6 ms·
I remember a comment here on HN about how identity theft is the wrong name. Your wife and dog dont stop recognizing you. It is financial fraud and it really sho
by giancarlostoro 8y ago
I remember a comment here on HN about how identity theft is the wrong name. Your wife and dog dont stop recognizing you. It is financial fraud and it really should be the entire responsibility of creditors to fix. The second you report it you should be able to have it sorted or be fully capable of suing them for defamation of your identity e.g. claiming you went on a credit card binge when you did not... We need an overhaul on privacy and our credit system. I am even much more concerned about the latter since it affects peoples lives much more dangerously.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- zkms 8y ago> a surveillance technology that police and debt collectors use to track most of the United States’ 325 million inhabitants via their Social Security numbers, license plates, address histories, names and dates of birth. The mass-monitoring tech, called TLO, is a product of the Chicago-based credit reporting giant TransUnion, which last year had revenues of nearly $1.9 billion. One brochure for the service promises access to a startling amount of personal data drawn from myriad sources: more than 350 million Social Security numbers of dead and living Americans, 225 million employment histories and four billion address records. Add to that billions of vehicle registrations and call records and you have one of the largest commercial surveillance databases in existence. > It’s used not just by cops but also by debt collectors and private companies carrying out background checks. Private investigators use it to track cheating spouses. Honestly that this database exists at all is a serious problem in itself.
- narag 8y agoIn my country such a database has existed for a long time. It's the national id database. It's controlled by national police. Everyone of us owns an eight digits number. As for me: identity is a right, not some secret that I want to hide. What doesn't make sense is that people are afraid of USA government having much needed data, while private organizations have them already.
- d6e 8y agoHow does your country handle authentication? The real problem is that in the United States, social security numbers and birthdates are used as private information for authorization with all the various financial and health institutions. I'm less afraid of them being public and mostly afraid of the fact that all these institutions treat that information as private.
- Arnt 8y ago(I'm probably from another country, since my such number doesn't have eight digits.) There are three ways to authenticate myself, none of which is knowing that magic number. Many institutions choose to do it simpler and more convenient, which is then their problem if anything untoward happens. (BTW: None of the authentication mechanisms are available to minors, which fits in well with another aspect of the law: If an adult or a legal person enters into an agreement with a minor and something goes wrong, that's not the minor's problem.)
- rtuulik 8y agoDifferent country, but similar system here. Every person gets assigned a 11 digit personal id number at birth. That id-code then gets used as a identifier. If you sign up for something, you just give them that number, and it will work as a unique identifier, they will know exactly that you are THAT John Smith, not that different John Smith For something simple, like signing up for the grocery store customer card, it is enough to just say your name and number, for bigger things, like opening a bank account, you have to show your ID-card or passport. For remote authentication, you use the ID-card for secure Internet banking, signing contracts digitally, voting, etc
- Kiro 8y agoIn my country all that is public information.
- pkz 8y agoIn Sweden all citizens get a unique 12 digit number at birth (where the last char is a checksum). It is used for identification and you can call the tax agency to find the ID of everyone. For the public sector it is a great value as a primary key but increasingly shops have started asking for it too. This means a lot of information is easy to aggregate from multiple sources and build profiles of people. I guess most people don't care.
- onion2k 8y agoWe have the same thing here in the UK (national insurance numbers) but one key difference to the US seems to be that we rarely need to disclose ours. You use it for tax related activities and that's all. I'm pretty sure if a shop asked for it most people would say no, because no one knows their own without looking it up, but also because it'd be really weird.
- olivermarks 8y agoRegarding @pkz comment about Swedish citizen numbers if you are in sweden and don't have one it is a nightmare getting anything accomplished - utilities, broadband etc, even if you are paying Swedish tax. Despite being EU members that federalization model fails if you don't have that number
- pkz 8y agoThis is true. Not having one makes regular life increasingly difficult. In many cases I am pretty sure it boils down to system designers actually not considering there could be customers without one. Software won't work without the ID number to connect data to. In healthcare hospital staff typically works around this by using "Mr twelve" - 1212121212 - which is syntactically correct with the correct checksum, but not identifying an individual.
- branchless 8y agoMitchell and Web: identity theft https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=CS9ptA3Ya9E https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=CS9ptA3Ya9E Another lie from the bankers that our advertising hungry media repeats.
- mncharity 8y agoFraud? So the suggestion is the old state of law was preferable, from a public policy perspective? Before "identity theft" was created? Created by a process that was described, if I'm remembering the right bill correctly, as industry lobbyists standing in the hallway outside the Congressional committee room on their phones - stepping into the hall to call their clients back to ask what else they would like, and then cycling back through the room to add it? Hmm... could be. ;) In other news, it seems the NYTimes has managed to use the phrase "regulatory capture" three whole times so far in 2018![1] Woo hoo! We'll be addressing this in no time at all. Right after rolling back copyright extension. And tech innovating better fora support for constructive public discussion. RSN. Maybe next week? :/ Sigh. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/search?endDate=20181031&query=%22regulatory%20capture%22&sort=newest&startDate=20180101 https://www.nytimes.com/search?endDate=20181031&query=%22reg... But yes, it is possible to push on these things. History is contingent. And no one ever promised bootstrapping a civilization was quick or easy or monotonic.
- S_A_P 8y agoIt's definitely a brilliant smokescreen. The credit agencies/banks/insurance companies that fail to secure your personal data can blame you and call you a victim instead of admitting negligence...
- jjeaff 8y agoThey are still required to fix things and return your money. If someone "steals" your identity, and then shows up at the bank and withdraws your money, the bank will be on the hook for that loss, not you.
- newnewpdro 8y agoIt's not that simple. There are superficial barriers and hoops in place which make the chances of you not getting your money back non-zero. Not to mention, it will at the very minimum inconvenience you and waste your time. Credit cards are less problematic in this area, but when it's a bank account / debit card, there tend to be fairly agressive deadlines for identifying the fraudulent activity and contesting it as well as arbitrary processes, forms, and reviews unique to each the bank. In the interim you don't have the funds - for many people living paycheck to paycheck this can be a catastrophic situation. I recently had to go through this process with a debit card someone on the other side of the country had fraudulently charged $500 to. Due to my being in the midst of leaving for a long bout of travel, it was a nightmare to get the protest documented on time, and my bank suddenly required all sorts of exceptional identifying documents they never require in the course of regular business, requiring me to jump through a number of additional hoops like accessing my safe deposit box to retrieve my passport - when I wasn't even in the same state at the time. It all just added more delays to the process. As far as I could tell, the bank was treating me as the potential criminal. They were operating under the assumption that I, the victim, am actually the perpetrator attempting to commit fraud. Through this lens, the process being frustrating and inconvenient to the customer appears advantageous, as it all increases the odds of them failing/giving up.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoYour bank was just trying to figure out which of two internet strangers not in your home territory was the real you. Someone using your card isn't the main problem with "identity" theft. That's a minor issue. If it's more than a few hundred bucks you'll notice immediately. Someone getting a loan or a social security card benefits or health insurance or tax refund or committing a felony in your name is the major issue, which can run your life with you not even knowing for possibly years.
- brownbat 8y agoMitchell and Webb offer the canonical spoof: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=CS9ptA3Ya9E https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=CS9ptA3Ya9E
- oliveshell 8y agoExactly what I thought of reading the parent comment... what a brilliant bit of satire. “I’m not clear why you think it’s my identity that was stolen, rather than your money.”
- blattimwind 8y agoM&W are one of those duos where the accuracy of some sketches is almost painful.
- gmjoe 8y agoVery true. It's not identity theft, it's financial fraud. It's not stealing music, it's copying music. It's not buying ebooks, it's leasing them. It's crazy how easily we (and journalists above all) accept semantic distortions of reality, and forget what's actually going on.
- ddingus 8y agoI just wrote the same, now reading thread. Infringement of or on the person.
- giancarlostoro 8y ago> It's not buying ebooks, it's leasing them. I mostly agree, though in some cases you do own them in a format that is reasonable. In other cases some ebooks are open on github as well under Creative Commons.
- ddingus 8y agoTheft is wrong in the same way copying a file as theft is wrong. I just realized that upon reading your comment. From the old world, the word infringement was used. People do or have a thing they are not supposed to, basically. No theft occurred because no loss of property happened. Thus, the other word. I would wonder about examples of infringement back when information was much less fluid. Identities are one such example. This could be infringment of the person, again setting modern language and examples aside.
- ric2b 8y ago> No theft occurred because no loss of property happened. Thus, the other word. Money was moved from the bank via fraudulent behavior.