6 ms·

This occured minutes ago. This live stream coverage shows the failure in the end https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O8d9CqS2cvc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O8

by exDM69 8y ago

This occured minutes ago. This live stream coverage shows the failure in the end https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O8d9CqS2cvc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O8d9CqS2cvc NASA live stream last minutes have audio track (in russian and translated to english) following the failure. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gDcYgYQbHg8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gDcYgYQbHg8 Both streams were abruptly halted, but links work for now. Crew survived.

modernerd 8y ago
Timestamp of booster failure / eject seems to be 3:06:36. https://youtu.be/O8d9CqS2cvc?t=11194 https://youtu.be/O8d9CqS2cvc?t=11194
- lstodd 8y ago
  No, that's first stage separation.
- scoggs 8y ago
  Thanks! If you want to watch the entire take-off itself as well it starts @ 3:03:20 https://youtu.be/O8d9CqS2cvc?t=11000 https://youtu.be/O8d9CqS2cvc?t=11000
- bulatb 8y ago
  Between 3:06 and 3:07 they're reporting first stage separation was good and the rocket is performing well. 3:07:15: The male Russian voice says "Booster failure, right? Two minutes, forty-five seconds."
  - modernerd 8y ago
    Ah! Thank you.
  - bulatb 8y ago
    Other sources are saying the problem happened at booster separation. Maybe that was the initial cause and the actual failure developed some seconds later? Not sure how to reconcile that with this audio.
    - ygra 8y ago
      The telemetry will tell. Rockets send back heaps of data from dozens, if not hundreds of sensors. All that is stored precisely so there's no guesswork based on a ground camera and the real-time audio needed.
dogma1138 8y ago
Good that they cut the steam I don’t understand the criticism of them doing so if this had turned to be a disaster I don’t think the family of the astronauts would want the whole world seeing the disaster as it happens live.
- Delynx 8y ago
  --
  - larkeith 8y ago
    You may want to reread OPs comment - it mentions nothing of withholding information from the family, nor what they themselves want to hear.
    - dogma1138 8y ago
      it's a single comment account created to manufacture outrage there is no reason to think they are even here anymore nor that they would care to actually read my post.
  - dogma1138 8y ago
    Reading comprehension is a lost art i see in no where was it stated that cutting a the stream was done because of the families and friends especially solely but you need to be especially thick to reason that this isn't a consideration not to mention a benefit. In an emergency situation it's pretty common to shut down all non official communications and direct everything through the contingency execution channels as well as to clear all non essential personnel from the room and stop all non essential activities this includes activities such as streaming and posting on instagram to the dismay of millennials everywhere. It takes a special kind of person to think that the only reason people cut the stream during emergency is because they are trying to cover their asses, these people have dedicated their life to a job that isn't glamorous, doesn't pay well even in the US yet alone russia so yes they care about their colleagues and the people who they send up to space it's not that big of a club. And it's in no way presumptuous to think that families and friends of those who were in the capsule might not want the world to see the events as they unfold in real time in case the worst happens. I don't think you'll find many people that would say yes I would like the screams of my loved one to be broadcast live as the spacecraft they are in crashes into a mist of fire and debris on the ground. So yes congrats for managing to create a troll account for a single purpose of telling me exactly how wrong i was.
deleted 8y ago
[deleted]

by exDM69 8y ago

modernerd 8y ago

Timestamp of booster failure / eject seems to be 3:06:36. https://youtu.be/O8d9CqS2cvc?t=11194 https://youtu.be/O8d9CqS2cvc?t=11194

lstodd 8y ago
No, that's first stage separation.
scoggs 8y ago
Thanks! If you want to watch the entire take-off itself as well it starts @ 3:03:20 https://youtu.be/O8d9CqS2cvc?t=11000 https://youtu.be/O8d9CqS2cvc?t=11000
bulatb 8y ago
Between 3:06 and 3:07 they're reporting first stage separation was good and the rocket is performing well. 3:07:15: The male Russian voice says "Booster failure, right? Two minutes, forty-five seconds."
- modernerd 8y ago
  Ah! Thank you.
- bulatb 8y ago
  Other sources are saying the problem happened at booster separation. Maybe that was the initial cause and the actual failure developed some seconds later? Not sure how to reconcile that with this audio.
  - ygra 8y ago
    The telemetry will tell. Rockets send back heaps of data from dozens, if not hundreds of sensors. All that is stored precisely so there's no guesswork based on a ground camera and the real-time audio needed.

dogma1138 8y ago

Good that they cut the steam I don’t understand the criticism of them doing so if this had turned to be a disaster I don’t think the family of the astronauts would want the whole world seeing the disaster as it happens live.

Delynx 8y ago
--
- larkeith 8y ago
  You may want to reread OPs comment - it mentions nothing of withholding information from the family, nor what they themselves want to hear.
  - dogma1138 8y ago
    it's a single comment account created to manufacture outrage there is no reason to think they are even here anymore nor that they would care to actually read my post.
- dogma1138 8y ago
  Reading comprehension is a lost art i see in no where was it stated that cutting a the stream was done because of the families and friends especially solely but you need to be especially thick to reason that this isn't a consideration not to mention a benefit. In an emergency situation it's pretty common to shut down all non official communications and direct everything through the contingency execution channels as well as to clear all non essential personnel from the room and stop all non essential activities this includes activities such as streaming and posting on instagram to the dismay of millennials everywhere. It takes a special kind of person to think that the only reason people cut the stream during emergency is because they are trying to cover their asses, these people have dedicated their life to a job that isn't glamorous, doesn't pay well even in the US yet alone russia so yes they care about their colleagues and the people who they send up to space it's not that big of a club. And it's in no way presumptuous to think that families and friends of those who were in the capsule might not want the world to see the events as they unfold in real time in case the worst happens. I don't think you'll find many people that would say yes I would like the screams of my loved one to be broadcast live as the spacecraft they are in crashes into a mist of fire and debris on the ground. So yes congrats for managing to create a troll account for a single purpose of telling me exactly how wrong i was.

deleted 8y ago

[deleted]