8 ms·
An Update on the Security Issue
- denzil_correa 8y ago> For 15 million people, attackers accessed two sets of information – name and contact details (phone number, email, or both, depending on what people had on their profiles). For 14 million people, the attackers accessed the same two sets of information, as well as other details people had on their profiles. This included username, gender, locale/language, relationship status, religion, hometown, self-reported current city, birthdate, device types used to access Facebook, education, work, the last 10 places they checked into or were tagged in, website, people or Pages they follow, and the 15 most recent searches. Another reason to not use your phone number as a unique identifier.
- hw 8y agoIt's also a good idea to just not use Facebook, or at least scrub all profile details and any personal information including pictures. On a more serious note, the unusual activity started Sept 14, took then 11 days before actually determining that it was an exploit, and took then 2 days after that to actually fix the issue. 2 days might not seem like a long time, but with automation, the hackers could have gone through a lot more accounts in that time frame.
- mehrdadn 8y agoBirthday is pretty bad. They treat these as if they're all the same when they're not.
- testplzignore 8y ago> Within two days, we closed the vulnerability That is very slow for a server-side vulnerability. Was the fix that complicated that it could not be safely deployed within minutes or hours? Or did the FB management not take the issue seriously?
- samat 8y agoOr were they asked by FBI to keep the thing going’s so they could catch the attacker? Lots of reasons to delay.
- vthallam 8y agothat's not how things work.
- zackkitzmiller 8y agoDoesn't the FB deploy process take a day in itself? Edit: This hasn't been the case for years.
- mikevin 8y ago> > Within two days, we closed the vulnerability "Within two days, we closed the vulnerability, stopped the attack, and secured people’s accounts by resetting the access tokens for people who were potentially exposed. As a precaution, we also turned off “View As.” The last sentence could mean they disabled the feature and then spent two days fixing the vulnerability before re-enabling it. It's not clear though, maybe this is just wishful thinking on my part.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoUnder 2 days is good timing to code, test, and globally deploy a bugfix. The only way to close a hole more quickly is either shut down the system (which might be worse than the bug) or if the bug was extremely recently introduced and you can rollback to a recently tested good version of the system.
- pcanahuati 8y agoI lead Security and Privacy Engineering at Facebook and wanted to chime in on this thread. As soon as we found the vulnerability, our first priority was to determine how we could protect people most effectively. If we had closed the vulnerability immediately, the attackers could have escalated their attack to modify information or post as someone else by using the access tokens they had already acquired before we reset them. Instead, we determined all the potentially affected accounts and reset their access tokens in a coordinated way to prevent further misuse of the vulnerability. We haven't reset 90M accounts all at once before. Identifying the attackers, defining our remediation, validating that it would work, and closing the vulnerability while simultaneously ensuring all accounts were secure is complex to do at scale.
- samspenc 8y ago> We saw an unusual spike of activity that began on September 14, 2018, and we started an investigation. On September 25, we determined this was actually an attack and identified the vulnerability. I'm unclear why it took 11-12 days to uncover this?
- jtokoph 8y agoPossible scenario: Someone noticed a spike on Sep 14th which was a Friday. Person A probably sent an email to Person B asking for information. Person B finally replied to ask person C on Monday. Person C gets looped in Tuesday and assigns Person D to take a look at it. Person D is finishing up a task and starts looking on Friday. Everyone thinks this is fine as the issue is probably just a front-end bug that's causing looped requests. It's not considered a security issue yet. They make a little progress on Friday, but are out of town in Tahoe for the weekend. Monday the 24th rolls around and they finally figure out that it might be an attack and report back up the chain, a process which took 24 hours. Now it's the 25th, which is 11 days later.
- Ibethewalrus 8y agopossible scenario 2: 1-Mark opens calculator 2-gets how much $$$$$$$$ he’ll lose if fb shutdowns for couple hours 3-lets hack continue 4-profits Joke aside, i’d estimate they have about in the ballpark of over 200 security engineers that have alerts for when smth like unusual activity happens
- jsnell 8y agoFirst, it's saying that the spike of activity started on 14th rather than that that's when it was detected or first acted upon. September 14th was a Friday. Due to the weekend, it's unlikely anyone would have noticed before the 17th unless the anomaly was actually triggering production critical warnings. The pratical timeline was one week. Second, if the counters that were being triggered by the attack weren't obviously malicious, it's likely that for some amount of time it was treated as a lower priority figure out what's going on deal rather than a sign of something being critically wrong. "Hey, we're getting 25% increase in access to the video uploader but the number of successful uploads is normal. Did we break the page somehow and people are having to reload the page?". And then somebody spends a day looking at what was pushed the previous Thursday before deciding that the widget is working correctly and escalating to someone else. It's also highly likely that the product teams at Facebook (who would probably have started the investigation, since it was product-related counters going up rather than something obviously security-related) might not have sufficient access to logs to determine the exact sequence of events. Maybe they didn't have the raw IP addresses of the requests, so couldn't realize that all this increase in traffic was coming from a handful of systems. Maybe they could only see the requests to their own service, but not the full path of requests to other services that the attacker used to pivot from one vulnerability to another. A week after detection to deciding it was a security issue seems like a pretty plausible timeline to me.
- deegles 8y agoSerious question... how does any smaller, less tech-focused company have a chance of keeping data secure if not even Facebook can do it?
- foolfoolz 8y agothey don’t. your startup against 5,000 chinese. who’s gonna win
- TheCapn 8y agoWell let's not jump to conclusions so quickly. Reading Facebook's report it states that their vulnerability was within a feature they developed. A smaller company is likely to have less complexity in their software. Less complexity == less chance of vulnerability typically. You can't be perfect. And you likely have less talented engineers than Facebook can afford, but if your software doesn't provide these sort of bridges that Facebook developed then that's one less point of exposure you're testing/fixing/securing.
- foolfoolz 8y agothe u. s. government has hacked CA providers so even companies following best practices are vulnerable. how can any company possibly compete against nation state attack?
- ilovecaching 8y agoYou just do the best you can. Totally secure is a myth. As a smaller company, however, you have an advantage that your footprint is much smaller and easier to reason about. The larger you become, the more software you have to run, the more you have to manage, the more lucrative an attack on your systems will be for the attackers. That's why in security we don't play the blame game when someone gets hacked. We know it could happen to any of us, might already have happened, and we're all doing the best we can with the resources we have.
- ams6110 8y ago
- mehrdadn 8y agoTechnical question: Does anyone know if there are any common legitimate reasons to allow an authentication system to automatically generate access tokens for a client in response to something other than an actual user login? The thought of it sounds horrifying to me so I'm wondering if I'm missing something and how/why they might have approved such a design.
- techntoke 8y agoWhen you want to gather people's personal and private information and pretend it was a breach.
- jazzyjackson 8y agoConspiratorial but I like it.
- personamb 8y agoNot common at all. I was an eng at FB when the "View as" feature was being built. I wasn't involved in the project at all, and my memory is hazy (this was probably 7 years ago by now), but I remember people being like "wow this is crazy and probably a bad idea". I don't actually know if View As generating access tokens was how it worked originally, or if that was a later refactor. Just, in general, spoofing privacy / access control is really scary, no matter how you do it. However, at the time, Facebook was getting a lot of shit (rightfully) for not helping users understand the privacy model, and the View As feature was actually incredibly useful for helping users understand what was public. So my guess (pure speculation) is that yes, people acknowledged it was scary, but decided the value was worth the cost.
- techntoke 8y agoThe amount of information leaked in this is so statistically significant that Facebook should be shutdown while they do an investigation. I currently get approx. 3 robocalls a day even though I'm in the Do Not Call Registry, and they are always from different numbers. They even know my name and address even though I don't publish it. Having your information leaked like this has real consequences. After the issue with Cambridge Analytica, you are simply becoming a lab rat peasant for the oligarchy. Any autonomy that you may have had will soon fade away.
- CydeWeys 8y agoOh god, maybe this is why I've started getting a ridiculous number of spam phone calls every day over the past month. Shame on me for giving them my phone number for account security/verification way back ... turns out it wasn't worth it.
- mehrdadn 8y agoDid you get a security notice from Facebook regarding this issue?
- hoorayimhelping 8y agoI got a security notice and I've gotten one new phone call every day from the same number. Blocking it the other day seemed to have worked.
- CydeWeys 8y agoNope. Would it be an email?
- mehrdadn 8y agoNot aware if there was an email, but I think there was a banner on the website that was shown to those potentially affected. If you didn't receive one then I presume you shouldn't have been affected.
- 8y ago
- joe_hoyle 8y agoThe post seems to suggest the number to be concerned about is 30 million users who had access tokens stolen. Seems to downplay the 400 million users who had their profiles leaked. "They used an automated technique to move from account to account so they could steal the access tokens of those friends, and for friends of those friends, and so on, totaling about 400,000 people. In the process, however, this technique automatically loaded those accounts’ Facebook profiles, mirroring what these 400,000 people would have seen when looking at their own profiles." Seems a lot more like this has leaked the privacy of 400 million users, but Facebook are trying to focus on the smaller 30 million (though granted, those are more seriously affected.)
- ilovecaching 8y ago400,000 not 400,000,000
- joe_hoyle 8y ago:facepalm:
- theabacus 8y agoDon’t worry, Facebook. I was affect by this (even though my account has been disabled for 2 years) and realized I should leave finally. So I did. And nothing will bring me back to any service you have since you’ve only demonstrated CYA and uncaringness. If you really cared, you’d compensate me monetarily for my loss due to your negligence.
- ilovecaching 8y agoWhat I've taken away from the last few years of watching large companies deal with bad actors is that cyberwarfare is here. The public is yet unaware that we technologists have become front line soldiers battling against nation state actors and brigands, and not just for their child's birthday address. I've listened to plenty of OWASP/Black Hat talks about critical pieces of infrastructure ("air gaped" power grids for example) hacked by red teams. This is scary stuff. We all need to start treating this like the hidden war it is and start planning for the worst. Cyberware is no longer the warfare of the future it is the now.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- scoggs 8y agoI definitely agree. I'm very worried about the potential for a World War 3 scenario where not only has the warfare technology in combat, the weaponry and ammunition, the missiles and bombs and such becoming more precision and deadly components of war but beyond that the parties involved have the added digital technology, imaging technology, unmanned aircraft vehicle technology, and all the rest of the warfare-related tech that's cropped up over the last decade plus added to their arsenal. In an all out war scenario we don't really know the extent this new technology will ultimately play. Is it going to be the type of scenario like the first two World Wars where rifling, tank, and air combat technology is going to be one of the deciding factors? Is it going to be something more akin to World War 2 where Alan Turing's work on deciphering of the Enigma Machines / Nazi's communication codes is going to play an integral role in preparation, troop movement decisions, and gaining the edge on the enemy? I get the feeling, personally, that it's going to be a combination of everything above and more. Those individual military's capability of incorporating all of the tech at their fingertips and applying the knowledge / inferences gleaned while also making the best use of their cyber, hard, and soft military tactics is going to be a major deciding factor since the war will probably be staged on many fronts (physical and digital) between many allied nations versus many other allied nations. The ability to communicate and execute will be as important as it always was (e.g. maximum importance, as usual) and I strongly feel that history will reveal the more technologically advanced and more wisely dependent nations of those technologies will write history as they become the winning nation(s) / powers.
- donalhunt 8y agoGot an account? Check if you are affected here: https://www.facebook.com/help/securitynotice https://www.facebook.com/help/securitynotice
- jorblumesea 8y agoWhen are we going to wake up and understand Western companies need state help to deal with state actors? This isn't script kiddie stuff, it's other countries with billions of dollars in backing, built to tear apart our infrastructure, steal IP and gain a competitive global advantage. The idea that FB or any Western company can stand against tens of thousands of Chinese engineers with almost unlimited budget is absurd. As much as the government and government interference is maligned in tech, we need to start considering a serious public/private cybersecurity partnership.
- komali2 8y agoI am of the opinion that our ruling class is simply too old to comprehend the importance of this issue. This is ageism, but I can't think my way around it. The questions the Legislative body were asking the tech companies were so bad, and that's presumably after they'd been briefed by whatever experts worked for them. Executive branch: "As far as the cyber, I agree to parts of what Secretary Clinton said." FCC: "The thousands of dead people responding to our public request for comment is fake news. Also, it was a hack. But we weren't hacked." Justice Samuel Alito on how cell phones can have huge storage capacity: "What if the person had on his person a compact disk?" Justice Anthony Kennedy on what happens when you get a text, while sending one: "Does it say: 'Your call is important to us, and we will get back to you?'"
- 908087 8y agoIs Facebook going to foot the bill?
- gaius 8y agoWestern companies need state help Imagine you are GCHQ or the NSA. You discover a 0-day. Do you a) make sure your own citizens and allies are patched ASAP or b) keep it quiet so you can use it yourself, perhaps on said citizens?
- vthallam 8y agoThis is crazy. It shows how the social graph is so brittle. My girlfriend's account was one of the affected and since then she keeps getting these random messages from profiles who look like ex military. No idea how they even find her profile, because she actually disabled search on FB for her name/profile. For facebook, this is just yet another security incident, but for millions of ordinary people whose contact details are exposed and many of who are women, a continuous threat.
- minimaxir 8y ago> Also, can I point out the irony of ironies that the attackers used the "View As" feature, which is ostensibly a PRIVACY check tool, to gain access to all this private information? https://twitter.com/alplicable/status/1050819857351098370 https://twitter.com/alplicable/status/1050819857351098370
- sorokod 8y agoThe relation between Facebook, it's users and attackers is the same as between cattle ranchers, their sheep and sheep rustlers.
- switch007 8y agoI got part way through their stupid verification (I think I gave my phone number, but then they wanted photo ID). So I need to give them a scan of my passport to see if they failed to protect my other personal data...?
- shanemlk 8y agoI happily deleted my Facebook yesterday. It's scheduled to be deleted permanently in 30 days. I can no longer criticize a company while using their product.
- ngngngng 8y agoAnyone have any ideas on how someone outside the EU can get facebook to follow the right to be forgotten thing? I don't believe deleting my account will delete any of my data, although i've already deactivated and plan to delete permanently soon.
- fossuser 8y agoI think I read recently that deletion does now delete your data post GDPR.
- simonlebo 8y agoOn the 28th of September I got charged $900+ for Facebook ads that I never ran. I reported it as fraud to my credit card and let Facebook know. I would recommend everyone that have their PayPal integration to check their bank statement for unusual activity around that date.