5 ms·
Over a trillion dollars over 28 years. There are about 250 million U.S. taxpayers. That's $150 out of the pocket of every single taxpayer, every year, just to c
by kibwen 8y ago
Over a trillion dollars over 28 years. There are about 250 million U.S. taxpayers. That's $150 out of the pocket of every single taxpayer, every year, just to cover the cost of this one monumentally embarrassing failure. If you're a U.S. citizen born after 1974, you've been setting fire to this money annually for your entire adult life. No value has been provided other than as a government subsidy to military contractors, and if the whole point is just to transfer wealth to military contractors then we might as well just call it a subsidy and have them sit on their hands rather than continually embarrass us with their empirical incompetence. It's hard not to seethe with rage at the thought of all the better things that this money could have been spent on. I look forward to wasting my tax dollars on this boondoggle for the rest of my life.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoIt’s even worse, since there is also the opportunity cost of what could have been done with all the time & materials. A purely direct wealth transfer of the net profit would at least save that all, which could have gone into something else. And possibly also environmental costs.
- saas_sam 8y agoI mean it's not like the money just went into a hole. These things were built by U.S. factories. Not the best use of taxpayer money by any means, and we are right to be angry, I just want to point that out.
- greeneggs 8y agoMisallocating labor is worse than throwing the money into a hole. The money itself doesn't matter, it's just an accounting tool.
- mikestew 8y agoI mean it's not like the money just went into a hole. It went into a big ol' hole that had a billboard next to it labelled "Opportunity Cost".
- sosborn 8y agoOut of curiosity, does the 250 million taxpayers include tax paying businesses?
- kibwen 8y agoNope, and although that suggests that $150 would be an overestimate (if we disregard the huge portion of taxes that are earmarked for social security, individual income tax contributes 80% of government revenue), this is countered by 1. the fact that the $1 trillion price tag is a low-ball estimate, 2. the fact that the tax base was 50 million fewer 30 years ago, and 3. the unlikelihood that the price tag is adjusting for inflation, which would increase the real value of contributions over the past 30 years (according to CPI, prices in 2017 were 87% higher than prices in 1990).
- belltaco 8y agoAren't the same tax payers paying for the business taxes as well through the increased price of goods?
- bradfa 8y agoSure, some of the money has gone to a small number of rich people, but there's quite a large number of working class people designing and assembling these planes. To say that the money has been set on fire or that no value has been provided seems a bit harsh, much of the money is employing a large number of skilled people in the USA and in other countries. And it's not just the USA taxpayers who are paying for this, these planes are sold to a few different customer countries.
- maxander 8y agoAll of those skilled workers could have been building something useful, however. The waste of their time and skill is indeed burning resources, in an even more concrete sense than setting money on fire.
- spaceribs 8y agoBut then they would have time to be politically active enough to demand better living conditions and social safety.
- vkou 8y agoThey could be, but if the program didn't exist, our economic system would not have allocated their labour to productive ends.
- tadfisher 8y agoThat's a fairly conclusive statement with no objective basis. Care to elaborate?
- vkou 8y agoWe have millions of unemployed people, and much work that needs to be done (Teaching, childcare, elderly care, infrastructure maintenance, construction, etc.) Why aren't they doing it? Could it be because we don't optimize for 'overall value created'?
- 8y ago
- pwaivers 8y ago> "No value has been provided..." There is value provided. These planes support the US world hegemony and are amazing centerpieces of the US military. If you argue that we could have done it for cheaper, that is fair. But there is value in them.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoOnly if they work consistently, which they've yet to start doing.
- barrow-rider 8y agoJDAMs, NATO, and the Petr-Dollar are doing more for US Hegemony than these overpriced drone-stop-gaps ever will.
- rbanffy 8y ago> No value has been provided Well... The US, and every country that's paying attention learned how not to build a military plane.
- melling 8y agoWe spent $1 trillion on the war in Iraq in 10 years. Another trillion in Afghanistan. Our budget deficit starting next year will be $1 trillion a year for the next decade. While I think the F35 project was a mess, there are even bigger problems in comparison. The interest on the debt is going to grow to an incredible amount: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/the-skyrocketing-interest-payments-on-u-s-debt/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/the-skyrocketing-interest-payme...
- kibwen 8y agoThere's no reason to suspect that my opposition to the F-35 implies support for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. In fact, I'll be explicit: the Iraq and Afghanistan wars were and are shameful, deplorable wastes of human life and resources.
- melling 8y ago"Over the next decade, interest costs will total nearly $7 trillion, rising to become the third-largest 'program' in the federal budget." If you thought a trillion dollars over thirty years for the most advanced jet in the world was a lot of money, how do you feel about getting absolutely nothing for $7 trillion?
- ChuckMcM 8y agoAnd the Trump tax cut will grow the debt by a trillion dollars in just 10 years[1]. So in a sense you and everyone else are just buying this on your credit card and letting your grand kids pay it off. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/25/business/trump-corporate-tax-cut-deficit.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/25/business/trump-corporate-...
- agumonkey 8y agoIs it that embarassing ? I couldn't find a good summary about the state of F-35s. I don't think 150usd per year is a huge amount of money (12.5 per month). (Sure for some it's vital, I'm not saying this). Military..
- Analemma_ 8y agoIt amounts to about $100 million every single day, if that helps make the absurdity more clear.
- mrbonner 8y agoHow do you ratify the hidden benefits of advanced researches going along with the aircraft? Have you seen the flight helmet with integrated HUD? I think it is out of this world. And it is just one of the many advanced technologies created in the process. Saying this is a waste of money is akin to say NASA mission is a waste of money.
- kibwen 8y agoI hate the argument that we should tolerate wasteful military spending because it sometimes creates accidentally results in useful applications. For $1 trillion dollars, how many millions of worthwhile discoveries could have been devised by directly investing in scientific research? Saying that military spending is a worthwhile vehicle for useful research is akin to saying that a worthwhile way to power a car is to use gasoline to heat a water boiler to drive a steam turbine. The inefficiency is astounding.
- mmmmmmmmm 8y agoIf you don't like it, vote for lower taxes. Also, to claim this program has produced nothing of value is an outright bold-faced lie. The US has received over 300 planes from this project.
- Buldak 8y agoI'm kind of baffled by the number of people here defending this. I can only imagine that Americans have an emotional investment in their military that inclines them to overlook waste that they would never tolerate in any other area.
- mmmmmmmmm 8y agoI'm kind of baffled by the number of people here opposing investment in technological advancements. You'd think hacker news of all places would understand the risks inherent in investing in an any sort of state-of-the-art technological project. Not all projects are going to succeed; but that doesn't mean we shouldn't try. It seems the real reason these people are angry is because they hate how strong the US military is. You know they don't actually care about the wasted money because they're also the same people who think we should be spending billions of dollars a year on state-funded healthcare to keep octogenarians alive a year longer.
- barrow-rider 8y ago> I'm kind of baffled by the number of people here defending this With literally trillions of dollars at stake, why wouldn't defense contractors set up "marketing" teams to defend it? And the post above: "adversaries are posting about how bad it is to run support for it" -- a perfect dodge. If you're not supporting this gigantic fucking money pit then you're clearly in league with the enemy.
- kibwen 8y agoConsidering that this has been flagged off the front page after receiving 92 upvotes in one hour, I'd say you may be on to something.
- davemp 8y agoThis is an overreaction. The F35 is a maturing platform. Issues are being ironed out and the result will be an incredible aircraft far beyond any other fighter currently flown. There is a product. The run away price tag certainly shows inefficiencies of contracting at this scale. Accountability is not really there for companies that do not perform to the level required to honor their contracts. Patents, required expertise, and other logistical hurdles keep competitors few. Building military systems is not software, there are so many considerations and potential roadblocks. Tests cost millions and take months to years. Think of how difficult and expensive it is to make an iPhone--iPhones don't have to perform deft aerial maneuvers at Mach speed, win the (complex as hell) radar/sensor game of cat&mouse, and hit things with missiles. $1 trillion sounds like a lot, but keep in mind our beloved iPhone company is worth about that much. My iPhone 8 certainly provides me more direct value as an individual, but the capability of an F35 is not a cheap thing.
- onetimemanytime 8y agoBroadly speaking...didn't we lose just the after tax profit that companies made? Of course there's an opportunity cost but this is FedGov, not exactly known for using tax dollars as best they could /should.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]