3 ms·
You present the current market situation as if it's the result of well-informed consumers making rational choices. This is far from the case. The majority of p
by rahimnathwani 8y ago
You present the current market situation as if it's the result of well-informed consumers making rational choices.
This is far from the case. The majority of people who buy 'cheap' printers do not know how expensive they are to run. Even if the manufacturer displays the # pages a cartridge can print, these numbers usually assume 5% page coverage, which is very low compared to the eye-catching sample prints shown on the printer's box.
All of this is intended to mislead consumers.
I like how in supermarkets (in the UK at least), shelf labels clearly show the price per kg, or per ml. So it's easy to compare items. And I like how there are regulations for how efficiency (and hence running costs) is measured for cars and washing machines.
Maybe we need similar regulation for printers: you can sell anything you want, but the ongoing cost must be calculated in a specific way, consistent across all manufacturers and models, and must be displayed prominently.
- rayiner 8y agoThe cartridges are sold on the shelf right next to the printers! People can easily see how much they cost. And there is an ISO standard for calculating page counts: https://www.lexmark.com/common/images/iso-page-yields/understanding-print-cartridge-page-yields.pdf https://www.lexmark.com/common/images/iso-page-yields/unders.... Yes, that's not the coverage for eye-catching sample prints on the box, but you also won't achieve the EPA-estimated gas mileage driving the way they show in car commercials. I have a different theory--power users want to have their cake and eat it too. People who print a lot lose under this model, because it shifts costs from light users to heavy users. From their perspective, it would be better to have expensive printers and cheap ink. (The same is true for price discrimination generally. Apple's pricing practices are good for people who can get away with a 32GB iPhone, bad for people who need a 256GB one.) Or, they're simply ignorant of the economics, and think that printer companies could offer unrestricted printers for the same price by cutting into their fat, fat profit margins.
- rahimnathwani 8y ago"The cartridges are sold on the shelf right next to the printers!" No they're not. The cartridges aren't usually on a shelf at all. Epson's ink cartridge retail packaging is designed to be hung on a hook. "Yes, that's not the coverage for eye-catching sample prints on the box, but you also won't achieve the EPA-estimated gas mileage driving the way they show in car commercials." Right, but the way EPA-estimated gas mileage is close to the way real people drive. The 4%-5% coverage listed in the PDF you linked is not, especially given that most home injket users are printing photos, web pages, and their kids' school stuff.
- rayiner 8y agoSee Figure 2 on page 3. Seems quite representative.
- rahimnathwani 8y agoThose pages in figure 2, that have 5% coverage PER COLOUR may be representative of the median coverage, but not of the mean. Watch some middle school kids print out their homework. That one cover slide with a coloured background, or the few slides with full page photos, may have close to 50% coverage per colour. Even if only every tenth page is like that, the mean coverage will be twice the median.