4 ms·
Deforestation is a great issue in developing economies. It's something which must be addressed. What's not mentioned is that human population growth is the ma
by mc32 8y ago
Deforestation is a great issue in developing economies. It's something which must be addressed. What's not mentioned is that human population growth is the main driver of this pressure.
Given our abilities to manage disease and such, more efforts should go into educating women in developing allowing them to become more independent and have more control over their reproduction. When people move from agrarian societies to urban, they don't need more than replacement numbers --but in many developing economies the effort to stall growth is overshadowed by other less effective efforts.
China would not be where it is without the great effort (though hamfistedly implemented) it put into controlling growth --it was only necessary to dampen growth while the country caught up economically and now natural forces are effectively resulting in pop stability (unlike India, for example).
- PinkMilkshake 8y ago> China would not be where it is without the great effort (though hamfistedly implemented) it put into controlling growth I would not advocate this authoritarian approach (I'm not saying you are). Part of the solution is what you said earlier, education. But population stabilizes on it's own as a country goes through the Demographic Transition. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_transition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_transition Or for something more light-hearted: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QsBT5EQt348 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QsBT5EQt348
- im3w1l 8y agoThe demographic transition is just a theory. UN have already had to adjust population projection upwards as the curves have not followed the theory as close as predicted.
- SCHiM 8y agoDo you have a reference to this?
- barry-cotter 8y agohttps://www.newsecuritybeat.org/2013/08/demographic-transition-stalled-sub-saharan-africa/ https://www.newsecuritybeat.org/2013/08/demographic-transiti... > fertility decline in Africa has generally proceeded more slowly than in other parts of the world, with several cases of “stalls” and even small fertility increases over time https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/bitstream/handle/10986/22036/AfrDemographicTransitionOVERVIEW.pdf https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/bitstream/handle/10986/2... > While this study looks at lessons from East Asia, Latin America, and the Middle East, Sub-Saharan Africa currently exhibits two unique demographic characteristics. First, it is the only region in the world that is still at a very early stage of the demographic transition. As such, it can learn from other regions that have gone through the same journey to ensure that demographic change paves the way to deeper and more sustainable prosperity. As this book points out, this path is neither easy nor automatic. Success requires actions in differ- ent policy realms that are time-coordinated, adapted to the current level of the demographic transition, and results-driven. The second unique characteristic of the region’s demographic picture is its heterogeneity. While a small number of countries are far along the transition, with fertility rates that are below replacement levels, many others are exhibit- ing surprising delays in the transition in the last 10 years. Some countries are showing very little movement along the natural transition and are stuck at very high fertility rates. These large differences argue for differentiated policies that target different sectors and processes. They also argue for country to country learning and knowledge sharing.
- ElBarto 8y agoWhat China did was their only option. We need to realise that sometimes the "authoritarian approach" is the only option available. There is no other way to put the brakes on steep population growth especially as this is usually linked to culture and education. But education may work 20 years down the line, which is too late for such an issue. The demographic transition is also besides the point as the issue is to stabilise population at a lower level that it would have done 'naturally'.
- adrianN 8y agoThe question is whether the population will naturally level out before or after the last old growth rain forests are gone. We need to empower women in those countries and enable people to make a living in other ways than selling timber and slash-and-burn agriculture. Breeding and selling rare butterflies[1] is one option that I've heard of, but obviously that doesn't scale. I don't find it unreasonable to just pay people for not cutting down rain forests. First world countries have a responsibility here. After all we cut down all our old growth forests and now demand that developing countries don't do the same. [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-kenya-butterflies/kenyans-sell-butterflies-to-save-rainforest-idUSL0378588120070803 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-kenya-butterflies/kenyans...
- Jedi72 8y agoPeople always throw these concepts around as though 'First world countries' is 4 or 5 individual people. I didn't cut down any forest, neither did my family. Perhaps my family trade was training birds in those forests, so I was personally very disadvantaged by cutting them down. So should I have to pay other countries not to cut theirs down now? My point is, these high-level thoughts are theoretically sound but can never be applied to the real world.
- adrianN 8y agoIf you value intact ecosystems and diversity you should definitely pay for them. You can't just tell poor countries not to exploit the resources that they have and hope they comply. Especially when your country's wealth is build on clear cutting, strip mining, and pollution. Even if you think that the past has nothing to do with you, the simple argument that you have money and like Orangutans and they have nothing but a forest should be enough.
- barry-cotter 8y agoChina’s population isn’t stable. Every single Han majority state has below replacement fertility, Singapore, Taiwan, Hong King, Macau and China proper. The post WW2 history of Taiwan strongly suggests that the one child policy was unnecessary. It was brutal, evil and unnecessary.
- ElBarto 8y agoChina's population doubled in 50 years. It is estimated that the One Child policy prevented 400+ million extra increase. It's not possible to draw equivalence between Taiwan and the mainland. The mainland's population exploded after WWII. It has more than doubled since 1950. Using words like 'evil' is emotional, not rational.
- tremon 8y agoGiven the issues we can attribute (at least in part) to overpopulation, why would an at-or-above replacement rate be intrinsically more stable?
- screye 8y agoBeing below replacement rate completely destroys the way our taxation and welfare systems are built. Both rely on having more people contributing taxes than there are leeching off of them. In the 1 child policy, 1 working person is suddenly responsible for the welfare of 2 retirees. Welfare systems would collapse, unless it was rethought from ground up.
- buckminster 8y agoThe work has been done. The total number of children being born each year is already falling. The world population will stabilise. We have serious problems but this isn't one of them.