3 ms·
1. The thing I now dislike about HN are the posts that get upvoted. Yes, eternal September and all, but this has persisted through the slower summer months and
by karmakaze 8y ago
1. The thing I now dislike about HN are the posts that get upvoted. Yes, eternal September and all, but this has persisted through the slower summer months and I don't see it ever returning to the high S/N ratio of the recent past. I find myself more often finding gems on pages 3+ with top posts just being a general feed.
2. Discussions are now becoming rare. So many posts sit on the front page with many upvotes and zero comments.
3. Downvote misuse as mentioned is irksome but not fatal. My problem with them is the UI for them. Upvote if you agree, so downvote symmetrically (and incorrectly) implies disagree. Downvote should really be represented as 'flag' with a type such as factually incorrect, disruptive, adding nothing to the discussion, or other poor conduct (as mentioned in other replies regarding the guidelines).
- Melchizedek 8y agoSo many posts sit on the front page with many upvotes and zero comments. There's a weird mechanism that punishes posts with comments, because they are deemed "controversial". Regarding downvoting - just disable it. What makes the echo chamber even worse is that only users with a certain amount of points are able to downvote. So people who have already avoided being downvoted by others get to effectively police who else amasses the required number of points to be able to downvote. It's a vicious cycle where only a group of like minded people will be able to downvote.
- karmakaze 8y agoThis exactly illustrates the problem with downvote as the UI. Think of the same in terms of flagging unacceptable behavior. Then it makes sense and is positive. Only those who learn what is acceptable get to moderate.
- karmakaze 8y agoTwo downvotes, no comment as to why, either folks think it funny or just won't get it.