The first two seem distasteful, but I fail to see how the dignity field proposal falls in the same vein. You are both criticizing inaction (just get them out of

The first two seem distasteful, but I fail to see how the dignity field proposal falls in the same vein. You are both criticizing inaction (just get them out of here and I don't care what happens to them) and action (let's get them in one area, offer them shelter, and provide services). This seems to me like speaking out of both sides of your mouth.