5 ms·
It’s unfair that companies, who have extremely high power in the relationship, can load their contracts up with one-sided and often unenforceable stuff. Employe
by ryandrake 8y ago
It’s unfair that companies, who have extremely high power in the relationship, can load their contracts up with one-sided and often unenforceable stuff. Employees, who are the party with low power, must accept the terms or GTFO. Then the onus is on them to spend their time and money fighting the legal battle to invalidate these unenforceable bits.
Wouldn’t it be fairer if the party with all the power, and who dictates the content of the contract, must convince a judge that it’s enforceable before a defendant has to lift a finger or shell out money?
Currently contracts seem to be nothing more than one-sided weapons that powerful companies use to get vulnerable people to do things that they otherwise wouldn’t and can’t afford to fight. Let’s not pretend that more than a small fraction of employees out there actually get to meaningfully alter the contracts under which they work.
- rm_-rf_slash 8y agoThat’s why we have/had unions.
- bicubic 8y agoWhy the hell is this being downvoted? Collective bargaining is one of the primary purposes of a union
- chrisseaton 8y agoA lot of workers do not like unions for many reasons (not a valid reason to downvote, but it's probably why.)
- galaxyLogic 8y agoIt's possible that mafia gains control of a union, think Jim Hoffa. That of course is not the purpose of labor movement. It's a bit like marriage you have to pay a bit for it but having someone support you and fight with you is worth the commitment. Unite!
- throwaway2048 8y agoIts also possible that the mafia (or mafia esque tactics) gain control of businesses too.
- badpun 8y ago> Employees, who are the party with low power, must accept the terms or GTFO. I have successfully asked for some clauses to be removed from the contract.
- eropple 8y agoAs have I, but it requires a certain level of confidence and market position (and the knowledge that you can). A better world is one where this doesn't...yanno...happen at all, yeah?
- ryandrake 8y agoSure, a relatively small number of employees have this ability, due to market demand or whatever, so congrats! If you want to feel what it’s like to negotiate employment as a more usual employee, try negotiating the terms of your cell phone contract.
- pnutjam 8y agoHe said he got his, what don't you understand. He' what's wrong with America, BTW.
- sneak 8y agoI disagree. It is not a better world to prevent people (employers) from doing things that they wish to do, that willing consensual partners in those activities do not object to. If you don’t want this to happen in your own life, then don’t sign such contracts. Leave other people to their own business. You are not their parent.
- Xylakant 8y agoThis is spoken from a position of privilege. We, as highly skilled tech workers in a field where demand outstrips availability, with probably a solid rainy day fund accumulated, we can afford to say no to a contract because we know the next is round the corner and we know how to feed family until then. A large chunk of the workforce does not. They depend on the paycheck, need to feed people that depend on them and in their case, the employer holds all the cards. They more or less must sign. Even if they have another option lined up, for them it’s probably the choice between bad or worse terms.
- sneak 8y agoWhy do you think employees have less power? Both parties have exactly the same power: to kill the deal. Contracts only happen by mutual consent.
- azag0 8y agoYes. But that’s not the point. The point is that the leverage of both parties entering the negotiation is in most cases very skewed.
- the_dege 8y agoIf you have the money/family support... If you are young enough... If you are not a woman... Add any minority to the list as needed. You can't always afford to turn down a job offer.
- cmiles74 8y agoEmployers have a much larger pool from which to choose employees than the pool of employers from which any one employee may choose. In addition, the majority of employers have (either by coincidence or agreement) landed on a similar set of crappy and unreasonable contracts. For the vast number of employees out there, it's either submit to the contract or remain unemployed.
- ryandrake 8y agoYes, and yes, and don’t forget: employers tend to have ready access to legal advice which is too expensive for the average employee. Our legal system gives strong advantages to entities the more they can afford.
- eeZah7Ux 8y agoNot to mention the impact of not signing a contract is much higher for a person than for a company.
- ben_w 8y agoIn many cases, employees are replaceable cogs who can be done without for the brief period before being replaced, while employment is vital and the absence of it for even short durations can be life-threatening. Software is a rare exception, not the rule. Even then, people like me who have enough savings to live for over a year without a paid job (looking after a parent with Alzheimer’s in my case) are a tiny minority.
- athenot 8y agoI think this could be solved by outlawing severability (where if one clause of the contract is junk, the rest still stands). That would make the contract written in a much more careful manner, and make those junk clauses a liability for the entire contract. Not a lawyer though, so happy to hear the flaws in this.
- nerdponx 8y agoWhat if you make an honest mistake in the wording? What if the contract is complicated and you end up having part of it invalidated in court? What if the law changes, making part of your contract unenforceable? There are so many good reasons to not outlaw severability, whereas outlawing it is a poor solution to one specific problem.
- logfromblammo 8y agoPut a hard limit on clauses that may be severed without invalidating the entire contract. Two, perhaps. Three strikes, and you're out.
- PurpleBoxDragon 8y ago>What if the contract is complicated and you end up having part of it invalidated in court? Sounds like a feature, not a bug. Contracts have to be simple. If you can't do the transaction with a simple contract, you have to find a different method to carry out what ever is desired to be done.
- nerdponx 8y agoI'm sorry, but this is a ridiculous statement. This isn't just about labor contracts. Contracts between businesses need to cover lots of different eventualities and edge cases. They need to acknowledge and adhere to a variety of laws, depending on the jurisdictions involved. Disclosures must be made. Eventualities must be planned for. Nobody (for the most part) wants to go to court to resolve something that could have been headed off in a contract.
- djsumdog 8y ago> Currently contracts seem to be nothing more than one-sided weapons that powerful companies use to get vulnerable people to do things that they otherwise wouldn’t and can’t afford to fight. That totally hits the issue on the head. They're not negotiated contracts. They're one sided hammers.
- BonesJustice 8y agoIndeed. If there is no downside to stuffing contracts with every potentially useful clause they can think of, then why not do so? Perhaps the solution is to give workers the right to have employment-related contracts reviewed and negotiated by an attorney of their choosing at the employer’s expense. With actual costs attached, employers would suddenly have an incentive to keep their contracts as short and simple as possible, reserving the more onerous clauses for only the most senior positions. Contracts for most positions would need to be kept short, reasonable, and comprehensible such that candidates don’t feel the need to exercise their right to attorney review.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wool_gather 8y ago> Perhaps the solution is to give workers the right to have employment-related contracts reviewed and negotiated by an attorney of their choosing at the employer’s expense. This is one of the key reasons that unions are helpful to workers: each one of them doesn't have to go through this on their own. One expert does it for all of them.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- TheAceOfHearts 8y agoThis would be incredibly hostile to small businesses. Now you need to waste even more money on lawyers and tons of time navigating useless government bureaucracy. Big companies will be able to comply with any regulation thrown their way, but I don't think you can say the same about smaller shops. Your solution is penalizing good actors as well. I can just imagine it now: Oh, we want to hire you but it looks like the next available turn for contract reviews is 1 month from now. Sorry, looks like you'll have to sit around without making any money in the meantime. A judge's time is generally quite expensive, and handling the massive load of contracts would likely require appointing a lot more judges. What if both parties are fine with a contract? Why should they be forced to get the government involved? And if both parties decide to re-negotiate a contract, do we need to go through the whole government approval process again? I agree that there are issues with some employment contracts, but you are making some incredibly broad generalizations focused on a few bad actors without taking into consideration the broader consequences.
- Nullabillity 8y ago> This would be incredibly hostile to small businesses. Now you need to waste even more money on lawyers and tons of time navigating useless government bureaucracy. Big companies will be able to comply with any regulation thrown their way, but I don't think you can say the same about smaller shops. Your solution is penalizing good actors as well. This would encourage shorter and simpler contracts, making things easier for both the parties and any involved judge. > What if both parties are fine with a contract? Why should they be forced to get the government involved? And if both parties decide to re-negotiate a contract, do we need to go through the whole government approval process again? Because, as the GP mentioned, it is not an agreement between equals.
- sincerely 8y agoI have no sympathy for a small business that includes unenforceable terms in a contract and I'm not sure why you are considering them a "good actor".
- nraynaud 8y agoI know that in France the unions are mostly doing contract review. They have their little desk, and employees come see them after they have been wronged by their employer, and the union member spends hours with the law books reviewing the contracts, various written interaction and timeline of event. People think of them as mostly organizing strikes or demonstrations, while most members spends their time reading laws and contracts. When they start seeing a new illegal trend, they blow the whistle publicly.
- mindslight 8y ago> Currently contracts seem to be nothing more than one-sided weapons that powerful companies use to get vulnerable people to do things that they otherwise wouldn’t and can’t afford to fight. Let’s not pretend that more than a small fraction of employees out there actually get to meaningfully alter the contracts under which they work. A straightforward way to address this could be through standardized contracts/clauses for mass markets. In the world of software understanding is not free, and the world of ambiguous natural language legalese is clearly even worse! In a market big enough to have many parallel participants, each clause of an agreement should be selected from a standardized bag such that online reading can readily explain your rights and responsibilities. For the most part, this is already somewhat done through state "employment law", "landlord-tenant law", and the like. But then we get the OP situation, as well as contracts that actually attempt to countermand the law - I recently had the pleasure of reading a lease that was essentially an anti-tenant screed. From the other direction, it also would be nice to voluntarily be able to give up a currently "standardized right" - say I don't need hot water in my apartment for savings of $100/mo. Assuming it was truly consensual and not just setting up a race to the bottom - percentages quotas or the like could address this.