36 ms·
I don't disagree, but it's really really hard to determine what proper liability should be. It's easy with things like "Company X left their S3 bucket publicly
by freedomben 8y ago
I don't disagree, but it's really really hard to determine what proper liability should be. It's easy with things like "Company X left their S3 bucket publicly accessible then put PII in it." It's much less easy when "Company Y got hacked because of a 0-day in their OS kernel, or in their web server that is an open-source project, or even a 0-day in a codebase that they own but have generally very good practices on (stuff happens, even very good devs write bugs sometimes)."
Does the Linux Foundation or a group of random devs on github that gave their code away for free get handed a massive and possibly bankrupting fine for that? And if so, why would anybody release code for free? If not, and you say that "GPL/MIT/etc. warrants no serviceability so it's on the adopter," then why would anybody use open source and open themselves up to the liability when they have zero control over the project and its associated quality control and process?
For this reason I don't think governments can do a good job at making fair regulation that doesn't have severe unintended consequences.
Something that might help tho, is providing easier civil recourse for those affected. For example, if Equifax gets hacked and leaks my identity and somebody buys a car in my name, it should be very easy for me to sue them to make it right. That's something that is clearly broken with our current system.
- sopooneo 8y agoI say companies should pay a painful fine for all data breaches no matter what. They'll have to buy insurance against it, and the insurers will eventually learn to price the risk properly. And it will also be in the insurers' interest to learn how to audit their client companies.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoYup. Take GDPR. It doesn't try to price user data. If you screw up real bad, it just says, "up to €20 million, or 4% of the worldwide annual revenue of the prior financial year, whichever is higher".
- felix_nagaand 8y agoFailing to disclose a breach should be treated like covering up a crime. Companies are dissolved, fines levied, people go to jail, damages are paid. Failing to address security vulnerabilities quickly, or publicize their existence and suspend operations until they're fixed is negligent and is most similar to reckless endangerment. Similarly, hiring inexperienced, unqualified, or otherwise knowingly incapable people to perform a job is negligence. Failing to know and perform what precautions one needs to take is likewise negligent. People go to jail, fines are levied, damages are paid. A previously unknown exploit used to gain access to a company is like a car accident and should be treated as such. Company pays damages and moves on.