3 ms·
Which works great when you have a decentralized internet with a million separate sections where people with different views congregate with their own community
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
Which works great when you have a decentralized internet with a million separate sections where people with different views congregate with their own community moderation policies.
But when it comes to YouTube or Facebook, no moderation policy is appropriate because there is no single set of community standards for all users. When you have more users than most countries have citizens, you're acting in the role of a government.
Obviously the best solution to this is to get back to a decentralized internet where no one site has more than 5% of the total users, but in the meantime the big players shouldn't be censoring anything. And if that so happens to make them less competitive against smaller sites without so many users they're expected not to restrict anything -- good.
- leetcrew 8y ago> Obviously the best solution to this is to get back to a decentralized internet where no one site has more than 5% of the total users, but in the meantime the big players shouldn't be censoring anything. And if that so happens to make them less competitive against smaller sites without so many users they're expected not to restrict anything -- good. i would like to see governments take more of a black/white stance toward "safe harbor" protections. if you need to moderate for the bottom line, you can do it, but this should come with additional liability.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThen nobody would do it. It isn't bad to have moderated spaces as long as they're actually run by individual communities and not amalgamated general purpose platforms imposing one party's views on everybody else. As soon as you impose liability you go from moderation as a mechanism to weed out malice to essentially an editorial board that has to pre-approve everything as officially sanctioned by the platform. It excludes an important middle ground.
- bilbo0s 8y ago>But when it comes to YouTube or Facebook, no moderation policy is appropriate because there is no single set of community standards for all users... There doesn't have to be. In my view, YouTube and Facebook, are private property. It's like the example of the exclusive country club. I can't argue that the country club is big and has all the best restaurants, so they have to let me in. It's their club. Or perhaps a more analogous example. What happens a lot up here in Wisconsin is that some families sit on a lot of land. Needless to say, during deer season, there are a lot of people who think they can just go on that land to hunt. But that's not how it works. I don't like it. I'd like to hunt on some of that land. It's all of the best spots being monopolized by one family, but it's THEIR property. My right to hunt doesn't mean that all of a sudden they don't have a right to their land. It's their land. Same with YouTube. Go to another video streaming site. Or start your own. But you don't get to tell YouTube what to do with their video streaming site. Your right to speak freely is not impinged at all by them precluding you from their site for instance. Any more than my right to hunt is impinged by a certain family, that shall remain nameless, not sharing their land.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThere is a difference between having a lot of land and having all the land. There is also a difference between recreation and constitutional rights necessary for the successful operation of a democracy. If someone has a thousand times more land than the average person, but still only 5% of all the land, they have no obligation to share. If someone has more than half of all of it, it's antitrust time and different rules apply.
- bilbo0s 8y agoBut no one's constitutional rights are violated by a guy owning land, or indeed, by a guy owning a video service. You don't like his service, use another. YouTube doesn't own all of the video streaming services around. Not even close. All your arguments just don't apply to the case you're trying to make. YouTube doesn't own all the video streaming services. And the government doesn't restrict your right to speak freely outside of YouTube. So where is the necessity to speak on YouTube coming from? You haven't presented an argument that would, in any way, support abrogating our social compact of private property.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> You don't like his service, use another. Sure, all you have to do is get all your viewers to switch from Facebook/YouTube to something else. Which you have no real control over, hence the problem.
- bilbo0s 8y agoBut that's not a problem with YouTube. YouTube is not forcing your friends to use YouTube, and neither is the government. Your friends can easily view your video stream on any other service. So "but my friends won't use Twitch instead", is not really a legitimate reason for us to abandon our belief in private property. Sorry.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago