5 ms·
There are a few things that give me pause about progressive visions of the future, but the biggest one is just the sheer terrifying demographics of it. The pre
by philwelch 8y ago
There are a few things that give me pause about progressive visions of the future, but the biggest one is just the sheer terrifying demographics of it.
The predominant culture of the developed world is catastrophically infertile. The more progressive parts of these cultures are often the least fertile, while the more conservative and traditional parts are more fertile. But the offspring of these traditional subcultures often convert into the progressive culture, at least where that culture is more prosperous and holds higher perceived status.
Part of what makes religions so persistent is their evolutionary fitness from a memetic perspective. “Tell everyone you know to worship $DEITY, have lots of babies, and also kill/shun anyone who tries to stop worshipping $DEITY” is a great algorithm for maximizing the number of $DEITY-worshippers. “Never have sex or try to convert anyone” is a shitty algorithm, which is why the Shakers are practically extinct while Islam is on course to become the world’s largest religion (and may already be, if you subtract the plurality of western Christians who are behaviorally secular anyway).
I suspect some memetic program that survives contact with science, prosperity, and progressivism without turning infertile, if it ever evolves, will be the foundation of the future of human culture.
- labster 8y ago> the developed world is catastrophically infertile I read that more as "have defused the population bomb". Cultures that have less children have more wealth to pass on to their children, making each one more likely to survive. The rest of the world having tons of children is likely to face shortages of land, water, food, health care... etc. This leads to all sorts of instability, which I'm sure you can imagine. The thing is, liberalism has a lot of memetic fitness too. Classical liberalism has been devouring the world for the past few centuries, and while it occasionally suffers setbacks, it's done very very well against kings, dictators, popes, shoguns, and the like trying to hold it back. Just because liberalism is in a decline now doesn't mean that it's lost its power.
- philwelch 8y agoThe good thing about extinction is that it indeed defuses the population bomb. Rich liberal societies consistently reproduce at less than replacement. This is obviously unsustainable; a population that doesn’t reproduce fast enough to replace itself will go extinct. Obviously unsustainable growth isn’t a great thing either, but as long as the rate of growth is low enough for technology to keep up, the earth can actually sustain a surprisingly high population in comfortable conditions. The limiting factor turns out to be energy.
- labster 8y agoBut exponential human population growth is currently unsustainable, and has been for the last 70 years. Global warming is proof that the are using ecosystem services faster than they can be replenished, which is having cascading effects across trophic levels. We're in the middle of a mass extinction. In order to get down to levels of human population that we should have, the nonviolent solution is to drop reproduction below replacement rate for a few generations. This is good. Why on earth do people equate negative population growth with extinction? Populations of most species rise and fall all the time with availability of resources and amount of predation. This is Ecology 101 stuff. I feel like most of the people who argue this have some sort of deep-seated fear that the world with run out of white people and God forbid non-Caucasians take over the world. But societies reproduce memetically, not genetically, so it doesn't really matter about local reproduction levels -- as long as you have immigration, a society survives. Agreed that energy removes a lot of barriers, but not all of the limits. Earth is still a constant size, and having an ecosystem is helpful to us. But with enough energy, other planets start looking attractive.
- philwelch 8y agoYou’re the one making this about race, not me. It is exactly because societies reproduce memetically that immigration isn’t a sustainable solution—if the rest of the world either globalizes or immigrates enough, they too will also reproduce below replacement levels. It’s also abundantly clear that human population decline has absolutely nothing to do with availability of resources, because human populations with more resources are paradoxically less fertile. Speaking to global warming in particular—once a single technologically advanced country figures out how to cheaply extract CO2 from the atmosphere, either through a more efficient means of doing that or through a breakthrough in energy production, that country can unilaterally solve the problem forever, even with continued use of hydrocarbons (since they can operate a closed loop of reextracting used hydrocarbons from the atmosphere). The fact that we aren’t there yet means that population growth outstripped technological growth for a long while, but in the long term, it’s a solvable bottleneck, just as the low agricultural output of much of the world was a bottleneck solved by Norman Borlaug and the Green Revolution.
- barberousse 8y agoIt would have to be the end of the nuclear family, the entire foundation of the traditional perspective in the developed world, replaced by some form of collective inter-gender polyamory whose main benefit is to reemploy the ancient notion of child rearing by "a village", permitting multiple members to rotate between wage earning, child rearing, and personal time, so that the lifestyle is compatible with trending standards in progressive living. If you've seen The Expanse, this would be familiar to you one of the lead characters grow up under these precise conditions in a possible future Earth. We are already seeing a growing appreciation for practices like ethical polyamory, open marriage, etc today, coupled with the growing depreciation for things like real estate while the divorce rate tells us traditional marriage is becoming untenable. The polyamorous communes of our progressive descendants may be more robust emotionally and economically, as they assume those functions of the nuclear family without the constraints of "traditional" two-adult family units (cheating, disinterest, work/life balance, max 2 earners, etc). The traditional perspective believes it has a monopoly on social harmony and fertility because it adheres to strict, heteronormative, and patriarchal rules that appear to have "always worked"; the wager our this collective polyamorous future is to recreate those "village" conditions, even more primordial than the nuclear family
- Animats 8y agoIsrael tried that, in the kibbutz era. It didn't last. The communal socialists have been overcome by religious fanatics.
- philwelch 8y agoI am polyamorous, and I happen to know a lot of polyamorous people. “Reproducing above replacement level” is not, in my experience, a good description of the polyamorous community. While you’re right in that nuclear families aren’t ideal, the more fertile subcultures are those where extended families are valued. And these cultures are, by and large, religious and culturally conservative. The only issue there is the tendency for the children of those cultures to assimilate into the progressive mainstream; after all, that’s what happened to us.
- CuriouslyC 8y agoWe're probably heading for something like that in the (very) long run. Pretty much all eusocial animal societies are arranged with a small number of breeding females and collective child care. We're unusual animals to be sure, but I don't think we'll be an exception in this case.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoThere's a simple term for this entire issue - evolution. Evolution does not mean good, or progress. It just means that traits that are beneficial to passing on one's genes will survive. Those that are harmful to passing on one's genes will tend to fade. This is self evident with genetics, but it's no less true with culture. Cultures that prioritize characteristics beneficial to their own survival and heritable reproduction will thrive. Those that don't, won't. We've created a society where people who recklessly reproduce with no concern for the consequences or anything except for themselves, will not starve and will mostly go unpunished for their awful decisions. At the same time those in the middle who are more educated and socially conscious tend to be much more cautious and judicious with reproduction. Even those on the top who are capable of 'responsibly' reproducing are increasingly choosing not to. This is going to lead to an interesting future...