3 ms·
You are almost correct. The problem is that most of the people that laugh at aether only studied just a little of special relativity and wants to sound smart in
by gus_massa 8y ago
You are almost correct. The problem is that most of the people that laugh at aether only studied just a little of special relativity and wants to sound smart in the Internet.
The aether was a good idea, it was wrong, but it was a good idea anyway. Perhaps they exaggerated trying to model it like a solid/liquid and deduce the properties, so they got weird results, but it was common those days. For example, the first model of Maxwell used some weird mechanical elements. The mechanical part was useful to deduce the equations. A few years later he dropped the mechanical part and keep only the equations. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Maxwell%27s_equations#On_Physical_Lines_of_Force https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Maxwell%27s_equatio...
The main difference between aether and a modern field theory is that with aether you have a preferred reference frame. Some things are not moving and other things are moving. Like in a lake with still water, the buoys are not moving, a moving boat is moving, and you can make some experiments to measure your speed of the boat relative to the water.
In the field that is used currently for photons (and other elementary particles) is different. You don't have a preferred reference frame. Any object that is not accelerating can be selected as a not moving object. But any other object that is moving at a constant speed can be also selected as a not moving object too. Any of them can be selected as not moving! But to compare the measurements in one of the object with the measurements in another object you must make some corrections. And the most important property is that there is no experiment that you can do to measure your speed relative to the field. This is related to the fact that light goes at the same speed for every "boat" here, even when they are moving at a constant relative speed.
So the field is like a magical fluid, even more magical than the aether. The important part is that there are accurate equations to describe all this handwaving and all the magical properties of both. The equations for the aether doesn't agree with the measurements in experiments, the equations of the field agree.