4 ms·
I’ve written about this here before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16703193 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16703193 It feels unintuitive to think
by philwelch 8y ago
I’ve written about this here before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16703193 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16703193
It feels unintuitive to think about “dark matter” that can’t be directly observed outside of its indirect gravitational effects, but that carries with it an implicit assumption that we should be able to directly observe all the matter in the universe, with the further implication that all the matter in the universe obeys the four fundamental forces that our matter does. Except we already know of other particles that don’t quite do that, like neutrinos, which we can just barely detect directly.
If you take at face value the observation that most observed mass in the universe (via the effects of gravity) is dark, then it appears that our fundamental understanding of reality only describes a minority of the universe and that what’s truly special isn’t the “dark matter”, but rather the “anthropic matter” that we can more easily observe. The dark matter may simply be multiple entirely alien classes of matter with their own fundamental forces, stuff that doesn’t interact with our matter at all outside of gravity and contains, perhaps, observers of its own trying to figure out what the hell we are and whether we exist, since we don’t respond to their fundamental forces.
- gus_massa 8y ago> with the further implication that all the matter in the universe obeys the four fundamental forces that our matter does. Except we already know of other particles that don’t quite do that, like neutrinos, which we can just barely detect directly. Left-handed neutrinos interact mainly by the weak force and also by gravity. We have a lot of knowledge about them. You can create a neutrino ray and a neutrino detector, and (if wired properly) measure their speed. We know that there are three types of neutrinos (or perhaps there is a fourth neutrino). We know that they can change midflight from a kind of neutrino to another kind of neutrino. The change takes some time, so you can create a neutrino ray of one kind and a neutrino detector of the other kind and measure how many of the neutrinos changed midflight. So the neutrinos are well understood and there are many labs that can measure them. (Right-handed neutrinos are more difficult to measure because they interact only by gravity. Some people think that they don't even exist. Some people think that they may be part of the dark mater. I think this is still not settled. Anyway, all the neutrinos we know are left-handed neutrinos.)