4 ms·
I have several thoughts on this: The race adjusted performance is interesting and useful but they're basically using it as a proxy for wealth. Why can't they
by dsfyu404ed 8y ago
I have several thoughts on this:
The race adjusted performance is interesting and useful but they're basically using it as a proxy for wealth. Why can't they just use some metric that directly represents wealth?
If Massachusetts schools are efficiency with money than the system nation wide is far more screwed up than anyone is willing to admit.
That state ranking depends in part on money spent is abhorrent. That should be tracked for reasons that should be obvious but not part of a composite score meant to represents results.
The bit about unions lines up with my anecdotal experience. I worked with the education department in college and they did not hold teachers unions in high regard. If your unions are so bad that college professors at a state school in a blue state gripe about how they hold back progress then I think it's fair to say your union is pretty bad.
- rayiner 8y agoThey're not using race as a proxy for wealth, because the two things are different. There are unique challenges faced by minorities compared to white americans of the same income level. (Remember, Trayvon Martin was a middle class black kid whose dad was a white-collar government worker. A big part of #blacklivesmatter is educating people that black folks face unique problems that aren't subsumed within the larger issue of income inequality. And as to Hispanic students the challenges there are obvious--they're much more likely to be in families that are English as a second language, and also much more likely to move around a lot.)
- dan-robertson 8y agoI’m not convinced that ESL families is the main difficulty facing Hispanic children. I’ll accept that there are disadvantages to Hispanics but having ESL parents seems similar to those faced by almost any other child of immigrants. Perhaps one could argue that due to the visa system, non-Hispanic parents of Americans tend to have higher earning potential? I have no idea whether this is true or not
- rayiner 8y agoDue to the visa system, immigrants in the U.S. are not identically situated to each other. Non-Hispanic immigrants are much more likely to already speak English and have advanced degrees because they come here through visa categories that specifically select for those things.
- xyzzyz 8y agoSure, but their children aren’t. Children of non-Hispanic immigrants that are born in the US do better than US-born children of Hispanic immigrants. While English ability is clearly important in education outcomes, it’s not what makes the biggest difference.
- rayiner 8y agoThe level of English proficiency at home has a large impact on the English-language ability even of children that are born here: https://www.ewa.org/blog-latino-ed-beat/us-students-struggling-english-outnumber-kids-born-abroad https://www.ewa.org/blog-latino-ed-beat/us-students-struggli.... E.g. a quarter of California's children are enrolled in programs for English language learners, even though 93% are native born.
- xyzzyz 8y agoI'd be interested in seeing a causative model for this. My guess is that it's purely Hispanic vs. non-Hispanic distinction. The Hispanic kids grow up in mostly uniformly Hispanic environments, so they have less need to learn English, while latter grow up in more diverse environments. If hardly any neighborhood kids and classmates speak your native language, you need to learn English to communicate with them, while if you're Hispanic, chances are you're growing up in a majority-Hispanic neighborhood and are going to majority-Hispanic school, so you can do mostly fine with only basic English skill. The same thing is true about your parents, so poor English proficiency of kids is not caused by poor English proficiency of parents, but rather both are caused by the same factor.
- leereeves 8y agoWhat unique problem do you think the Trayvon Martin case proves black people face? I'm a middle aged white male and I've been confronted by neighborhood watch and by the police while walking in other neighborhoods. If I had attacked someone who confronted me, as Zimmerman claims Trayvon Martin did, it could easily have ended with a gunshot. I agree that a big part of #blacklivesmatter is claiming that black folks face unique problems, but in order to make that claim they ignore the cases in which white people have the same experiences. As a white person from an impoverished family who grew up in a mixed race inner city neighborhood, I see a lot of wealthy white people who claim my life experiences don't happen to white people. I see Hollywood and the news media making the same claims. I see BLM making the same claims. That's a distorted perspective of life in America that ignores the existence and life experiences of a lot of people. No, it's doing worse than ignoring them. It's actively trying to silence them.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoYou might find this interesting reading: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_New_Jim_Crow https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_New_Jim_Crow
- leereeves 8y agoDo you think I'm not aware of the claims? They're perfectly valid, until they claim that no white people have similar experiences. A lot of privileged people really seem to imagine that all white people are as privileged as they are. And when sociologists lump the population of Beverly Hills and Silicon Valley together with white people born in the ghetto, the resulting statistics mask the experiences of white people who aren't as fortunate. Specifically in response to that link, I believe the overpolicing of America is a serious problem, and the war on drugs is a war on poor Americans. I know it because I've seen it. I know too many people who've gone to jail or prison for drug crimes. But I won't call it "The New Jim Crow" because I've seen it affect too many white people as well.
- tptacek 8y agoNobody is claiming that "no white people have similar experiences". That's a claim you invented so that you could whale on it on this thread. All BLM says is that African Americans face distinct problems as a group, and, obviously, they do.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoHow is Trayvon Martin relevant to this discussion? Are you suggesting that Black people are somehow more prone to violence, after controlling for poverty, and that makes education harder for them? That's a .... controversial line of reasoning.