6 ms·
"The discovery could lead to a new means of data transfer in space, e.g., between space stations." Sure, we'll be building space stations with gravitational wa
by pdonis 8y ago
"The discovery could lead to a new means of data transfer in space, e.g., between space stations."
Sure, we'll be building space stations with gravitational wave transmitters as soon as we can figure out how to wiggle stars and planets in a controlled fashion to produce them. That should happen Real Soon Now.
- hyperpallium 8y agoYou capture a quantum black hole, slap a charge on it, and wiggle that: The Hole Man https://wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hole_Man https://wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hole_Man
- pavel_lishin 8y agoWouldn't that evaporate rather quickly? (Sure, Niven didn't know that _then_... but science has a habit of catching up to some stories.)
- waterhouse 8y agoAccording to this... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawking_radiation#A_crude_analytic_estimate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawking_radiation#A_crude_anal... "[F]or instance, a 1-second-life black hole has a mass of 2.28×10^5 kg", and the time taken seems proportional to the cube of the mass. So a 2.28×10^6 kg black hole would take 1000 seconds, and so on. How massive was the black hole in the story?
- pavel_lishin 8y agoThe story mentions "ten-to-the-seventeenth grams in mass and ten-to-the-minus-eleven centimeters across", but I'm not sure if that's the black hole in question, or a hypothetical one. They definitely mention it being smaller than an atom, though.
- waterhouse 8y agoInteresting. That's 10^14 kg, which, according to the above, would be between 10^24 and 10^27 seconds to evaporate, which is at least in the quadrillions of years. As for the radius... Looks like the Schwarzchild radius is proportional to the mass, and for the moon (7x10^22 kg) it's 0.11x10^-3 meters, so this 10^14 kg mass should be maybe 1.5x10^-13 meters, which is 1.5 x 10^-11 cm. Nice. It looks like Niven did his homework. Incidentally, Wiki says that Hawking argued for black hole evaporation in 1974, and Niven's story won an award in 1975, which I assume might indicate it was published around then. Seems it'd be a close call whether Niven heard about it before publishing his story.
- pdonis 8y agoThe problem for a hole this size isn't the evaporation time; that's way longer than the age of the universe. The problem is the Hawking radiation pressure. Some quick formulas (M is mass of the hole in kg): Evaporation time T = 8.4 x 10^-17 M^3 seconds Hawking radiation power W = 3.6 x 10^32 / M^2 Watts Hawking radiation pressure at 10^-10 meters (roughly one atom) distance P = 9.6 x 10^42 / M^2 Pa (Note that the last formula assumes that the hole's horizon radius is smaller than 10^-10 meters, which it is for Niven's hole.) For M = 10^14 kg, we get: T = 8.4 x 10^25 seconds (which is more than 10^18 years) W = 3.6 x 10^4 Watts (36 kW, comparable to your car's engine traveling on the highway with a family and luggage, but pretty darn bright for something that's basically just a light source) P = 9.6 x 10^14 Pa (almost 10^10 atmospheres!) So this hole won't accrete matter, because anything that gets close to it gets violently pushed away by its Hawking radiation. It will tunnel its way through Mars and out the other side, and then back again, executing simple harmonic motion, indefinitely.
- 0xFFFE 8y agoC'mon, we can already transmit data across different dimensions using a wrist watch & morse code. Yeah, bandwidth isn't that great but hey, we could use a wall clock.
- devgutt 8y agoI know you are joking, but transmit information through dimensions using gravity is one interesting conjecture why gravitational force is so much weaker than the other forces. It leaks through dimensions. And maybe this type of communication will be necessary when we have to leave this dimension to hyperspace because of the entropy [1]. [1] http://www.multivax.com/last_question.html http://www.multivax.com/last_question.html
- Twisol 8y agoFor what it’s worth, evidence has come out (explained well by this PBS Space Time episode [1]) that makes the “gravity propagates over more than three spatial dimensions” theory a bit less likely. [1] https://youtu.be/3HYw6vPR9qU https://youtu.be/3HYw6vPR9qU
- devgutt 8y agoInteresting video, so it is possible that there is no leak after all, but I think this does not prove that there are no extra dimensions, as the video tries to portrait.
- msslx 8y agoThe 3+1 dimensional spacetime is not embedded in a higher dimensional space [1]. If there are additional dimensions, they have to be "rolled up" and tiny. [1] http://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1475-7516/2018/07/048/meta http://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1475-7516/2018/07/...
- devgutt 8y agoI wish I could read a paper like this one! My takeaway is that is no leak, but this doesn't prove that there are not higher dimensions in space, just that the gravitational waves can't get through it (if exists).
- illvm 8y agoThat's not strictly necessary, is it? All matter should be able to effect gravity. It's a matter of having sensitive enough detectors for whatever is causing the disturbance, not necessarily having something which can produce enough of a disturbance to detect.
- jcims 8y agoI did some high school level math on the equivalence of the signals detected by LIGO vs the gravitational wave induced by the mass energy conversion of 1kg of plutonium from the other side of the earth. If memory serves the signal of the latter should have been ~3 orders of magnitude higher. Using nukes to communicate is a bit intense, but a tuned receiver should be able to pick up lower energy levels.
- pdonis 8y ago> the gravitational wave induced by the mass energy conversion of 1kg of plutonium from the other side of the earth. Did you take into account that in a process like this, virtually none of the energy released can be put into gravitational waves? The efficiency of such transmission is extremely low for processes involving ordinary matter--many orders of magnitude less efficient than for electromagnetic waves. You need huge quantities of matter to overcome this problem--or, alternatively, you need very dense matter, like neutronium, or strong spacetime curvature like that of a black hole (but not too large a hole, since curvature at the horizon goes like the inverse square of the hole's mass).