4 ms·
The sheer lack of nuance in just chemicals is ignorant and inherently leads to foolishness. It is about as good a framework as trying to decide if binary 1s or
by Nasrudith 8y ago
The sheer lack of nuance in just chemicals is ignorant and inherently leads to foolishness. It is about as good a framework as trying to decide if binary 1s or 0s are more dangerous. Bioaccumulation is totally peripheral to inherit toxicity although it makes toxins more problematic. Drinking too much colloidal silver will turn you blue-gray but it won't kill you.
Reminds me of "organic pesticides" being treated as rhetorically as safer because they are easier to understand despite it being the exact opposite and including heavy metals. They are broad mechanism toxins that effect essentially everything organic while synthetics are tailored to do things like disrupt very specific proteins that aren't even found in the vertabrates - much less humans themselves. Preferring known dangerous heavy metals over a remote possibility that something far safer and biodegradable that /might/ have something unknown is FUD just as sure as a known embezzler running for reelection saying his opponent might raise taxes.
- strainer 8y agoOrganic standards allow use of copper sulphate (subject to more controls that non-organic certified produce) It is entirely false to characterize organic as "including heavy metals" when they simply allow a fairly common and light "heavy metal" compound which is already permitted outside their standards (ALL organic standards are permitted for non organic use) Its striking that you could begin by lamenting "sheer lack of nuance" and proceed to base an entire criticism on deceived and inaccurate nuance.
- Nasrudith 8y agoI was thinking of the lead arsenate used in apple orchards. Specifically its widespread use to combat moth epidemics that were causing major problems and is related to contamination of groundwater around them. It was first replaced by the technically less longterm contaminating DDT briefly before a less toxic effective replacement could be found. Apparently it was banned by the 80s so I messed up the specifics but the point is that "organic" old style pesticides were often worse in toxicity and are far more general in their targetting.
- strainer 8y agoNeither Lead salts or Arsenic are permitted by organic standards. No substances permitted by organic standards are not permitted under general standards. You can check §205.602 here : https://www.ecfr.gov/cgi-bin/text-idx?c=ecfr&SID=9874504b6f1025eb0e6b67cadf9d3b40&rgn=div6&view=text&node=7:3.1.1.9.32.7 https://www.ecfr.gov/cgi-bin/text-idx?c=ecfr&SID=9874504b6f1... "I messed up the specifics but the point is that "organic" old style pesticides were often worse ..." You have not supported that argument, that organic certified pesticides were "often worse" You seem to be misapplying the term "organic" - its a movement/brand name, not a complete selection criteria. The name refers to the "organism" of the plant,animal,ecosystem. It is a general principle that permitted substances and practices should in addition to appearing safe in the immediate term - not be alien to the life and ecosystems involved (much decreasing the likelihood of unexpected reactions in longer term)