5 ms·
Walmart turns to Flipkart for tech
- Brahma111 8y agoWhereas I agree that FK is right there when it comes to technology, this seems a little far fetched headline. 4 yrs back during a mega sale, FK servers crashed and they rightfully earned a lot of flak for that. From then on, they have been doing a pretty decent job (adopting actor model, PWA to name a few). But Walmart is also not living under a rock. I have consulted with them and they are just as good as any other Enterprise. Their biggest challenge is their vast team size with each group doing their own stuff in silos. FK will not help them address that
- puranjay 8y agoFlipkart does have a lot of expertise in last mile delivery and logistics. They manage to deliver in rural India where there are no proper addresses and infrastructure. Plus, Flipkart likely has a lot of expertise in mobile as well, given how much of India's internet usage is now mobile-only. I reckon that expertise is worth a lot for any company looking to expand in the developing world
- aedron 8y agoIn India, because of lack of infrastructure, you can order food from KFC without giving your name, address or any cash up front. The delivery guy simply tries to find the location you indicated and hopes that you show up with cash. I am guessing KFC simply pushes any losses downwards onto the branches or drivers. It's fine for India, but I don't think a lot of the business models and know-how that works in India transfers easily to conditions in the U.S.
- Alterlife 8y agoI live in Bangalore and it sounds like this is out of some kind of paralell reality. KFC/pizza hut/dominoes don't set up shop in remote places 'without infrastructure'. It doesn't make "business sense". They are mostly limited to cities. They don't deliver long distances, food delivery in general is limited to 2km, and they certainly don't deliver without a name, contact number and delivery address.
- aedron 8y agoThe point is you can give them any name, address or phone number you want. In most cases they won't even use the phone number, except for the driver if he can't find you when he is delivering the food.
- rco8786 8y agoHow is this any different than the rest of the world? If you want your food delivered you should probably give them a findable address.
- plainoldjavadev 8y agoThat is definitely not how it works, name address and phone number are mandatory with almost all delivery services. COD - Cash on Delivery is an additional option available because old time folks are not comfortable sharing their banking information with 3rd party services. Please take a look at Swiggy or Zomato.
- rohit2412 8y agoSo, going by that logic, since you can order from Amazon with any address, so Amazon delivery in America without addresses too
- Alterlife 8y ago> They manage to deliver in rural India where there are no proper addresses and infrastructure. I don't think this is true. You have to enter a pin code when you order from Flipkart. It's used to compute the delivery fee. Flipkart also used to refuse to deliver products to some pincodes though the list of supported numbers has definitely expanded over the years. In short, I don't know what their coverage level is, but it boils down to: you can't get a package delivered to anywhere where there is no post office.
- lumos_42 8y ago> They manage to deliver in rural India where there are no proper addresses and infrastructure. 'They' here means the transportation, not the marketplace. It comes down to the transportation to make sense of improper addresses and provide wide coverage. Also, Ekart has a very limited serviceability and flipkart has to rely on third party logistics.
- mathnmusic 8y agoFactorDaily is well-known for its click-baity headlines. They published an article about India's Shakti processor being an "ARM-killer" and the lead architect had to clarify this on HN itself: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15685019 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15685019
- NicoJuicy 8y agoThis is 11 months old and according to what i see, factordaily has a lot of articles. So, i'm not sure if one example can be generalized. Untill then, they keep in my rss list though :)
- mathnmusic 8y agoTheir content is often excellent. It's just that they often go overboard with their headlines. Have heard this complaint multiple times in my network.
- dunpeal 8y agoSerious question: what do you consider "any other enterprise" in this context? Because the obvious comparison would be Amazon, Walmart's chief competitor, and I don't know how they could match that seeing how they don't have anywhere near the kind of expertise, experience, and investment that Amazon had for over two decades. To me, it actually makes perfect sense for them to buy an Indian firm to become their tech lab. They don't have the knowledge or resources to even enter the field to compete for talent to build up their tech in the US - let alone win it.
- jorblumesea 8y agoBut does Walmart understand why FK works and how to use it? Can they take that talent and apply it to US markets to give them a long term competitive edge? Digging further, what business decisions got them into this mess? Will FK help them address their lack of vision or clarity around the new digital world? I feel like many businesses look to some hot new tech solution for what are fundamentally pure business problems. Akka, PWA and Tensorflow will not save Walmart from Amazon, if that is indeed the plan. Anyone can buy talented engineers, but can you use them?
- ravivyas 8y agoI would not call FK talent cheap, running a service at that scale is no easy feat.
- dilipray 8y agoAll the great tech guys are out of Flipkart long ago. Now they just have the crap.
- johnydepp 8y ago> what business decisions got them into this mess? Flipkart is head-on competition with amazon in India. And Walmart want to do the same in US. So what is your confusion? Wallmart can definitely apply the tech from FK to US market.
- jorblumesea 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- aodin 8y agoWhat a strange article - a discussion of Walmart's ecommerce technology without a single mention of its jet.com acquisition, which had over 1,000 employees in 2016 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jet.com https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jet.com)? The article is not praiseworthy enough to be a PR plant, and it lacks any substance from insiders. Seems to be tea leaf reading more than anything. I'd also add that the acquisition cost of Flipkart was largely driven by direct competition with Amazon during the bidding process.
- giancarlostoro 8y agoI was thinking the same thing, though I think Walmart is miss-interpreted they are not stuck behind the times when it comes to technology. In fact much like PayPal their infrastructure runs on Node (that way the front-end and back-end code is not so diversified). Now I know some people dislike NodeJS, but I hold the belief that programming language is irrelevant if you can be effective with it, and I noticed PayPal got much faster / stable after they switched to NodeJS, so JavaScript in back-end enterprise seems pretty damn effective. Now if only we could just stop treating Walmart like an old lady who needs hand holding when doing technology and see their acquisitions as more than acquihires and more as investments...
- dunpeal 8y ago> The article is not praiseworthy enough to be a PR plant, and it lacks any substance from insiders. Seems to be tea leaf reading more than anything. So par-the-course for "internet journalism".
- NTDF9 8y agoWalmart couldn't use Jet's technology in the US. What they want to do with FK is two-pronged: 1. Not lose, arguably, the second most important market in the world 2. Bring some of that web/app first executives in the fold and apply it in other markets like US or Europe. India is one of the few markets where a tiny company is still head-to-head with Amazon Walmart has money. They just don't want their old execs to run the e-commerce show.
- aodin 8y agoMarc Lore, the founder of jet.com, is currently the CEO of Walmart eCommerce U.S. Are you an insider? Where have you heard that Walmart was unable to use any of the jet.com technology?
- Nelkins 8y agoDisclaimer: I used to work at Jet and am biased. Not entirely true, but not entirely untrue either. In my opinion, lots of Jet tech was more stable, featureful, and performant than what Walmart had to offer. But in many cases, politics prevented them from taking full advantage of Jet's tech. In my experience, Walmart tech was very resistant to letting Jet run services that the Walmart website had to rely on (not in all cases; pretty sure Walmart is using Jet's inventory system: good presentation on it here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dSCzCaiWgLM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dSCzCaiWgLM). I think there was a feeling like we were encroaching on their territory. Think about it: Walmart buys Jet, Marc Lore is made head of Walmart eCommerce, layoffs happen on the Walmart side shortly thereafter. Not exactly something that will foster warm fuzzies. Walmart also gets WAY more traffic than Jet, and I think there was a little bit of dismissiveness caused by that too. A sense of, "We are the big fish, we are not doing anything wrong, and we are just going to keep on doing what we're doing." I'm sure there were other areas of close collaboration, but I didn't see too many of them. I haven't worked there for five or six months, so things may have changed, but that's how it was from my perspective. I did love working there though, was a very transformative time for me as a technologist.
- unmole 8y ago> India is one of the few markets where a tiny company is still head-to-head with Amazon In what universe is Flipkart a tiny company? Sure, it's small compared to Amazon but that's because Amazon is a global behemoth.
- blocked_again 8y agoMy friends at Walmart says this is a BS article and asked me to call this out.
- NicoJuicy 8y agoWalmart did buy Flipkart though...
- blocked_again 8y agoDefinitely not for tech.
- NicoJuicy 8y agoSo, what do your "friends" do at Walmart
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- blocked_again 8y agoTech.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- blocked_again 8y agoOn other note do you get money for posting links in hacker news? You posted 5 links in hacker news from this website in the last 23 hours!! cc @dang
- NicoJuicy 8y agoNo, i have a RSS feed with a button "post to HN", which makes it easy. cc @dang
- 8y ago
- bluedino 8y agoWal-mart is lauded for their tech but on a lot of aspects they are just like any other big, old company. On the vendor side, we get bashed by managers that are reading reports that are over a day old, delivered by email. They run quite a bit of stuff on IBM hardware still, which tells me they have a lot of legacy systems running. And they try to outsource EVERYTHING. EDI, order tracking/acknowledgement, their web portal is a clusterf--- that was IE only up until a short while ago. https://imgur.com/mbP35Hy https://imgur.com/mbP35Hy
- jitendrac 8y agoI think the acquisition of flipkart was not for tech, rather it was for the User acquisition, the real and loyal buyers who are proved value users. aside of it, It was also beneficial as flipkart has its own logistic and order tracking system good enough for indian rural areas.
- throwawaywhynot 8y agoI work at walmart eCommerce and this article is just plain bs