3 ms·
This doesn't seem all that scammy to me. The genius bar person was forthright that they needed to replace the components because they have a full repair only po
by ummonk 8y ago
This doesn't seem all that scammy to me. The genius bar person was forthright that they needed to replace the components because they have a full repair only policy and the water damage indicators were red. He was forthright that this wasn't necessarily the cause of the display issue. He also did hint at other repair shops in the end by saying that there were no other options "in terms of fixing it in the store".
- kbenson 8y agoThe full repair only policy is not really a problem. Apple wants to make sure they give you back a functioning device, so people aren't walking around saying they got their Apple repaired and it's still broken (or breaks quickly afterwards). The full repair only policy while actively trying to prevent third party repair services is a problem, as then you are preventing people from being able to repair only actual problems just because Apple wants to control its image, and you run into situations like this. Who cares if water indicators are tripped? There should be an options for someone to repair what's needed, and deal with further problems later if they crop up. Apple doesn't want to allow this. > He also did hint at other repair shops in the end by saying that there were no other options "in terms of fixing it in the store". That's not hinting at other options, that's just not outright lying when asked a direct question, which ends up revealing another option. That's a low bar to hit (and thankfully he did).
- Someone1234 8y agoYou're arguing that it isn't "scammy" because the policy that Apple itself created sets a rigid structure that causes repairs to be more extensive and expensive? Essentially a policy replacing completely working components without testing them, because a 5c Liquid contact indicator said to. This seems like a defense of the individual "Genius," since they can point at corporate/policy, rather than a defense of the policy itself which is what the video is about.
- evanslify 8y agoI’ve been told otherwise; Is this full repair policy a “by-country” thinng?