3 ms·
I think your whole characterization of pilot theory's value and its relation to other interpretations is incorrect. Firstly, it's primary value is that it's an
by naasking 8y ago
I think your whole characterization of pilot theory's value and its relation to other interpretations is incorrect.
Firstly, it's primary value is that it's an ontological interpretation, meaning it preserves realism where most other interpretations sacrifice realism. The motion of its beables has nothing to do with this.
Secondly, pilot wave theory still requires the fewest number of assumptions, roughly on par with Many-Worlds, which means it's axiomatically simpler than other interpretations.
Whatever you mean by "simpler", its not a form of simplicity that actually matters when gauging plausibility of a theory.
- lmm 8y agoI see many-worlds as a strict subset of pilot wave theory, since the pilot waves behave in exactly the same way as a many-worlds wavefunction. Adding a layer of particles-guided-by-the-waves on top of that is an extra complication that can only be justified (if at all) in terms of the intuitive appeal of their resemblance to macroscopic physics. (There's an argument of avoiding nonlocality/spooky-action-at-a-distance which I find specious: the particles are indeed localised but they don't actually play any significant role in determining behaviour. The pilot waves are doing all the work in the theory, and they have all the usual entanglement/interference/... behaviour (as they must, in order to be a correct theory of QM)).
- naasking 8y ago> Adding a layer of particles-guided-by-the-waves on top of that is an extra complication that can only be justified (if at all) in terms of the intuitive appeal of their resemblance to macroscopic physics. This "Bohmian mechanics is Many-Worlds in disguise" is simply false [1]. The axiomatic basis is completely different, and this is apparent because with Bohmian mechanics you can easily derive the Born rule, and as a result, it also makes a new prediction that isn't allowed in typical QM, quantum non-equilibrium [2]. Deriving the Born rule with MWI is a hotly debated open problem. [1] https://arxiv.org/abs/0811.0810 https://arxiv.org/abs/0811.0810 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_non-equilibrium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_non-equilibrium
- lmm 8y ago> This "Bohmian mechanics is Many-Worlds in disguise" is simply false [1]. Saying "clearly" a lot does not convince me, and seems to be all that paper does. > The axiomatic basis is completely different, and this is apparent because with Bohmian mechanics you can easily derive the Born rule, and as a result, it also makes a new prediction that isn't allowed in typical QM, quantum non-equilibrium [2]. You've contradicted yourself: a quantum non-equilibrium condition would be one that did not follow the Born rule. Excluding quantum non-equilibrium requires an additional rule and looks to be much the same problem as deriving the Born rule under MWI. Were quantum non-equilibrium to be observed, that would be major evidence that our current understanding of QM is wrong; however, by the same token, our non-observation of it must count as evidence against a theory that predicts it.
- Strilanc 8y ago> pilot wave theory still requires the fewest number of assumptions, roughly on par with Many-Worlds, which means it's axiomatically simpler than other interpretations Isn't the most common complaint about pilot-wave that the wave corresponds to normal QM and the pilot is a superfluous detail? I would not pick minimalism as one of its strengths.
- naasking 8y ago> I would not pick minimalism as one of its strengths. Minimalism is one of its strengths. The type of objection you raise is a fundamental misunderstanding of both pilot wave theories, and what "minimalism" actually means when it comes to selecting among competing theories.