4 ms·
> penniless and dependent on the institutions she viewed as failures of the human spirit. Link? She died in her Manhattan apartment [1], not some government f
by paulddraper 8y ago
> penniless and dependent on the institutions she viewed as failures of the human spirit.
Link?
She died in her Manhattan apartment [1], not some government funded facility. And colleague Leonard Peikoff [2] was heir to her estate, including the copyrights and royalties on her works.
[1] http://www.literarymanhattan.org/place/ayn-rands-apartment-2/ http://www.literarymanhattan.org/place/ayn-rands-apartment-2...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonard_Peikoff https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonard_Peikoff
- cultus 8y ago>She died in her Manhattan apartment [1], not some government funded facility. I believe the parent was referring to government institutions such as social security, which Ayn Rand wound up using after being signed up by a social worker. She spoke out against such programs her whole life. However, she needed it, it was different. A common refrain with such people.
- paulddraper 8y agoYou insinuate contradiction where none exists. Disliking being "excessively taxed" your whole life doesn't preclude you from trying to get some of it back. In fact, I dare say you'll try even harder to get it back. Just because you didn't want to blow the budget on the Christmas party doesn't mean you can't show up.
- skookumchuck 8y agoIf someone opposes collective farms in the Soviet Union, must they starve in order to avoid being moral hypocrites? The thing with Social Security is we're all forced to pay into the system. It's not immoral to accept the paycheck. I'll be accepting those checks, too, despite opposing SS and consistently voting against it.
- sbuttgereit 8y agoExcept that you're cherry picking points out of her positions to make your point. These sorts of simple minded reductionist arguments fail to actually convey any sense of the position of those they seek to caricature. Her action was consistent with her thinking as expressed around decade before her "needing it". Her actual position, from 1966: https://campus.aynrand.org/works/1966/01/01/the-question-of-scholarships/page1 https://campus.aynrand.org/works/1966/01/01/the-question-of-...
- ufmace 8y agoI don't think an economic conservative accepting social security while being against it is a contradiction, any more than an economic liberal using schemes to pay the lowest taxes possible while being in favor of higher taxes. It seems a little ridiculous for a economic conservative to refuse to accept social security despite being forced to pay into it their whole life. Just as much for an economic liberal to pay the highest taxes possible and give all of their extra income to the Government too. I think optimizing your current situation given what the rules of your society currently actually are doesn't preclude you from advocating for a different set of rules.
- dmix 8y agoRand also paid into social security (and taxes) for her entire life. She did not go out and seek social security, she had to be thoroughly convinced by her lawyers, after much arguing, that she deserved the money because it was essentially hers, and only when her husband became seriously ill. She didn't end up making a decision to take it, she left that choice to her lawyers. She eventually took $11k over 8 years from social security until she died....which isn't much at all (about $1.3k/yr, hardly a 'living wage' as people on the left like to say). Quite a big difference from 'depending on the state' or 'capable people leeching off of other hardworking individuals' as she despised. Regardless she lived in the US, not in her idealistic economic system. Expecting her (or anyone) to live perfectly like they would in their fantasy ideal political/economic system is a ridiculous standard and dismissing all of her (flawed) work because of it is a no-true-scotsman-esque fallacy. I'm sure she would have preferred paying into a private retirement insurance fund and people donating to private retirement security funds for those who weren't capable of investing in insurance themselves (which she most certainly was).