3 ms·
Among other things, the situation in the article is an excellent example of why we need a national ID system instead of the absurd patchwork of different issuer
by crooked-v 8y ago
Among other things, the situation in the article is an excellent example of why we need a national ID system instead of the absurd patchwork of different issuers that exist today.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ghaff 8y agoLeaving aside the politics of a true national ID card, even if there were a national ID card which went beyond a social security card (which many people don't have a physical copy of), there is absolutely no way that the federal government is going to regulate driver's licenses. And that was the issue here. Of course, we also have a national ID in the form of passports, but a lot of people don't have one.
- toomuchtodo 8y ago> Of course, we also have a national ID in the form of passports, but a lot of people don't have one. Passports should be issued to citizens free of charge, and could carry driving endorsements as physical and digital metadata (I don't suggest that harmonizing driving credentialing and administration across all 50 states and other US territories is an enormous undertaking, just one that should be done).
- lbotos 8y agoAre there countries that issue passports for free now? Tried a quick search and didn't come up with anything fruitful.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoNot entirely free, but I did find several countries that charged as little as $15.
- fzeroracer 8y agoI suppose a happy medium would be making passports much easier to get. Make them completely free to apply for, simplify the paperwork and start automatically printing passports for newborns. This doesn't solve the issue of people lacking a drivers license but might solve a few others along the way.
- koolba 8y ago> ... there is absolutely no way that the federal government is going to regulate driver's licenses. While true, it’s also hilarious as they do indirectly regulate speed limits, road composition, vehicle safety features, and emission standards. So basically everything except the person operating the vehicle.
- cure 8y agoThe federal government also indirectly regulates driver's licenses, cf. the Real ID act (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_ID_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_ID_Act).
- ghaff 8y agoVery indirect. They have requirements for driver's licenses being used as IDs for federal purposes. (Which is actually not unreasonable although we got by without doing so for many years.) The issue of course is that their driver's license is the only government-issued photo ID they possess so if they want to fly or enter a federal building without a driver's license, they would need to get a federal ID such as a passport issued which has both monetary and time costs. (And isn't available for everyone.)
- dhshsjsjd 8y agoPassports can’t double as ID because that’d conflict with the primary purpose of passports, passing through borders. A national ID would presumably be available, or obligatory, to everyone. But countries can and do deny passports or rescind them < the passport is a letter asking the govt of a foreign country to let its citizen in. Sometimes you don’t want a citizen to leave or vouch for him. Anyways all states I’ve lived in have IDs that are solely IDs
- toomanybeersies 8y agoNational ID is opposed in the USA (and also in New Zealand, Australia, and the UK) because it's seen as overly intrusive of the government. It starts as a national ID scheme, and then eventually everything about your life gets centralised into one database, which the government is free to abuse. I'm also opposed to the idea that you're legally required to carry an ID card at all times, like in many European countries. This is already happening in Australia with MyGov, which is an online platform for all your government things. As part of MyGov, they've introduced My Health Record, which is single central medical record. Apparently the Australian Taxation Office have been using My Health Record to go after sex workers for tax evasion by searching for people with an abnormally high frequency of STI checks.
- rayiner 8y agoAlso, it would be a huge waste of time to issue national ID cards now, when we're on the verge of splintering into warring nation states.
- drdeadringer 8y agoHonest Question: ... really?
- rayiner 8y agoI'm being glib, but I gotta say that "increased integration" seems like the last thing we need in a country full of people that hate each other.
- tptacek 8y agoThe enmity doesn't break down on convenient geographical lines; it basically just charts how prosperous the urban centers of each state are.
- rayiner 8y agoWhile Ds and Rs are interspersed within states, I feel like there is a lot more acrimony between states than within them. I feel like Ds in Maryland wouldn't be so upset if they were just dealing with Rs in Maryland (and vice versa).
- rayiner 8y agoIt sounds like the problem was bureaucracy--Georgia not being able to fix a birth certificate issue without travelling to Georgia. The solution to that is--to nationalize the bureaucracy? It's not like a nationalized system wouldn't be dependent on administrative subdivisions. In this case, Mr. Bearden's birth information would've still been filed away somewhere in Atlanta. Likewise, any solution that involves getting those records from Atlanta to somewhere else could be implemented just as easily without having a central national ID system.
- x86_64Ubuntu 8y agoSeems to work with car registrations. When I was in Kansas City, a police officer was able to run my tag even though I'm from South Carolina. Kind of funny how the government just simply can't do anything that might help the common man, but when it concerns authoritarian tendencies, the motivation is endless.