2 ms·
>Scientific skepticism is always healthy and should be welcomed. I strongly disagree. Principled scientific skepticism from practicing scientist and expert is
by nabla9 8y ago
>Scientific skepticism is always healthy and should be welcomed.
I strongly disagree.
Principled scientific skepticism from practicing scientist and expert is welcome and can contribute.
Layman scientific skepticism in hard sciences like physics is worthless and even harmful. No matter how skeptical a layman who reads popular science magazines is, they don't contribute. Only thing we can do is to learn. Our judgment and opinion is worthless.
People want to understand, contribute and discuss, but even if we have the education to understand the issues, we don't have the time or interest really think it trough. Everything valuable flows top down from experts to the layman.
Generic examples taken from the history like "Even gravity we thought was fully solved until Einstein doubted that we understood it fully" are just using different words to express tautologies. They don't provide information to the issues at hand.
- GeekyBear 8y agoScience is about repeatable experimental outcomes that are predicted In advance by theory. Demanding that people believe in a theory that so far has not been supported by the experimental data is more like religion than science.
- gpderetta 8y agoWhich theory is not supported by experimental data? GR? There is hardly any theory with more experimental support.