4 ms·
Personally I am most worried about the coordinated rhetorical push against "toxicity". It seems far too vague and exploitable and promotive of a centralizing ag
by Nasrudith 8y ago
Personally I am most worried about the coordinated rhetorical push against "toxicity". It seems far too vague and exploitable and promotive of a centralizing agenda and increased control. There are complete assholes of course but everything about the solutions seems like a pretext for control akin to "think of the children" while their spending and other efforts make it clear that they aren't something they are interested in helping or protecting but in use as a shield.
It brings to mind YouTube's issues with advertisers and their clients being fools. People head away from the stale inoffensive mass market of television and then they start complaining about their brand being associated with it. Rather than realize that is where the traffic is try to reshape things to what they already left.
- charlesism 8y ago> "think of the children" Well, that trope usually applies to children doing themselves harm. I do not worry overly about children harming themselves in the current environment. I worry about them harming me.
- WalterSear 8y agoIt's a Simpsons reference, using the term ironically. https://youtu.be/7xbW0TtZMPQ https://youtu.be/7xbW0TtZMPQ
- charlesism 8y agoI realize that. People generally refer to that quote to criticize people who use "protecting the children" to shame others into supporting bad arguments. Where social media is concerned, the situation is different. The worry is that "the children" will grow up with a bunch of insane, toxic ideas, and their behavior will endanger the rest of us. So it would be more apt to say "think of the adults!"
- criddell 8y agoI'm not really worried for a couple of reasons. Your worries about the rise of think of the children excuses, well, there are a lot of children there. Maybe we should think of them... The big reason I'm not worried is that no change is ever permanent. If the rules turn out to be too restrictive, then do another pass at them. Today, Reddit is a shitty place that I think is a net-negative for the world. If they were to change the rules and turn it into some kind of milquetoast site that was neutral or mildly positive, I think we would be better off. I think the sad truth is that all that toxicity is making the few people running Reddit a lot of money and that's all they care about.
- candiodari 8y agoWhat about the many times in history where that was effectively not the case ? I mean, say, take a Russian living in 1905 under the Tsar. Odds are very slim indeed they would have lived to the point when times/rules got better again. Or a Chinese living in the 1920s ? Rules relaxed again in both cases, but those people would have died long before the rules changed back.
- alphabettsy 8y agoI see where you’re coming from, but you’re talking about a governmental and cultural shift to restrict liberties compared to booting some people or organizations from a virtual platform.