5 ms·
After seeing how few senior financial industry people went to prison for their work that directly caused the 2007-2009 economic crisis, I'm highly skeptical tha
by walrus01 8y ago
After seeing how few senior financial industry people went to prison for their work that directly caused the 2007-2009 economic crisis, I'm highly skeptical that justice will actually be served.
- rayiner 8y agoI'd love to hear which specific person did which specific thing that you believe "directly caused the 2007-2009 economic crisis." Identifying a "direct cause" of the 2007-2009 financial crisis, with certainty exceeding 90-95% (the "reasonable doubt" threshold) would be worthy of a Nobel Memorial Prize, in my estimation.
- walrus01 8y agoa) the people who paid off the bond rating agencies to rate mortgage-backed securities full of junk mortgages as AAA. b) the senior executives at institutions like bear stearns who signed off on creating the mortgage backed securities and their known composition of shit mortgages. c) the senior executives at the rating agencies who knowingly rated shit bonds as AAA. d) senior executives at institutions like Countrywide which pumped the shit mortgages into the market.
- rayiner 8y agoAnd you’re 95% certain that bond ratings are what caused the financial crisis?
- walrus01 8y agono, at a more fundamental level before the ratings agencies ever saw them, the composition of the mortgage-backed securities and their tranches. The number of no-documentation/no-income mortgages that were rolled together into securitized products by the clients of the ratings agencies.
- paulsutter 8y agoSo tell us then what it was? Good people doing solid work until they were hit by a random black swan event? That’s the official story and it’s absurd.
- kbenson 8y agoI think the implication is that there were multiple causes from multiple sides, all to varying degrees of culpability. In other words, bond ratings may not be the cause, but still be a cause.
- charlesdm 8y agoBoth b and d are most definitely not illegal -- deceptive yes, but not illegal. If I sell you a crappy asset (imagine a company almost going bankrupt) for $10m and you don't do proper due diligence on said asset, then you have no right of complaining afterwards. No one is going to do your homework.
- jazzyk 8y agoIf I am your client, you have fiduciary responsibility to warn me - I am paying you commission to do due diligence. If you know it is a crappy product, and don;t warn me, it is at the very least a SEC violation, punishable. Could also be viewed as fraud, and pursued as a crime.
- URSpider94 8y agoActually, in the USA, very few financial advisors have a fiduciary duty to their clients.
- jazzyk 8y agoAll bigger institutions certainly do. I have worked for quite a few.
- FireBeyond 8y agoAnd never mind those situations where GS etc were playing both sides, advising one side to buy, others to sell. They knew through sheer logic that one of these positions was by deduction not tenable. But they went for it anyway, collecting commissions on both sides.
- icebraining 8y agoSupposedly, that's why they paid "largest penalty ever assessed against a financial services firm in the history of the S.E.C." ($550 million). Unfortunately, I find it hard to believe that's anywhere near enough to dissuade them from doing the same next time.
- cycrutchfield 8y agoFor all of those you would need definitive proof that those decisions were made with criminal intent to commit fraud. That is a very high evidentiary standard to clear, which is why these cases are so hard to prosecute. Even the Enron case, which was a pretty clear case of fraud, took the government 5 years to build a case and win in court. So, while all of those things you mention do indeed sound bad, they are incredibly difficult to prove in a criminal trial.
- walrus01 8y agoWhile I don't disagree with your points, it boils down to a defense by the persons accused of "We, titans of industry of finance, were so clueless, inept and incompetent that this unexpected thing happened. We definitely weren't intentionally trying to defraud anyone!". Doesn't exactly sound like a ringing endorsement for people whose yearly salaries are >$500,000.
- charlesdm 8y agoMaking profits unethically doesn't necessarily mean it's fraud. The two things are very different. I can knowingly sell you a crappy car, and if you sign an agreement that you bought and accepted the good in its current state, that's that. Yes, I acted unethically, but I didn't defraud you.
- Sabinus 8y agoThe rich have the ability to make their unethical actions legal, whereas the poor have no such sway in politics.
- cycrutchfield 8y agoIt has nothing to do with politics, but it may have something to do with the cost of legal representation.
- cycrutchfield 8y agoThat is how our system of criminal law works, though. We would prefer 100 criminals go free to prevent 1 innocent person from being convicted.
- matt4077 8y agoNobody "paid off the rating agencies". Or, more accurately: everyone did. It was standard practice for the rating agencies to be paid by those being rated. Now that's obviously not a terribly smart idea. But there's simply no way to blame any single individual when none of them had the power to the system by themselves. I mean: quite obviously the companies being rated would have loved for others to bear the costs for it.
- zerg2k 8y agoThat can be easily refuted by saying “do you really think that all big bank executives didn’t know what was going on and decided to ride the money wave”?
- rayiner 8y ago“Where there is smoke there is fire” is not a doctrine of criminal law. Also, by that token, who should we have prosecuted for the 2000 tech-related crash?
- walrus01 8y agoa number of people were prosecuted: https://www.google.com/search?client=ubuntu&channel=fs&q=worldcom+court+case&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8 https://www.google.com/search?client=ubuntu&channel=fs&q=wor... the dotcom 1.0 crash had a lot of irrational exuberance, where VC money was raised and pissed away for ideas that wouldn't work at the time (beenz, flooz, pets.com, webvan, etc). Then there was the outright fraud like Enron and Worldcom.
- tptacek 8y agoThe criminal justice response to dot-com and to the 2008 crash seem comparable.
- lovich 8y agoEric Holder, the attorney general at the time, did not prosecute bankers for the 2008 recession. The attorney general did prosecute people responsible for the issues in the dot com crash. How is that comparable? Holder even stated, "I am concerned that the size of some of these institutions becomes so large that it does become difficult to prosecute them" because it might damage the economy. That is not an aspect the AG should be considering. They should be upholding the rule of law which did not occur after the 2008 crisis
- walrus01 8y ago
- drb91 8y ago> with certainty exceeding 90-95% (the "reasonable doubt" threshold) How do you figure? Smells like a p value taken from a science class, not anything related to a legal definition of reasonable doubt.
- hammock 8y agoIt's a rough estimate to help you grok the concept, and is widely taught in law school. It is best viewed in comparison to another standard like "preponderance of the evidence" or "more likely than not" (51%)
- protomyth 8y agoOf everyone involved, I would love to see the rating agencies and their corporate officers get charged with fraud for rating the bundles of crappy mortgages AAA.
- paulddraper 8y agoThere are not specific people responsible. There are organizations, financial institutions, executives, investors, businesses, etc. that did not deserve jail, but did deserve to lose financially. Instead, some lost their sort and others were shielded with $100,000,000,000s of taxpayer money. The kinds of people that supported this flagrant graft are despicable. Probably not jailable (I mean most politicians and even the president supported bailing out asset holders), but more despicable than Zuckerberg or most of the scapegoats you see in the news.
- chrisgd 8y agoIt would have been nice to see them throw some charges and see what sticks.
- RoyTyrell 8y agoAre you advocating that the US government should just charge people with crimes that haven't been investigated and they have perhaps no evidence for, just to see if a jury will convict them?
- drb91 8y agoRich government officials were the victims this time. I feel confident.
- paulpauper 8y agoMadoff and Alan Stanford went to jail. although unrelated to the 2008 financial crisis, is evidence white collar criminals can in fact get very punitive sentences. In the case of the 2008 crisis, the link between the actions of any one individual and the crisis itself is more tenuous. The problem was no so much maleficence, but underestimating risk. The risk management models these banks were using could not have foreseen such a large and sudden catastrophic failure. You cannot put people in jail for failing to account for tail risk. Second, the crisis was possibly also caused by poor government policy, such as programs creating incentives for low-income homeowners who may have not have had good credit.
- walrus01 8y ago> poor government policy there is fairly strong evidence that repeal of the glass-steagall act was a contributing factor to the environment that allowed investment/securities firms to get out of control in the 2001-2008 time period: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aftermath_of_the_repeal_of_the_Glass%E2%80%93Steagall_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aftermath_of_the_repeal_of_the...
- stephengillie 8y agoSo then do we jail our Congess for (un)making laws?
- kbenson 8y agoI'm pretty sure it's not possible to find congress guilty of breaking the law by using the power vested in them by the Constitution. I think the closest you could come would be laws being ratified that the Supreme court then determined (from a case being brought) that infringed on constitutional rights, in which case that portion of the law is struck, but IANAL. Although, maybe you were joking?
- stephengillie 8y agoI might have used the incorrect sarcasm markup.
- dmfdmf 8y agoVirtually nobody went to jail because the govt was complicit in the whole scheme to a) boost the economy through debt creation and b) push loans for sub-prime borrowers (specifically targeting minorities) to get buy-in for the "American Dream" of home ownership for "disadvantaged" groups. Moreover (and probably more important) is that the parties involved except the govt all had plausible deniability in that they could point to the other parties to deflect blame. I say "except the govt" because they were the ones who were pushing the banks to lower loan standards for minorities, backing the GSE's with explicit loan guarantees and encouraging home ownership as the essence of the American dream to minorities. The mechanics or mistakes of how it was done, with CDO's or inflated credit ratings or even fraud, were a consequence of the govt pressure applied. Also, this was not an explicit policy written into regs & etc. but an implicit policy imposed by threats or hints by agencies that had a lot of power over the banking, mortgage and credit markets they regulate.
- maxxxxx 8y agoIn medical the standards are a little higher so they may be found as having violated medical regulations. What I am curious about is whether Holmes will in the end have made any money with Theranos. She should lose everything and then some more but I suspect she will still end up with a few million in the bank or in houses.
- philwelch 8y agoI’m a little shocked at the expectation that the US should be the type of banana republic that imprisons people as scapegoats for recessions.