4 ms·
How Yan Lianke Became China's Most Controversial Satirist
- dang 8y agoAll: if you post in this thread, please avoid two scourges: (1) comments on the evils of communism or the opposite—we've all heard it a million times and nothing new on it will ever come out of an internet forum. (2) any trace of nationalistic flamebait from any side. I'm putting up this banner because every thread related to China has been degenerating badly lately. The idea of HN is to avoid such "night in which all cows are black" threads, so please stick to specifics.
- greatquux 8y agoI'm intrigued by that phrase you just mentioned. Never heard it before... "Night in which all cows are black"?
- rrampage 8y agoThe closest equivalent I have heard of is "At night all cats are grey". [0] [0] - https://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/all+cats+are+grey+at+night https://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/all+cats+are+grey+at+ni...
- dang 8y agoIt's a phrase of Hegel's that comes from his criticism of romantic idealism. https://ndpr.nd.edu/news/hegel-s-preface-to-the-phenomenology-of-spirit/ https://ndpr.nd.edu/news/hegel-s-preface-to-the-phenomenolog...
- brownbat 8y agoPossibly a critique of deriving truth from intuition, which leaves no way to critically distinguish between two conflicting ideas, much as you can't distinguish between cows by color at night. Hegel wasn't exactly from the Strunk & White branch of philosophical writing though, so I could easily be wrong. :)
- dang 8y agoBased on refreshing my memory by a couple of cheap web searches, I think that's at least in the ballpark.
- woodandsteel 8y agodang, you say we should avoid those two topics, but don't say what you think it would be productive to discuss instead, much less give any examples yourself. I could be wrong, but perhaps this is because you would rather that modern China simply not be discussed at all.
- dang 8y agoNo, it's that we want to avoid discussions that turn out always the same and always get increasingly vicious.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rjtobin 8y agoI’m always hesitant to read a translated novel (especially literary fiction). Seems like too much would be lost in translation. Even putting language aside, without knowing the cultural context within China, would Lianke’s books be totally lost on me? I’m guessing my view here is naive (and, in terms of the cultural context, a sort of self-fulfilling project). Any HNers care to educate me on this?
- claytoneast 8y agoI made a serious effort last year to read more translated works. Read a couple of Turkish novels, a Chinese one, and a couple others. Really enjoyed it, highly recommend reading translated stuff. Certainly your experience of the piece will not be 100% what the native writer intended, but it will be close, and that is okay. Even translated, there will be ideas and phrasings and ways of thought that you simply will not find in most native English writers works. Shakespeare read today will not have the same effect that Shakespeare perhaps intended it to have, 4-500 years ago, and that is okay. We read it all the same for what it can give us.
- yorwba 8y agoTranslated books live and die with the ability of the translator. A bad translator can make a bad book boring, a good translator can turn a mediocre book into a page-turner. Whether the translator did well or not can only be seen by trying to actually read the book. I read the first few pages of "Serve the people!" on Amazon and found it to be quite well-written, with appropriate explanations for cultural context where necessary. Then I read the same part in a pirated Chinese version [1] and found it to be even better. The most difficult part of a translation is to preserve not only the content but also the form. Yan Lianke makes some stylistic choices like reusing sentence structures with only a few words swapped out, that would sound incredibly forced if you tried it in English, but flows naturally in Chinese. In these cases, the translator can only leave it at an approximation. Some metaphors are also difficult to convey. In the original, Yan Lianke compares history to a measuring rope, whereas in the translation it turns into a yardstick. Maybe there's some intentional subtlety that gets lost (the rope is flexible, the yardstick is rigid). Then there are simple translation errors that slipped through quality control, e.g. 一颗发光的五星 (one shining five-pointed star) is translated as five gleaming stars. But if you're not explicitly trying to compare between versions, you're probably not even going to notice that there's anything off. Rather than wondering whether the translation is inferior to the original, try finding out whether you can enjoy it nonetheless. Disclaimer: I'm a native speaker of neither English nor Chinese, so I might not be the best person to judge what quality literature in either language looks like. [1] https://www.bannedbook.org/resources/file/600 https://www.bannedbook.org/resources/file/600
- brownbat 8y agoYan Lianke's "Serve The People!" contained vivid sex scenes, with characters aroused by destroying images and writings of Mao and set during the Cultural revolution, when the punishment would be death by firing squad. The Party responded to the 2005 controversy by halting a magazine's publication of the work. This in turn led to enormous demand for the novel, naturally. Wikipedia (yes, guilty), citing July 2007's "A pen for the people" in "The Age." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yan_Lianke https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yan_Lianke See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect
- sevensor 8y agoI was intrigued by the descriptions of Chinese rural poverty. Eating bark and clay during famine times, fertilizing the garden with night soil, eating meat once a year. When I read The Good Earth, I thought it was a picture of China painted for Westerners. Which perhaps the article is as well, but it's interesting that the pictures are so much the same.
- plink 8y agoAudible has only two of his works: "Lenin's Kisses", and "The Four Books". Does anyone have recommendations on other audiobook sources for his works?