tzs 8y ago
> It seems pretty strange that they can do this. How does copyright even apply here, other than for the defendant? If I buy a book [...]
It might be significant that in this case it is not a book. Copyright is a bundle of different rights, and some of them usually only come up for certain kinds of media.
In particular, one of the rights in the bundle is the right to publicly perform the work. Perhaps broadcasting playing the game could violate the performance right?
> Could someone prevent you from running a service where someone mails you a book, you cut out some pages and replace them, and then mail it back? I don't think so.
I wouldn't be so sure. Here are two cases, both involving a company that apparently buys works of art, mounts them on ceramic, and sells the result.
In the first case [1] they bought books containing good quality prints, removed the prints from the book, mounted each print separately, and sold the tiles separately.
The 9th Circuit found that this was a derivative work and was infringing.
In the second case [2] it was apparently again the same company buying and mounting art. This time the works they bought and mounted and sold were notecards and small lithographs. The 7th Circuit said that this was not a derivative work and not infringing.
[1] https://openjurist.org/856/f2d/1341/mirage-editions-inc-v-albuquerque-art-co https://openjurist.org/856/f2d/1341/mirage-editions-inc-v-al...
[2] https://www.law.cornell.edu/copyright/cases/125_F3d_580.htm https://www.law.cornell.edu/copyright/cases/125_F3d_580.htm